Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Audio Players for the Vision Impared?

Cliff posted more than 10 years ago | from the music-for-those-who-aren't-quite-blind dept.

Music 27

Panz asks: "Over Easter my 86 year-old grandmother asked my parents to help her buy a CD player. Normally, there would just be a technology barrier to overcome. Unfortunately, my grandmother has macular degeneration which prevents her from using traditional consumer electronics. What, if any, low-vision friendly CD/MP3/audio players are available? Is there such a thing on the market?" What CD/MP3 players have interfaces suitable for people who have less-than-stellar eyesight? Features that would be nice to have would be backlit displays, and larger than normal text displays.

Sorry! There are no comments related to the filter you selected.

Not to be a jackass... (0)

Anonymous Coward | more than 10 years ago | (#8890784)

But a record player would be perfect. It's really easy to see the records, and you can feel where to place the needle. Not to mention you don't have to push a button to play on most models, since it comes on when you move the arm.

Re:Not to be a jackass... (1)

dotgain (630123) | more than 10 years ago | (#8894539)

Surely a record player with a simple "Go" button (they do exist, it automatically cues the needle and starts playing) would be _much_ easier for a "granny" to use.

I still don't think you're serious, though. It's harder to put the records away, clean dust off them etc..

Why do you need to see? (1)

Tom7 (102298) | more than 10 years ago | (#8890807)

I have a simple MP3 player with a display so crappy that I never look at it. Basically, there's play/stop, forward and back, and volume controls--all of which can be found by touch--what else do you need?

I really should let Mr. Obvious whore karma here, (1, Troll)

orthogonal (588627) | more than 10 years ago | (#8890808)

This is rather obvious, but, since you don't indicate this needs to be portable...

Get her a PC, and run Winamp at its built-in double sized setting on a low resolution monitor.

And then do her a real favor, and rip all her CDs so she doesn't have to bother with changing the CDs.

Re:I really should let Mr. Obvious whore karma her (1)

Xaymot (754751) | more than 10 years ago | (#8919680)

Old People + PC = victimized or confused old people

Archos / Rockbox (4, Informative)

ibbey (27873) | more than 10 years ago | (#8890875)

The Archos Jukebox Recorder [amazon.com] with the Rockbox [rockbox.haxx.se] open-source replacement firmware has several features designed for blind [uark.edu] . I haven't used them, so I can't comment, but you might try posting a question on the rockbox list for further details.

Re:Archos / Rockbox (2, Informative)

ZenCrawler (149867) | more than 10 years ago | (#8892166)

I use a jukebox FM recorder with rockbox / talkbox installed.

The system works well in speaking out menu options, and can spell/speak a folder name if you record one. The rockbox system also has user defined fonts and you can create custom what's playing screens to use an ultralarge font ( there are tons of fonts ranging in sizes from 10 lines fit on the screen, to 1 line of text takes up the screen ) to make it easier for her to see what is playing/browse the files.

However the buttons on archos jukebox/recorder products are small, and not really touch defined all that well. Also rockbox has current method of limiting access to menus/options in case an incorrect button is pressed. Not to mention the frail nature/high cost of a hard drive based solution.

How about Fisher Price? (2, Interesting)

Cpyder (57655) | more than 10 years ago | (#8890920)

Altough intended for kids, they usually have got huge, colourful buttons. I don't think this one [fisher-price.com] has got a display, but at least it hasn't got tiny buttons. Good luck!

DVD player (3, Insightful)

cybermace5 (446439) | more than 10 years ago | (#8890922)

Most DVD players these days will play just about anything, including MP3 CDs and audio CDs. They are also very inexpensive, and tend to have more or less readable large displays, given the fact that they work on a TV.

portable/cd walkmans (2, Informative)

next1 (742094) | more than 10 years ago | (#8890963)

the key here could be to go portable.

my panasonic cd walkman has 7 buttons: ff, rw, play, vol. up/down, stop and an eq button.

you don't even need to look at the display - all it does is display track number, eq settings and batteries.
i often find i use the controls just by touch.

stand alone cd player units or small shelf systems etc have more options, remote controls, etc. so would be more confusing and harder to use with poor sight.

Remotes (3, Insightful)

hswerdfe (569925) | more than 10 years ago | (#8891000)

any thng that works with a good remote.

Remotes are Amazing...they are designed so you don't have to look at them you can feel the buttons. and know where to press.

except the pesky EJECT button....which is missing from most remotes.

other than that simple sugestion I am usless to you.

Re:Remotes (1)

Cyno01 (573917) | more than 10 years ago | (#8892197)

They dont put eject on remotes since if your ejecting something they asume your going to go to the unit and take it out. On that note, if you hold down stop on my universal remote it ejects the dvd, but theres no button to put the disc back in the case and the case back on the shelf...

Consider a talking-book player (3, Interesting)

Andy_R (114137) | more than 10 years ago | (#8891026)

If this is a degenerative condition, you might want to consider products aimed primarily at the blind or partially sighted, such as a talking book player - in Britain these can be bought from the Royal National Institute for the Blind here:http://onlineshop.rnib.org.uk/display_product .asp?prodid=2169

Re:Consider a talking-book player (1)

taylortbb (759869) | more than 10 years ago | (#8891807)

In Canada you can get a Victor (I think, anything designed to play DAISY talking books should work though) talking book player from the CNIB (Canadian National Institute for the Blind), www.cnib.ca (you can get the same players from others in different countries). While they are designed for talking books they also play audio CDs, they are designed for people that are completely blind so they have VERY large buttons that are all shaped differently. If she is legally blind you may be able to get one for free.

