×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Star Wars Galaxies - Jedi, Vehicles, Speeder Bike Racing

simoniker posted more than 9 years ago | from the bantha-fodder dept.

PC Games (Games) 49

Thanks to GameSpy for their interview with Lucasarts staff about playing as a Jedi in Star Wars Galaxies. The article discusses the powers granted to the newly-unlocked Jedi in this PC MMORPG ("There are over fifty Force powers, ranging from Force Lightning, Force Weaken, and Force Throw, to Jedi Mind Trick, and a variety of lightsaber moves"), and the possibility your Jedi character could be lost forever ("We have partial permadeath for a Jedi. Basically, a Jedi is allotted a certain number of deaths before they lose all progress that character has made.") Elsewhere, player-owned vehicles were enabled in the game earlier this week, and the official SWG page has information on the types, including the X34 Landspeeder, Swoop bike, and Speeder bike, and even documents player-hosted races that are being attempted, showcasing an in-game reproduction of the Mos Espa Circuit from Star Wars: Episode 1.

cancel ×
This is a preview of your comment

No Comment Title Entered

Anonymous Coward 1 minute ago

No Comment Entered

49 comments

The Grind (4, Insightful)

ziggles (246540) | more than 9 years ago | (#7774502)

I don't know why anyone cares about becoming a Jedi. You'll be grinding through professions for countless hours and days.. just so you can get to a new profession to grind through. The game doesn't suddenly change once you're using a light saber instead of a pistol. I don't know anyone who has lasted more than 4 months in this game, even people who usually love MMORPGs get sick of the repetitiveness and lack of incentive to do anything other than grind. Such a pity too.. the Star Wars universe is a lot more interesting than the usual EQ/DAoC type thing IMO.

Re:The Grind (5, Insightful)

kherr (602366) | more than 9 years ago | (#7774583)

I don't understand why people feel a burning desire to max out at each profession by countless hours of grinding. That's why the game loses fun for them. If you just do stuff with your character (run missions, sell goods, whatever) eventually you get the experience to level up. But to make becoming a master your objective would get very old, very fast. No wonder people stop playing.

With the player cities there are more places to go and the vehicles now make it easier to travel. These player communities are where the interesting interactions in the game are. They've also (thankfully) nerfed the creature handler stuff so the game is not so much "creature wars".

Re:The Grind (4, Informative)

YomikoReadman (678084) | more than 10 years ago | (#7778114)

I played for 4 months, never grinded a single profession, and dropped it with 3 masteries, having completed just about all the content available to me. I'd killed a Krayt Dragon, I've killed a Dark Jedi Master. People stop playing for all the reasons the grandparent poster gave. This game simply has no content at all. There are a few buggy, half broken themeparks, a handful of quests, and beyond that, there is 35 professions, not counting the Jedi classes. That is where all the content is, and it is no substitute for a storyline or any quests.

Re:The Grind (2, Interesting)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7785787)

That is where all the content is, and it is no substitute for a storyline or any quests.

And the sad part about this is, Star Wars has a huge universe which could have been used to make plenty of storylines and quests. It's sad that SWG was released before it was done in order to make more money for sony in a certain quarter. This game should have been the MMO that would have brought casual players/non mmo players in.

Re:The Grind (1)

YomikoReadman (678084) | more than 10 years ago | (#7789839)

I totally agree with that. I was a bit iffy on this at the outset, and then they put in the monthly storylines, which were good. However, in 6 months, there have been 2 parts to the monthly story. In addition, most of the monthly story is aimed at combat classes, and are nearly impossible for a crafter to complete. There is a huge amount they could have done, and still can do. It is simply a matter of the development team getting up and implementing it all.

Where are the spaceships? (4, Insightful)

Andy_R (114137) | more than 9 years ago | (#7774699)

I think I'd rather fire up mame and play the original arcade game to get my star wars fix.

Half the fun of the orignal film was the idea of flying around in cool spaceships, having battles, but that seems to be totally missing from this game. So they finally put in the vehicles that should have been there on day 1? All you get is a beaten up hovercar and two motorbikes that the wheels have fallen off.

Get back to me when I can win a souped-up smuggling ship in a game of cards and use it to run empire blockades.

Maybe someday there will be... (3, Interesting)

cgenman (325138) | more than 9 years ago | (#7774898)

Interestingly enough, with the ever-expanding star wars featurelist, it could someday achieve that beautiful glory of the original design doc.

