Beta

Slashdot: News for Nerds

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

First thoughts: Star Wars - The Old Republic

RogueyWon (735973) writes | more than 2 years ago

User Journal 6

I wasn't going to play Star Wars: The Old Republic. I have umpteen other games to play, plus I'm in the process of actually trying to buy a house, sorting out some fairly substantial family issues and having problems with mad neighbours. A new MMO was the last thing I needed. And yet, here I am, with a level 29 Jedi Shadow (tank spec).I wasn't going to play Star Wars: The Old Republic. I have umpteen other games to play, plus I'm in the process of actually trying to buy a house, sorting out some fairly substantial family issues and having problems with mad neighbours. A new MMO was the last thing I needed. And yet, here I am, with a level 29 Jedi Shadow (tank spec).

What happened? The watercooler effect. This is one of those rare games that has a large portion of my friends and colleagues - even those who aren't gamers - talking about it and playing it. This happened with World of Warcraft (though I was too heavily into Final Fantasy XI to get it into it at launch). It also happened when the Wii was launched. It singularly failed to happen for other gaming "events", such as the launch of the PS3 and the 3DS. At any rate, the buzz was great enough - as was everybody's expectation that OF COURSE I would play it - that I ended up giving in.

As I'm only level 29 (with a cap of 50), I've obviously seen next to nothing of the game. There's an expectation these days that MMOs are largely about the end-game and, of course, I haven't even had the faintest whiff of that yet. However, I've seen enough of how questing, levelling and general mechanics work that I feel like I can offer some thoughts.

First things first; World of Warcraft comparisons are, to some extent, unfair. While the basic UI design is lifted straight from WoW (as it was in Bioware's earlier Dragon Age), this conceals a number of often very striking differences from the venerable genre juggernaut. I'm not saying that WoW wasn't a crucial influence on ToR's development, but it is clear that there are a lot of other elements in the game's DNA. I've certainly picked up stuff that feels much more FFXI than WoW in places. There's also quite a bit of stuff - particularly around what you might call the "singleplayer" elements of the game - that hasn't been tried at all before in an MMO. If you've been putting off trying this because - like me - you felt you'd seen all that WoW had to offer, then you may want to reconsider.

The most immediately apparent differences lie in the questing and story structures. In WoW, story has always been a fairly perfunctory thing. For most quests, you get a page of text (that nobody ever reads) and wander off to wherever Questhelper is telling you to go to kill your 12 mobs or collect your 6 mob-spleens or whatever. In ToR, every quest is introduced by a fully voiced cutscene. There's even slightly less use of that old Knights of the Old Republic cheaty get-out of having lots of alien speech which just cycles every so often (though it's not vanished entirely). What this means is that individual quests tend to be longer, more intricate and - in general - more interesting than the WoW equivalents. There are moral choices to make (sometimes with consequences later), companions to woo and even a few major twists. What this means is that while my WoW character was never more than my mute avatar in Azeroth, I actually think about my ToR character as something distinct from myself and find myself role-playing conversation choices in a way that I might in a Dragon Age or a Skyrim, but would never have imagined doing so in an MMO. While WoW had lore, only a small percentage of the players ever really cared about it. For everybody else, it was "those enemies are bad, go smack them". In ToR, I'm always conscious of where I am, what I'm doing and why I'm doing it.

Another big difference between WoW and ToR lies in the difficulty curve. Questing in WoW was trivially easy. Unless you did something stupid, you'd never find anything challenging and you didn't have to know much about your class. So come the level cap, you had lots of newly dinged players only just starting to learn how to play the game. ToR doesn't let you do that. Plenty of quests, including your class's main plot quests, include fights which are actually challenging. Past about level 20, if you don't know how to use your class's abilities to maximise the benefit of their interactions, you won't get very far. Instance bosses actually need tactics - indeed, the second boss in the first Republic instance is a huge block for many players. It's a risky move; WoW's popularity stemmed at least in part from how hard it was to get into. ToR is a much harsher mistress; MMO newbies may find their patience stretched to breaking point, particularly if they step into the group content. Personally, I like it - it makes levelling more interesting and it should reduce the difficulty that players new to the genre have in transitioning from levelling to end-game content. But combined with the fact that levelling is generally a good bit slower than in WoW (particularly than in modern-WoW, after the various nerfs), it makes it clear that ToR is much less willing to serve up instant gratification.

