Beta

Slashdot: News for Nerds

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Open Source for Enterprise Management?

Cliff posted more than 11 years ago | from the free-software-and-big-business dept.

Businesses 22

acooks asks: "After a recent talk on Open Source software to a class of MBA students, someone came to me with a huge opportunity to use Open Source to manage business processes. What they want is SAP, but for small to medium sized businesses and at a price that a small business can actually afford. Furthermore, they realised that Open Source isn't going to go away anytime soon and that they might as well try to use it to save costs (If IBM is embracing Linux and SAP & IBM plays nicely, then maybe it's worth finding out more about Linux). The questions that were raised basically boils down to this: Is there Open Source software available to manage a business or some of the business processes? Where do you start looking for something like this? I realised that this isn't something that you can quickly download from SourceForge or Freshmeat, so now I'm asking Slashdot."

cancel ×

22 comments

GNU Enterpise (3, Informative)

seanmeister (156224) | more than 11 years ago | (#5834906)

It's a work in progress, but it's there (link [gnu.org] )

Re:GNU Enterpise (1)

ceejayoz (567949) | more than 11 years ago | (#5839382)

If they're going to market to businesses, they really should be more mature than this [gnu.org] ...

Re:GNU Enterpise (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 11 years ago | (#5840276)

Maybe 'Gill' will give them enough money that they can get rid of that hideous monospaced font and those 20 foot deep textfields.

Compiere (4, Informative)

OpieTaylor (144173) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835027)

http://www.compiere.org/ [compiere.org]

"the most popular Open Source business application - usually among the top 10 of the 60,000+ projects in SourceForge"

I looked at it a couple years ago for a grad school project, and the documentation was limited. However, now the technical docs look solid, and there's classroom and on-line user training.

GNUe and Compiere (5, Informative)

hellgate (85557) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835038)

AFAIK Compiere (being FOSS itself) still relies on proprietary backends (Oracle); this was meant to change at some point, though.

http://www.compiere.org/ [compiere.org]

http://www.gnue.org/ [gnue.org]

Also check the Kernel Cousin for information:
http://kt.zork.net/GNUe/index.html [zork.net]

Re:GNUe and Compiere (2, Informative)

plum001 (569312) | more than 10 years ago | (#5839062)

The Open For Business (OFBiz, http://www.ofbiz.org) project on sourceforge uses open standards and provides a great framework for developing CRM and ERP applications for business. They have a good E-Commerce application and are working on other applications. The project uses an MIT license which is very flexible for businesses to create their own vertical applications or tie into existing legacy systems. Developing and interfacing with CRM/ERP applications for several years, I think OFBiz provides an excellent framework to create business applications. I also think OFBiz is a better solution than Compiere because it doesn't require proprietary components. Brett

One size fits none. (2, Insightful)

grunthos (574421) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835046)

Looking for one package that does everything is usually a wild-goose-chase.

Every business has special needs. See the recent discussion [slashdot.org] right here just a few days ago.

Compiere [compiere.org] and SQL Ledger [sql-ledger.org] sound promising, though.

Compiere? (2, Informative)

GOD_ALMIGHTY (17678) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835073)

Not sure if it does everything the poster is looking for. It's more of a financials package (ERP and CRM), but it is targeted at the small to medium business environment the poster asked about. http://www.compiere.org/.

I personally think only the largest businesses are going to use an all-encompassing customizable framework to base all of their business apps on. Most will use pieces that do one thing well and integrate them. All in one types like SAP let things play together nicely but you duplicate effort that might have been done in a more targeted package, assuming no one wrote a SAP module that does this.

Just my $.02

Good news and bad. (3, Interesting)

FreeLinux (555387) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835154)

If you are asking what Customer Relationship Management/Enterprise Resource Planning(CRM/ERP) apps can run on Linux then there is good news. First off there is SAP. There is also Oracle and probably a few others as well, I'm not sure about Seibel.

The bad news is that these applications are prohibitively expensive for Small to Medium Enterprises(SMEs). This becomes a greater problem with the fact that your desire for the application to be Open Source implies that you would prefer free software(wouldn't we all?).

There are a few Open Source projects that have been started to address this need but, they are very small and unlikely to be really helpful or useful in the near future. CRM/ERP apps are huge cantancerous beasts that require a tremendous amount of development effort. In fact, I'm not sure that development will ever end for this type of software.

Now, the really bad news is that our good friends at Microsoft have also seen an opportunity for CRM/ERP in the SME area and are making an effort to fill that void. Recent acquisitions including Great Plains, Solomon and Axapta show that they are aggressively moving into this market and the already have a product [microsoft.com] available.

This new M$ offering will certainly not be free, nor will it be cheap. But, it will be feature rich, powerful and just barely affordable to the SME market. Which all means, further lock-in to the borg.

Re:Good news and bad. (1)

afidel (530433) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835542)

A) Microsoft is irrelevant if they are specificly looking for OS solutions
B)MS is already admitting that they are pricing themselves out of all but the largest of mid-tier client.
C)There are at least two OS products in this field that have been linked to quite a bit in this discussion thread.