With staying power and adequate funding, who knows how far it could go. If Episode 3 doesn't incinerate the heart of the series that Episode 1 ripped out and Episode 2 stomped on, this MMPORPG could be in development for many, many years.

Re:Where are the spaceships? (3, Informative)

Gothic_Walrus (692125) | more than 10 years ago | (#7780246)

From what I've read, they're planning a space expansion for sometime in 2004. User owned space craft, gigantic space battles, free reign in space...the works.

Be patient, young Padawan...

Re:Where are the spaceships? (1, Interesting)

Lemental (719730) | more than 10 years ago | (#7781091)

Not only that but 16 new planets. Some of them are from the books and some are from the movies. After all, Dathomir is there. Why not have other book/movie planets.

I wanna go to genosis and visit the first historic battleground of the clone wars.

Re:Where are the spaceships? (1)

will_die (586523) | more than 10 years ago | (#7784923)

The tentative date of release for the space expansion is July. However according to devs back at SWG release, 6 months ago, they had not realy started on the space expansion besides some very old demos.
So in otherwords based on the current messed up system and the time schedule do NOT expect anything major. You will probably get a few new planets which do not have the current shuttle service to them, a few different ships, a limited battle system, and paths to follow to get from planet to planet which open into wide battlefield type areas.

Jedi crap (5, Informative)

Drunken_Jackass (325938) | more than 9 years ago | (#7774890)

If you don't know how the developers decided to allow you to unlock a force-sensitive (FS) character - let me give you the lowdown. The "top secret, dynamic, non-random, biological..." method they chose:

You have to master 5 random professions that are assigned at the time of your character creation. That's 5 out of 32. Sound like long odds? Don't worry, the developers thought sooooo hard on this, they figured out a way to give people a leg up. That's right, they placed Holocrons across the game as loot drops on uber characters (well, uber to casual gamers, not really to hardcore grinders) that will tell you 4 out of the 5 proffesions your character must master in order for you to unlock the FS slot.

What does that mean? Well, if you wish to unlock a FS (force-sensitive) slot, you have to grind up to a combat profession so you can solo these holocron dropping MOBS. Then you have to get a holocron (the drops are pretty rare). Then, you have to listen to the holocron on what profession you should next master.

Soooooo, imagine you become a great pistoleer. What happens if your first holocron tells you to be a master weaponsmith? Well, you start the mindless grind to a profession that you are mastering for the sole purpose of filling a randomly assigned profession, so you can be 20% closer to unlocking a FS slot.

Great.

They've basically removed the ability for anyone wanting to be a Jedi on creating a character that they've invested a lot of time personalizing and leveling, because now you have to spend your limited profession points to master wild goose hunt professions.

That's not even mentioning the fact that after you've completed four of the five professions, the holocrons you manage to pick up as loot stop giving hints and you're left blindingly hunting for the one last profession.

It totally sucks. It ruined the game for many players that thought the dev's would be a litle more caring and have a little more thought behind the end-game. It completely de-values the intent and any sense of caring that you may have thought the dev's had for the game.

Bottom line, the Jedi path is bullshit.

Re:Jedi crap (5, Insightful)

Mike Hawk (687615) | more than 9 years ago | (#7775111)

Thanks for the info. Now based on what you said, there are a couple counter-points.

#1 YOU DON'T HAVE TO BECOME A JEDI. Using your great pistoleer example: Be happy as a pistoleer. If you enjoyed the steps it took you to get there and the game as a pistoleer in general, stay that way. The grass isn't always greener, in life or fake life. Its worth repeating, if you aren't willing to bust arse to become a Jedi, don't worry about becoming a Jedi. I imagine it would be pretty hard to become a Jedi in Ultima Online, yet noone there is complaining how hard it is. This brings me to point #2...

#2 Becoming a Jedi should be hard as hell and generally not a good time. Though I am not a hardcore fan of the movies, most of the characters seem pretty unhappy with the situation when they decide to follow the Jedi. They leave their families and loved ones forever. They just pick up and go. This is very similar to the profession issue. You stop what you liked doing and give it up for a tough road to hoe. Great sacrifice = great rewards.

#3 Not everyone should become a Jedi. If it was easy or fun to become a Jedi, everyone would do it. The game would cease to function. It would just be stupid. Now 2 and 3 lead me to #4...

