Journal davidwr's Journal: Essay on capital punishment
Capital punishment is the ultimate punishment. It should be reserved for those who:
* caused a death. The death penalty for treason, rape, or other crimes where no death results is simply cruel and unusual.
* committed their act in cold blood without any mitigating circumstances. The slightest mental illness, the slightest intent not to kill, the slightest other circumstance which, if not present, would have resulted in a non-lethal outcome means life in prison is better.
* is, barring divine intervention, beyond redemption. The slightest acceptance of moral responsibility, even after sentence is handed down, means the execution should not go forward.
* the person would endanger the lives of others if he were incarcerated for life in the most secure prison possible
Very few people are simultaneously immoral or amoral and at the same time not mentally ill.
Of those who are, most can be kept from killing again by incarceration. For some, incarceration in a "supermax" prison may be necessary.
The number that is left is either very small or zero.
Since the combination of these conditions never or almost never happens, it is simply much more efficient to have life in prison than to have a death penalty.
I marked this "Pay no attention to my musings." If this shows up on Firehose then then the 'hose is hosed.
Essay on capital punishment More Login
Essay on capital punishment
Slashdot Top Deals