I've seen a bit of the group content. Obviously, I have the benefit of having a good few people I know in real life on the same server as me, though due to varying work, family and social committments, our levels are fairly diverse. For once, I'm at the back of the pack (having been to visit parents over Christmas, and then working between Christmas and New Year). I've also met a few other ex-WoW players in-game. These are identifiable because they actually know what they're doing. However - and I suppose quite impressively - they are in a minority. The game has clearly succeeded in drawing in a lot of people new to the genre, rather than just cannibalising WoW players for a short time (which is what the MMO versions of Lord of the Rings, Conan and Warhammer all did). For the moment, this means an awful lot of clueless newbies - I've had to explain the fundamentals of concepts such as "threat", "crowd control" and "need or greed" quite a few times. But in the long term, I see this as a healthy thing for the game and the genre.

The group quests themselves are generally well designed. The fall, broadly speaking, into two categories. First there are the "heroic" quests. These work more or less like normal quests, but they involve higher level enemies that require 2-4 players to beat them safely (though I've managed to solo a couple of the 2-man quests through very cautious play). These are a lot like the old heroic-outdoor areas that used to be in WoW, until they were patched out somewhere towards the end of the Burning Crusade era. They're fine for what they are - an opportunity to group together with other players, socialise a bit and work to a common objective. But they don't give you anything exciting or different. They're also completely optional - none of them are critical to any of the major quest chains. In a clever twist, they're also repeatable (once per day) - so there's an incentive to repeat them for additional rewards, making it easier to get groups for them.

More interesting, however, are the "Flashpoints". These align broadly with WoW's 5-man instances, though in this case the party size is capped at 4. They vary wildly in size, though on average, they are a bit larger than the standard 5 man instance size that WoW had settled on by the time of Burning Crusade's release. That said, there's nothing on the scale of the old Blackrock Depths. What sets these aside from WoW's instances is that they're heavily story based. There are conversations and decisions to be made during them, granting both social points (ToC's equivalent of faction reputation) and light/darkside points. When a conversation choice comes up, all players in the group pick their preferred option and the game rolls - the winning roll determines the choice. So far, the system has worked extremely well. The flashpoints feel like classic, tightly-focussed small-world co-op activities, rather than the slightly soul-less grinds from WoW. However, while lengthy dialogue is fine for levelling dungeons that will only be done once or twice by most players, I do worry about how it might play in level 50 dungeons that are done far more often. I can imagine that getting old real fast. Flashpoints tend to be trickier than "standard" WoW dungeons, though I do remember Gnomeregan and a few others being fairly tricky back in the early days of WoW.

The crafting side of the game is not that different from WoW. You are limited to one "production" trade and one "gathering" trade. Those work more or less as expected and are functional, if uninspired. What I'm less convinced about is the third profession you are expected to take; the companion quest profession. This allows you - for a fee - to dispatch your companion on a quest to gather more trade materials for you - and this is compulsory if you want to get serious about crafting. Unfortunately, the system is extremely boring. You choose a companion, choose an interesting sounding mission for them from a list... and they vanish. Then they reappear a few minutes later with your rewards. It doesn't help that the text descriptions of the missions often sound more interesting than the actual missions themselves. If you're fighting wamp rats on Tatooine and sending your companion off to negotiate a trade with the Hutts, it can feel very much like you have the raw end of that particular deal.

In fact, now we come to some of the more pronounced weaknesses of ToR. While I do, so far, like this game a lot, it cannot be denied that there is a lot wrong with it. The Auction House is awful. It's horribly crippled compared to WoW's, with what feels like pointless restrictions on functionality. There's also no matchmaking tool to find groups for quests and instances. I know that WoW didn't add one of these until mid-way through the Lich King era, but having played a game with one, it's very hard to get used to having that particular toy taken away. The datacron sidequests are also infuriating. These are hidden items that give the player a permanent boost to stats with no downside - except finding the item. Finding them involves what I can only describe as precision platforming. Now that would be ok if this were a Mario or a Ratchet & Clank - a game with controls designed for precision platforming. It would be ok if it was an Uncharted, with scripting to rescue the player when he makes a minor mistake. But it isn't. This game has WoW controls and WoW movement controls are not precise enough for this stuff. Result: frustration.