#4 All of this is very consistent with the movie portrayals of Jedi. Other game inconsistencies aside, in the time of the movies (this is the time the game is set in, correct?) Jedi are rare. Being a Jedi in general seems to be pretty miserable. One guy lives in a cave or something, another lives in some swamp. Yeah, woo, being a Jedi rocks!

Here's the deal, anything positive or desirable about being a Jedi is assigned by the individual. I do not play this game but a few guys at work do. They enjoy the game very much and have no desire to become Jedi. Turns out, the Star Wars universe can be just a pretty fun place to run around if one knows where to look.

I'd also like to thank you for perpetuating the stereotype of gamer as whiny baby who wants everything handed to them and considers themself a game design god. You should reevaluate your own priorities in the game if you think the Jedi path is too hard, and maybe in real life if this is how you present yourself in general.

Re:Jedi crap (2, Insightful)

mccoma (64578) | more than 10 years ago | (#7776407)

about point #4
How about the game designer's pick something other than a set of random events, like I don't know - a set of great quests - for the player to become a jedi. 5 random professions seems as far from the movies as possible.

Also, if it miserable to become /stay a jedi, why would I pay money to someone to continue doing it. This is supposed to be entertainment.

Re:Jedi crap (3, Insightful)

Acidic_Diarrhea (641390) | more than 10 years ago | (#7777271)

5 random events seem far from the movies? What event are you basing this on? And how do quests make this any more reasonable?

Looking at it, the movies really don't have that much in the way of how a Jedi is selected to become a Jedi. The only characters from the movies whose training has been portrayed is Anakin and Luke; Luke was mainly selected because of family lineage and events far out of his control demanding that he train AND Anakin was selected to be trainined because of his high level of forceness in his blood. Both of these situations seem quite random to me - I mean, you certainly don't pick your family lineage. Would you rather that in the game when you created a character, there was a random number generator employed to determine whether you had the appropriate inclination to become a Jedi? I mean, if you're basing it on the movies - that seems the most like the movies. Anakin and Luke both picked to become a Jedi but two events out of their control had to occur first - they had to be born with that special Jedi specialness and a Jedi had to be introduced to them so that they could be located and picked - in the Star Wars universe, Jedi are quite rare. If you make it, complete a set of quests and there's no randomness to it, then everyone would become a Jedi.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

mccoma (64578) | more than 10 years ago | (#7783291)

Well, I guess it seemed to me Luke had to go on several "quests" (I hate to use that word for SciFi, it sounds better for fantasy) to learn to be a Jedi. He does go from farm boy to Jedi through a series of adventures. I don't remember him working through 5 random careers - although I sure someone here will post them :)

I guess I don't object to the "randomness of being able to be a Jedi" as much as the "silly 5 career randomness". If only certain characters could become a jedi (some random roll at the start), fine - keeps with Star Wars. But, all other things being equal, my "non-jedi" account better cost less. The Jedi have a much wider range of choices and unless there are some "no jedi" things in the game, it might get a little annoying.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7786148)

If you make it, complete a set of quests and there's no randomness to it, then everyone would become a Jedi.

Not really, if you make it easy with to become a padawan but hard to become a Jedi then not everyone would become a Jedi.

Say for example that Padawans suffered perma-death. So anytime they were killed they would have to start from scratch. On top of that they are clearly marked as Padawans, and can be PK'ed by any other player and have bounties on their heads. Now say they have to finish 30 quests to become a Jedi. That would be pretty hard to do, but at least the path would be laid out for them and it could be done with a lot of hard work. I would say that would be less frustrating and more fair then leveling 4 professions then trying to find a mystery 5th one out of the remaining 27. This might be more like how it works in "star wars real life" but sometimes real life isn't fair..games should be

The real thing it comes down to is should games stay loyal to their source of insperation or should they be fun? To me I think they should always err on the side of fun. I would rather play a fun football game than a realistic football sim. I'd rather play a fun game based on the matrix then one that sticks to it's storyline so much that it takes away from gameplay. I guess it's personal taste, but I always think games should be more about fun than anything else.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

Acidic_Diarrhea (641390) | more than 10 years ago | (#7787675)

I began to read that first paragraph you wrote and realized that I had no interest whatsoever in discussing how to make a better experience in a MMORPG. No offense to you or anyone who plays those things BUT I just can't bring myself to care that much. I'm sure the whole system could be modified in the way you described or the way I described or whatever. Of course, the issue arising out of that is that probably you're going to get just as much complaining as ever. It seems like a lot of the people who are loud-mouthed braggarts online are drawn to MMORPGs and thus will complain about all aspects of the game, however implemented. Draw your own conclusions about how they are in real life. [Uh oh, this post is shifting into being a troll, as diagnosed by Slashdot moderators who love bringing the online pain down on people!]