Enterprise management? (-1, Troll)

Anonymous Coward | more than 11 years ago | (#5835205)

WTF is that? Do you mean programs to run your warp drives and navigate through the stars? Holodeck programs? What????

OHHHHH. You mean software to run a business. Why the fuck didn't you say that? You're an MBA? You've got pointy hair? OK, that explains it. Thanks.

Not everything is open source (3, Insightful)

spRed (28066) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835377)

The slashdot crowd might not want to hear it, but not every task is suited to OpenSource. Most open source projects are technical in nature, because the people who work on them are techies. No news here.

There are a number of afforable (< $50 a head a month) online service providers for this stuff. I used to work for one. It is hard to compete with a product that has dozens of man years of engineering time honed by hundred of man years of use and feedback.

There is some hope that an open source alternative will eventually match the commercial offerings. Many opensource projects just copy features found in closed source products. It takes a long time before the free versions out last and out innovate their monied competition.

My recomendation to small businesses is pay for one of the existing products, they are good.

If enough free software folk scratch their itch there will be an open source product worthy of use. But as Linus has said of using bitkeeper vs cvs, it is stupid to hamstring yourself by using an inferior product merely for ideological reasons. Of course, only the end user can decide if it will benefit your business more to use a for-pay versus open source project. And don't forget to check freshmeat every once in a while to see if the balance has changed.

Re:Not everything is open source (2, Insightful)

GigsVT (208848) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835433)

It is hard to compete with a product that has dozens of man years of engineering time honed by hundred of man years of use and feedback.

The horse and buggy had dozens of man-years of engineering time and hundreds of man years of use and feedback, and yet you don't see those on the road very much any more.

it is stupid to hamstring yourself by using an inferior product

Indeed. Anyone who would hamstring themselves by using proprietary software, or even worse, an ASP which could go out of business at any time and leave you stuck, is very stupid.

Re:Not everything is open source (1)

itwerx (165526) | more than 10 years ago | (#5839015)

The parent might be trolling but s/he has good points!!

Is this even needed? (1)

pmz (462998) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835456)

Instead of trying to find magical software, why not hire a really good management staff and reward them appropriately? I'd bet the cost is actually lower and doesn't reek of proprietary lock-in, five-year upgrade cycles, added technical support staff, and perpetual confusion over what the system is actually supposed to do.

I say proprietary lock-in above, because I think the ability of an Open Source project to organize and capture proprietary business processes is debatable. Open Source tends to have an outside perspective with respect to commercial business.

And, seriously, what "small to medium business" business processes can't be handed by e-mail and simple internal websites. This can even be done without Oracle (the horror!) or .NET/J2EE (think of the children!).

Re:Is this even needed? (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 11 years ago | (#5840249)

I agree -- this whole business computer thing is a passing fad. Everyone knows that computers are only good for games, IM, and e-mail. I handle all my business' accounting, taxes, and inventory with Outlook Express and some postit notes just fine.

Can you believe that there's even some hyperinflated dotcom called 'International Business Machines' -- I did some research, and it's true -- business computers is the only thing those fools sell. Tomorrow morning I'm calling my broker and shorting their stock.

Talk to your vendor(s) (1)

innerFire (1016) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835733)

You have vendors, right? You really do have money and are trying to buy something, right? Find out from people who know and who might actually have something to offer, like Red Hat and IBM.

If the vendors don't already have such products (and I bet they do), if you voice interest they will be more likely to develop them. For example, Red Hat is selling a separate database package based on Postgres. Certainly, they'll want to sell database applications, too (like ERP). At the very least, they'll direct you to partners of theirs who are developing such things. Just let them know you're interested.

Make it yourself (1)

mnmn (145599) | more than 11 years ago | (#5835829)


There was a GNU project that did that, but I think if you know the workings of your company you can easily run a postgresql database and serve business off it. Reporting tools like crystal reports work well with it being an SQL database, and you can use QT on linux to make simple interfaces for most anything.

Be sure to document everything as you go and restrict permissions for every user, if you go ahead with this, and consider releasing it opensource.

JD Edwards is open source (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 11 years ago | (#5836475)

I've worked at a couple of mid-sized companies that use JDE and I've had no complaints. The older version of the software is in RPG, the newer versions use (I think) C++ or a proprietary language that's pretty easy to get into. Since all the source is there it's easy to make mods and recompile what you need, and there's a pretty big community of friendly users if you have any questions.

What's that? You meant free software instead of open source? Well, I can't help you there...

First Problem is 'scope' (2, Informative)

nurb432 (527695) | more than 11 years ago | (#5837706)

The idea of 'enterprise' systems is rather vague in general. It means different things to different people..

First define EXACTLY what you need, then look at what's available with a *little* bit of looking..
(compiere, sql-ledger, gnuenterprise, nola.. ).

You will find none do what you need, so plan on having someone dedicated for a while to coding the missing component..

Ohio Edge (1)

Kunta Kinte (323399) | more than 11 years ago | (#5841058)

Ohio Edge CRM [ohioedge.com]

Unlike Compiere, doesn't require Oracle.

Check for New Comments
Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...