To sum up for now, this is a much more polished game than WoW was at launch. It's a less polished game than what WoW has become and that is a problem for it. However, set against this, it offers a lot of interesting stuff that just wasn't in WoW at all. The game seems to have had a good launch - certainly the most successful MMO launch since WoW. The key factor is whether Bioware have the energy, budget and resources to continue to develop it properly.

cancel ×

6 comments

Need an Egdod (1)

PopeRatzo (965947) | more than 2 years ago | (#38581170)

Thank you, RW, for your usual excellent review. I've played a bit of SW:TOR and I agree for the most part.

Something is happening, though, probably a personal change rather than something bigger. I seem to have more trouble buying into a fantasy realm than I used to. I definitely noticed it during my first few levels of SW:TOR. Maybe it has something to do with the fact that I never really felt right about the entire Star Wars universe. Not since I saw the first movies as a lad when they came out. I don't know, it just never struck me as real, despite (or maybe because of) the way the characters and worlds because so ubiquitous in our culture.

I never played WOW, because I didn't try it when it first came out and then got it into my head that I wouldn't be able to catch up. Maybe because I was so busy playing Eve: Online at the time.

Anyway, while there's a lot of good in this new game, I still get the feeling we're a few iterations away from having the kind of games that involve the kind of immersion of a T'Rain (I assume you've read REAMDE. As a sophisticated gamer, RogueyWon, it's a book you really ought to read if you haven't).

Thank you again for taking the time to give us your impressions. I always look forward to your game reviews. There were at least three games (as of now) that I might not have tried had it not been for your year-end wrap-up. If game developers aren't sending you review copies yet, they ought to (but maybe you're too inclined to be honest for them).

Re:Need an Egdod (1)

L4t3r4lu5 (1216702) | more than 2 years ago | (#38595102)

As a recently quit WoW player from vanilla, it's my opinion that you missed the golden age of that game. What we have now is but a shadow of former glory; There is no challenge to the game, and as such no real reward for playing. End-game content is always defeated within the first day (Illidan and LK were both downed on day 1 of BC / WotLK, although LK kill was deemed an exploit). Everything is geared towards making the game easy to access for new players, as it's been haemorrhaging players for a while now and needs to boost subscription numbers. Maybe something good will happen with MoP and it'll go back to the "good old days" of challenging content. I'm not holding out hope, though.

Looks like I'll need to give SW a go! Great review, OP.

Couldnt be explained better (1)

unity100 (970058) | more than 2 years ago | (#38595222)

What this means is that while my WoW character was never more than my mute avatar in Azeroth, I actually think about my ToR character as something distinct from myself and find myself role-playing conversation choices in a way that I might in a Dragon Age or a Skyrim, but would never have imagined doing so in an MMO

A couple of rebuttal points... (1)

fallen1 (230220) | more than 2 years ago | (#38595848)

I'm not sure if you've missed these or heard from someone else in-game and have not had a chance to test them but...

1) You are limited to one crafting profession per character. You are _not_ limited to one gathering trade/profession per character. However, to really utilize your chosen crafting profession you generally need both a gathering trade and a mission trade recommended for that crafting profession.

Caveat: At this time, it seems you could create a DPS character that, with their companion, could easily take 3 gathering skills and supply multiple other characters with their needed material. This would be on the order of "grindy" though.

2) You do not have to sit through the cutscenes/mission introductions/dialogue. The space bar is your friend. If you repeat the initial Flashpoint (Black Talon for us Sith) for instance, you can simply space bar through the conversation and then choose your response - everyone in that flashpoint can do the same, I believe. Or it may be just the group leader needs to, I have not tested the issue yet. My guild always enjoys going through the cutscenes and we do not mind at all going through them again when we have a new person along with us but if we are repeating a flashpoint or other mission with a cutscene that we have seen before, we don't have a problem with skipping the dialogue either.

3) As for Datacrons, if you are having an issue with control it may be mouse sensitivity which can be changed through the interface. I realize after reading your well thought out entry that you are probably a hardened enough gamer to have checked, but I wanted to mention it just in case.