Anyway, as for the football game point, which I have an interest in, I think there is room for both types of games. I have not played the new NFL Street from EA but I can tell you that I enjoy playing both NBA Street and ESPN NBA Basketball - fun arcade style vs. simulation.

Re:Jedi crap (2, Insightful)

Imperial Tacohead (216035) | more than 10 years ago | (#7782235)

Amen to the fact that you don't have to be a Jedi. Jedis aren't gods. It's just another character class. I think that the emphasis on Jedis stems from the lack of features in the game right now. Given the chance, I'd like to be Boba Fett or Han Solo over Luke Skywalker any day -- problem being that Han Solo ain't much without a ship to fly around in, and the bounty hunting in Galaxies is not as interesting as it might be.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7785983)

Thanks for your post, here are a couple of counter points... on #2 you said.. .#2 Becoming a Jedi should be hard as hell and generally not a good time. Though I am not a hardcore fan of the movies, most of the characters seem pretty unhappy with the situation when they decide to follow the Jedi. They leave their families and loved ones forever. They just pick up and go. This is very similar to the profession issue. You stop what you liked doing and give it up for a tough road to hoe. Great sacrifice = great rewards.

actually, this is only true of Anakin and Luke. Anakin wasn't giving up too much, he was free, but his mother was still a slave. It's not like he would have been living some glorious life had he stayed with his mother. Luke left because his aunt and uncle were killed, if they had not been killed he wouldn't have left. Also, this doesn't take into account all of the other jedi you see training in ep 2. Anyway, back to the game which is what is important. I agree becoming a Jedi should be hard, damn hard. Becoming a padawan should have been easy though. Rather than making people grind it out at random professions to become a Jedi, people should have been able to chose the path of padawan from the start. With a penalty, all padawan would have a nice sized bounty on their heads, would stand out in public, and have perma-death and no protection vs PvP. That would make becoming a Jedi damn hard, and challenging without making people grind away and professions they didn't care about. Plus it would fix the broken and boring bounty hunter profession

#4 All of this is very consistent with the movie portrayals of Jedi. Other game inconsistencies aside, in the time of the movies (this is the time the game is set in, correct?) Jedi are rare. Being a Jedi in general seems to be pretty miserable. One guy lives in a cave or something, another lives in some swamp. Yeah, woo, being a Jedi rocks!

The Jedi are rare in episodes 4, 5 and 6. Who is to say they are rare after that? They weren't rare at the time of the clone wars when there were 100's of them running around. The game could have been set at any time in the star wars universe. To say "Well the Jedi were rare at the time" only holds true for episodes 4, 5 and 6. Before and after then there were many Jedi in the galaxy. Who is to say there weren't more Jedi that were just in hiding during episodes 4, 5 and 6? Leia, Luke, Ben and Yoda hid with no problem from the empire.

Here's the deal, anything positive or desirable about being a Jedi is assigned by the individual. I do not play this game but a few guys at work do.

Well I actually HAVE played the game.

I'd also like to thank you for perpetuating the stereotype of gamer as whiny baby who wants everything handed to them and considers themself a game design god. You should reevaluate your own priorities in the game if you think the Jedi path is too hard, and maybe in real life if this is how you present yourself in general.

I'd like to thank you for perpetuating the stereotype of a fanboy who will stand by a product regardless of how poor/inept it is because you identify yourself with it. You should reevaluation your own priorities if you feel the need to suck up to game designers who don't care about you maybe you are too much of a suck up in real life also if this is how you present yourself in general. I of course don't mean this, I just want to show you how silly/petty your last point sounded.

Re:Jedi crap (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7789096)

Admit it:

You like games that suck.

Re:Jedi crap (4, Insightful)

Godeke (32895) | more than 9 years ago | (#7775126)

While I admit that it seems pretty lame, they did explicit tell people that it would be rare to see Jedi. Frankly, it sounds like they made it too easy, with the holocubes giving 4/5s of the solution.

The fundamental problem with licensed MMORPGs is that everyone wants to be the canonical characters. This was a problem back in the day of text muds - those who build upon a "hot property" (usually illegally, but lets ignore that for now) found that they had unhappy players because everyone wanted to be "character X" where X is the most power, cool and unbalanced character you can imagine. Its like a kingdom made of nobody but kings.

In SWG, they *thought* they could avoid that by making the Jedi slot nearly randomly distributed. 32 skills, pick 5, means your chance of picking correctly is (5/32*4/31*3/30*2/29*1/28) = 4.9 in a million. So some clues were obviously necessary, and they could basically meter the Jedi slots. The holocrons difficult means only those who really want it are going to become Jedi. For the player who wants to be Jedi, this may suck, may force them out of the game and probably isn't worth it.

The real error was revealing the secret formula. Now that it is clear how base and arbitrary the formula is, people aren't happy. Of course not: they all wanted to be Luke, and now that possibility has been taken from them.

Re:Jedi crap (3, Interesting)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7776017)

The system for getting a Jedi slot now isn't what it used to be originally. It used to take into account hundreds if not thousands of different character metrics ( numbers just about everything you do) to decide. Unfortunately this system just required way too many resources for today's technology, so they replaced it with the crap system we have today.

However I must admit that the player cities and vehicles are cool. My swoop bike is very fast :)

Re:Jedi crap (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7778750)

mmmm... speeder pants.

and player cities were the cause of so much greif, complaints, and general hell. Enjoy.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

will_die (586523) | more than 10 years ago | (#7784944)

The holocron were done for one reason, to keep people around so they keep paying the monthly fee; they were also first introduced right at the 3 month period so that thoses starting the game and paying for the 3 months subscription would have a reason to pay another 3 months.
Now that we are at the 6 month period for that they are now giving everyone in a game a free crystal.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7787430)

Of course not: they all wanted to be Luke, and now that possibility has been taken from them

No they didn't all want to be Luke, but many people did want to try out being a Jedi. SWG is like making a transformers game where it's hard to be a transformer. Who the heck wants to be a human in the transformer world? It's the same thing.

Players wanted to play SWG to be a Jedi, a Bounty Hunter, a Storm Trooper, etc. Instead most people are stuck with things like "Entertainer", "Master Chef", etc. Most of the cool professions are broken (ie smuggler, bounty hunter).

A lot of fanboys are saying everyone wanted to be a Jedi, but I'm sure people would have taken up other professions if they were interesting. It's not like you couldn't balance Jedi out if you put your mind to it.

Re:Jedi crap (1)

Godeke (32895) | more than 10 years ago | (#7790717)

Having balanced classes in muds, "It's not like you couldn't balance Jedi" made me laugh. If the Jedi aren't as cool as they are in the movies (i.e., the are comparable to "Master Chef"), then those who unlocked the slot would hate how "nerfed" they are.

No, the reason they were "unlocked" slots was so they could be "munchkin" characters. The balance they are trying to use now is "if you use your skills, people can kill you", and "oh, and as they kill you, you run the risk of losing your progress". Which means a Jedi must only use Jedi skills when nobody is looking, if they don't want to risk being PKed into the ground.

Actually, considering the mythos, that seems acceptable to me. Those who love a challenge will love being flashy and then fending off the challengers. But it places Jedi even further from the orndinary players realm.

Regarding my fanboy status: I don't own Star Wars movies or toys (except a few lego sets for my son). I based "everyone wants to be a Jedi" on my conversations with non hard core gamers: "So, would you every try a game like Star Wars Galaxies?" which is usually responded to with a variant of "Being a Jedi would be cool!".

Not if being a Jedi means months of boring toil to just unlock a slot where you get PKed for smiling wrong.

Umm, Weren't We Promised... (2, Funny)

dupper (470576) | more than 9 years ago | (#7775103)

...a space expansion, by now? Not to mention that the game would not suck?

Damn, I'm glad EBX was out of copies when I went to buy it.