Very nice overview! As a fellow SWTOR player, I enjoyed reading it.

Re:A couple of rebuttal points... (1)

RogueyWon (735973) | more than 2 years ago | (#38596138)

Interesting.

I may have got the wrong end of the stick on 1). Certainly, you can only have one "end point" crafting profession. I hadn't realised that a similar restriction did not apply to the gathering profession. That said, without a mission profession, your crafting profession will only ever be churning out greens (or you'll be spending a lot of money on the auction house).

2) is absolutely true - but good luck finding a group that's both aware of this and happy to skip the cutscenes. Apart from one re-run of the Esseles where I was entirely with people I knew in real life, I've had to sit around for the full duration of the cutscene in every other case. But yes, this may change at level 50.

On 3) my issue is more around the imprecision over jump lengths and air-movement - and also in the game's mechanics for deciding whether it registered your jump command before or after you ran off the edge of the platform.

Nice write-up (1)

IsoRashi (556454) | more than 2 years ago | (#38599850)

Nice write-up. I'm also a relatively old hand at MMOs -- started in college with EQ, then played DAoC, tried my hand at FF XI for a couple of months, and played WoW since basically release. I quit WoW about 1.5 years ago, and only really started playing ToR because friends and family would be playing.

I like that the quests draw you in to the story-line. I've been playing as an evil smuggler, however, and all the side-story stuff has started to become a little stale to me. Right now I'm on Alderaan and it just doesn't make sense why I'm getting involved in all these things. Even the lure of credits doesn't really make sense since I'm on the trail of Nok Drayen's treasure. I finally realized last night that this is why I was becoming bored -- if I was playing a good guy I would be more interested in helping out, but instead I just mash the spacebar and pick the meanest dialog options available.

I'm a little torn on the crafting system. I like that you can send your companions off to gather and do missions -- this means I don't have to fly around and manually gather mats. On the other hand, the timers can be a little prohibitive. For example, if I have only an hour to play tonight then I might only be able to send companions out once or twice depending on the missions. You're also pretty limited in what you can do until you get your ship as you generally want to have your first companion with you. Lately I've found myself playing some other game for 30 mins or so, then logging in to check the AH, send companions out, then log out again.

There seems to be a little imbalance as well in the various crew skills. Slicing, at release, was a killer crew skill. I've read accounts on g+ where people took it just for the credits it could generate and, by the time it was nerfed, had already amassed over 500k credits. I have one guy who has armstech and the weapons it creates are just plain underwhelming. I can make lvl 33 weapons, but all the trainer recipes are green. Why would I use any of those when I can go to a commendation vendor and for ~14 tokens buy a pistol that blows away anything I could make? Meanwhile, my bro-in-law's brother sends me nice blue gear a few times a week -- all stuff that he made with armortech, with recipes he learned from the crew skill trainer.

The reverse engineering system is an interesting idea, but not very reliable. I basically only RE stuff I make to get back the materials (gun barrels excepted). Say I RE a pistol and get a new recipe -- the blue schematic will have the exact same stats as the green one, except it will have a small added bonus (which is randomly selected when you discover the recipe). My smuggler can make a crappy blue pistol that has a tiny amount of defense on it -- a stat that I will never need.

I dislike a lot of the choices they've made so far with the UI. Maybe it's because I haven't modded mine? I'm pretty accustomed to the rather useful interface for WoW and a handful of mods for tracking cooldowns and abilities (mods which, I understand, are now incorporated in to the base UI for cataclysm?). You're right that the AH interface is pretty awful too. I almost feel like they made some UI choices just to be different from WoW, with no concern over whether it was a step in the proper direction. There are still a handful of places where they messed up very basic things. With one of my companions, every time he appears / is re-summoned, this one skill is toggled to on. All his other skills remember their previous state... but not this one. And it's the skill where he pulls the target to him, so not exactly what you generally want as the default for two ranged characters. At least there's no hunter dead-zone. Another one I noticed is that my "show Sith corruption" option keeps resetting to "on" every time I have to load in to a zone. I'm just confused as to how stuff like this made it past basic QA.
Check for New Comments
Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...