SWG must be revamped (0, Troll)

angryflute (206793) | more than 9 years ago | (#7775729)

Star Wars Galaxies simply needs to be revamped. (For example, they should do a Clone Wars MMORPG where everybody gets at least a couple of chances to be a Jedi.) As for the current incarnation, everybody should be given both a "normal" character and a Jedi -- they must figure a way in which not everybody can use their Jedi online at once. Otherwise, Galaxies is very much of a letdown. Who the hell wants to play one of the boring, ugly peons you see in the background of the SW universe?? It's an insult to the customer's money and time. SWG cannot be totally canonical with the movies -- a movie is a movie, and a game is a game. Lucas needs to get with it and let it go: Allow the developers to do what's necessary to make a good GAME.

Re:SWG must be revamped (1, Interesting)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7776155)

Or, alternatively, they could actually make it FUN to be something other than a Jedi. Right now, there isn't much to do in SWG except grind by killing widlife, or click through crafting. Everyone who isn't a Jedi is hoping that becoming one might make it fun. It won't. You'll just be a lame character in a tedious world who happens to have a shiny sword and a few limited cheat codes available.

Lifting a rock with your mind wouldn't be much fun if all there were in the world was rocks. It'd be the same as lifting it with your hand.

Re:SWG must be revamped (1)

gamgee5273 (410326) | more than 10 years ago | (#7777703)

I agree with you, but you need to realize something: Lucas doesn't care about the games. There was an interview lately where Lucas said he pays no attention whatsoever to the Expanded Universe, only the movies. Thus, the games, books, comics, etc., can do whatever the hell they want and, if continuity breaks in Episode III because of that, well, tough.

So, it's not Lucas. It's Lucasarts, but it's not the man himself. Furthermore, it isn't even Lucasarts developers who made the game - it's Sony Online Entertainment ones who did. So, you darts should be tossed at Lucasarts and Sony, basically. Then find whoever is the Continuity Editor at Lucasfilm nowadays and throw a big one at them...

Re:SWG must be revamped (2, Insightful)

Trillian_1138 (221423) | more than 10 years ago | (#7784800)

First, my understanding is developers are now required by LucasArts to stay true to the SW canon. While this obviously does not happen 100% of the time, the more recent games that have come out either fit within the origonal trilogy (i.e. Rogue Squadrono) or are far enough outside that they don't 'matter' (the Jedi Knight games). There are no longer weird and rediculous games like Rebel Assault or Yoda Quests that throws the player a really weird and random storyline. (Although I really enjoyed Yoda Quests....but that's a different issue.) So while I agree that liberties need to be taken with a game based on a movie franchise (wasn't there a /. thread on this recently?) I believe it's possible to create a true-to-the-move game and still have it be fun.

But lets, for the moment, assume that the developers are told, "You can only have a very small percent of the population become Jedi. You're not allowed to make any major deviations from what was shown in the origonal trilogy" Can't whine about it, it is what it is. So what's the best way to do that? I would agree that the requirement of random character developement is probably not the best way. As others have said, being a Jedi should NOT be easy, or the game would become rediuclous. Iif you want to play multiplayer Jedi Knight, go do that. So I don't think it's unreasonable for the game designers to have been expected to come up with a way to make Jedi difficult to obtain. And it's not totaly stupid that they made it slightly unpleasant.

But...

What others have said is correct: the game should be fun, even if not playing as, or playing to get to the point where you _can_ play as, a Jedi. The game designers were expected to make a game where it WOULD be fun to play as one of the "boring, ugly peons you see in the background of the SW universe." As the opening crawl said, it's a period of CIVIL WAR. It would seem to be an exciting time to be alive, and because the vaste majority of the people in the Rebelion, the Empire, or neither do NOT have the Force, they gotta live their lives too. Even some of the more exciting characters in the movies don't use the Force: Han Solo, Boba Fett, the 'droids, Princess Leia (ignoring her relation to Luke and Yoda's comment; for all practical purposes, in the origonal trilogy she's Force-less) and both the Rebel and Imperial armies...

So rather than bitching that the designers should have ignored canon and created a game that broke as many rules as possible until it became a fun game that was only losely based in the SW universe, you should complain because they had a responsibility to create a fun game WITHIN THE CONSTRAINTS THEY WERE GIVEN. While that's a difficult job, they're being paid to do it. And it doesn't seem an insurmountable goal. The game should be fun for everyone, Jedi or not. And fun whether or not you WANT to be a Jedi. And, in fact, the game should be fun enough that being a Jedi, while cool, isn't the ONLY fun part of the game.

I haven't played SW: Galaxies, but have been following discussions about it in hopes it will eventually appear 'finished' enough that I'll take the plunge. And from what others have said, it's not there yet. Make non-Jedi questing more fun. Allow more player-created content and events. Give people more enjoyable stuff to do! These are the complaints I hear. I hope the kinks get worked out of SW:G, I really do. I very much want to play and hope the game reaches the point where I can do so and love every minute of it.

But don't bitch about what the how the game should have a major rules overhaul. Bitch about how the developers don't seem to be using the rules they have very well.

-Trillian

Re:SWG must be revamped (2, Informative)

will_die (586523) | more than 10 years ago | (#7784937)

What thier is a system called the extended universe(EU) which is the general marketing/legal system where everything from SWG, to the books, to Yoda Games and the Christmas special belong to. Since according to lucas the christmas special does not exist it is not really in thier, but some other EU items do use characters created in the Christmas special so who knows.
So along as you pay the money or get permission you are part of the EU and can do almost anything you want as long as you don't mess around with the films or upcoming offical lucas stuff.
The problem with SWG was not that it did not have room to make itself a good game, look at KOTOR, it is just that it is a very poor game and very poor MMORPG. The reason for that must be placed with the main designer Raph Koster. Now that he has been promoted and is messing up EQ2 they are now removing stuff he designed and talking about implementing whole new systems. Give them 2 more years and it will be a decent shape and out of public beta.

Re:SWG must be revamped (1)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7787513)

o rather than bitching that the designers should have ignored canon and created a game that broke as many rules as possible until it became a fun game that was only losely based in the SW universe, you should complain because they had a responsibility to create a fun game WITHIN THE CONSTRAINTS THEY WERE GIVEN.

But there wasn't a constraint on when they needed the game to occur. They could have made it between episodes 1 and 2 and had plenty of Jedi. The argument could even be made that not all the Jedi or potential Jedi were killed between episodes 3 and 4. If Ben and Yoda could hide from the empire, why couldn't others? The idea of there being a small amount of Jedi in SWG to stick to cannon is BS by the developers/marketers. I'm betting it was strictly a marketing decision to make Jedi rare.

advertising on the box that you could become a Jedi while you couldn't actually do it ingame for months (the code wasn't activated) shows what kind of scam SOE is running with this game.

I wouldn't even argue that Jedi shouldn't be rare, but it should be easy to be allowed to train to become a jedi (ie to become a padawan) but hard to become a Jedi.

MOD PARENT UP! (1)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7787531)

This isn't a troll, it's the truth. Playing a Peon in the Star Wars Universe is worthless. The focus should be on gameplay, not cannon which is broken in SWG numerous times anyway. How many times in Star wars did you see someone wondering around with a regular axe as a weapon? Bone Armor? Uggg.

Re:MOD PARENT UP! (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7790769)

Everytime I saw a Gamorrean!

And why do you say "Uggg" ?

You some sort of Gamorrean hater?

Just a quick mention (3, Informative)

aztektum (170569) | more than 10 years ago | (#7776279)

To clarify a point that the blurb muddled (played the first couple months quit from lack of time. it's fun if u have enough friends.) anyway, to unlock the Jedi slot you have to take your regular character and get them on a specific (seemingly random from most accounts) career path.

When you unlock a FS (force sensitive) character slot, you create a character that you level up through the Jedi tree. This Jedi can die after I think 3 or 4 deaths (regular character slots can be cloned and blah blah Jedi cannot.). However you don't LOSE the FS character slot. You do however have to create a new Jedi (you start sub padawan I believe, but this is 2nd hand from Sept, it could have changed by now). Unless you reach Jedi Master, then you become a blue glowy, but what impact you can have on the game, I dunno.

I don't see a big problem with the way it works. It keeps to the idea there aren't a million true Jedi around during the OT, however I'm sure the Galaxy is full of force sensitives during the time period.

Slightly Off Topic: I was thinking of buying a 30 - 60 day game card just to check out the new features, what I'm really lookin' for is a MMORPG that players run on their own. Setup your own servers and play with friends, like NWN Persistent worlds, but gameplay more along the lines of Zelda games or FF Crystal Chronicles. Anyone know of such a thing?

Re:Just a quick mention (4, Informative)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7776570)

There's always the Everquest Emulation software. It lets you play Everquest without connecting to Sony's severs or having to pay a monthly fee. The folks at EQEmu [everquestserver.com] have been doing a fine job for about 2.5 years now. It's still in development but enough is completed to enjoy playing on a few of the servers. All the code has been reverse engineered by packet sniffing pretty much everything. Just need Everquest classic which I believe is offered as a free download on Sony's servers or just about free at any software store.

Re:Just a quick mention (1)

EvilSporkMan (648878) | more than 10 years ago | (#7776832)

I can't find this free download - could you provide some directions? You can order the game for $0.00 off the store at www.everquest.com, but I don't want to pay S&H.

Re:Just a quick mention (3, Informative)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#7777849)

http://eqlive.station.sony.com/support/tech_suppor t/ts_new_patcher.jsp

you will find the link on this page. just grab the exe and it will automatically download all of the files you need.

FYI, i don't believe the emulators work with the latest patch. SOE usually throws in some code that renders the emulators inoperable until they are fixed.

Re:Just a quick mention (1)

YomikoReadman (678084) | more than 10 years ago | (#7778131)

First off, there is a lot more than a random profession path assigned by Holocrons. Second, once you have unlocked the FS Slot, you make your char, which starts as a Jedi Initiate. Around 10 Million XP later, you can be a Padawan. Around 3 million more gets you to the Jedi Knight tree. 20 more million and you are a Jedi Knight, and if you are still alive at this point, you are the closest thing to God. If you are still alive, and not hunted by every BH on the server that can get the missions for your head on a stick, around 40 million more XP gets you to Jedi Master. If you die your third time after that, you simply get reset back to Initiate, loosing all progress. The whole "Blue Glowy" Concept was removed about 2 months ago.

Just Buy One On eBay (0, Troll)

molafson (716807) | more than 10 years ago | (#7776644)

Avoid hundreds of hours of "tedious" game play. Cut to the chase and buy a Jedi character on eBay. They'll be available sooner or later. Or you could just not play the game, I guess.

Bah... (1)

ReverendBobtheJunkie (716771) | more than 10 years ago | (#7776645)

To be honest, if I could pilot an X-Wing out of the box, I'd buy the game. From what I've seen, MMORPG's are just glorified chatrooms. Galaxies doesn't look any different to me from any other MMORPG. Booooooooriiiiiiiinnnngg.

Re:Bah... (2, Insightful)

suyashs (645036) | more than 10 years ago | (#7777000)

Actually, FFXI is a great MMORPG...it has things for you to do other than level...

Re:Bah... (1)

JavaLord (680960) | more than 10 years ago | (#7787548)

Actually, FFXI is a great MMORPG...it has things for you to do other than level...

like chat?

jedi-schmedi (1)

klokwise (610755) | more than 10 years ago | (#7785009)

ok... i haven't played the game, or in fact read anything about it but it seems clear that becoming a jedi is a pretty big goal for people.

however, tell me something: was han solo a jedi?

NO, of course he wasn't. who wants to wander round the universe in a bathrobe and a beard anyway. give me the "millenium falcon" and trousers with a nifty stripe or two down the side, that's a real goal.

lack of jedis (1)

schapman (703722) | more than 10 years ago | (#7787952)

i dont see why there shouldnt be lots of jedis in the game.. When i was playing jedi knight 2.. the best part of the game was light saber battling... To get me to play the game.. I think they should have twisted the reality of it so that all the professions could have force powers to a certain degree (jedi knights fighting... healers... even smugglers and pilot types be unreal at flyign (when it FINALLY gets put in the game) I'd rather play a game where you have 10 different classes of characters with different force strengths in different areas partied up against another 10. They should have used the big battle at the end of episode 2 as an example... lots of jedis running around fighting/jumping/blasting is fun... being an entertainer in a bar.. or a chef... is not. They really should have focused on the good parts of the Star wars Galaxy and left out the bad.

Re:lack of jedis (1)

Nohbi (720695) | more than 10 years ago | (#7788504)

I so bloody agree with this! As part of the books after the movies there were tonnes of Jedi who were something other than just solely Jedi. Some of them gave up their prior training, but most went back to it sometime during their Jedi training keeping their now trained force powers and went back to doing what they had done but are now better at.
Check for New Comments
Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Sign up for Slashdot Newsletters
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...