A good remote might be a better choice (2, Informative)

Unholy_Kingfish (614606) | more than 10 years ago | (#8891312)

You might even want to consider a regular name brand CD player, and get a good universal remote with a big LCD screen that can been seen easily. My father has the poor eyesight and a good remote goes a long way. Even if it doesn't light up, good tactile design makes all the difference. He can't see most LCD's so I made sure that he has a remote with different shaped buttons that can be felt easily. Check out http://www.remotecentral.com [remotecentral.com] for reviews.

Wi-Fi MP3? (0, Troll)

Christ-on-a-bike (447560) | more than 10 years ago | (#8891397)

Does she live near a Wi-Fi network? If so a Squeezebox [slimdevices.com] might do the job. It has a nice big bright display, and no need to change media.

OTOH she will need someone to set it up to play things she likes, and the remote may not be very usable. (Could be replaced.)

I don't understand the problem... (2, Interesting)

FFFish (7567) | more than 10 years ago | (#8891760)

What's the challenge of using a CD player?

You plug the CD Player into the back of the amp. You punch the amp's power button, the CD player powers on. You put the CD in, bump the drawer closed, and it plays. Punch a button, and it ejects. I rather doubt your gramma is going to be skipping songs and such, so the other buttons are irrelevent.

Paint the front of the tray red, paint the eject button bright yellow.

If you can't find a CD player that works as I describe, I've got an old Toshiba player that I'd probably be willing to donate to her, if you pay shipping.

Check out your local Frys (2, Insightful)

zulux (112259) | more than 10 years ago | (#8892049)



There was this line of brightly colored DVD players designed for kids near the Kareoke section. It had only a few, large, high-contrast buttons.

Would be great for the hard of sight as was onlt $60 or so.

While you're getting a music player - (1)

lightspawn (155347) | more than 10 years ago | (#8892186)

Remember the huge amount of non-music audio material available (say, from libraries, usenet, www.audible.com and www.rusc.com (to name but two)etc).

With those in mind, you may want a player that can also save your place in audio files, hopefully automatically, ideally for every directory. Do any MP3 CD players do that?

Hmm? (1, Troll)

pauldy (100083) | more than 10 years ago | (#8892310)

IANAL however, the apprent new american way is to bust out a copy of the ADA and sue, sue, sue.

There is another part of me that also says uhh GOOGLE.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=U TF -8&q=mp3+player+for+the+blind

Cost effective solution... (2, Insightful)

paploo (238300) | more than 10 years ago | (#8892796)

A good idea that would also be more cost effective than doing something like buying her a whole computer just to play CDs (to which a computer would create more problems for her than it would solve) would be a two step solution:
1. Find a CD player with the least amount of buttons on the front. It should also have the biggest buttons possible.
2. Colour code each of the buttons (and if possible, texture code them too).

Now you'll have to teach her how to use it in terms of things like: Press the red button to open the tray and press the green button to play the disc, but that isn't so bad.

HAL Home Automation (2, Interesting)

skinfitz (564041) | more than 10 years ago | (#8893165)

There is a product called HAL Automated Living [automatedliving.com] which using the optional Digital Music Center [automatedliving.com] addon may be ideal.

Basically you have all your CD's ripped into HAL's own playback program, but its all controlled by voice. You can either have it listening in rooms, or it can be controlled using the phone. It does other stuff as well like turn on the lights / TV / whatever you like etc. so may be useful overall.

I seem to recall an opensource type home automation system based on Linux so that may be worth investigating also.

Best of both worlds? (2, Interesting)

zcat_NZ (267672) | more than 10 years ago | (#8893410)

Verne uses his Linux computer with speech synthesiser to play his audio (mostly the soundtrack of science and space-related TV programs from Discovery channel, which he records via cron jobs since they run them at stupid hours)

The output from the computer is also fed into a small FM transmitter, so he can use an FM walkman or portable radio if he wants to listen while moving around. Unfortunately, there's no way of controllingthe audio thts way (ie skipping the ad-breaks)

Total cost == most of this stuff was being thrown away :)

Pretty much anything... (1)

joto (134244) | more than 10 years ago | (#8893817)

Buy a cheap no-brand CD-player with a large PLAY and EJECT button. The other buttons are there mostly for geeks.

The Archos Jukebox Recorder WITH RockBox (2, Interesting)

Catharsis (246331) | more than 10 years ago | (#8894283)

Recently, the Rockbox Open Source firmware replacement added voice support.

Considering that the rockbox firmware (which completely replaces the original (crappy) firmware) is free, multi-lingual, and has optionally enlarged fonts, I'd say go get one!

The Jukebox itself has a battery life of around 10 hours, and comes in 10-20GB versions, last I checked. Archos has recently been phasing these ones out of production, so you can find them cheap here and there, and off ebay.

Requisite reading:
Rockbox! [rockbox.haxx.se]
Archos [archos.com]

It also works with the Neo MP3 player which I don't have a handy link for.

Never look at my MD player (0)

op00to (219949) | more than 10 years ago | (#8894781)

It's in my pocket, bag, jacket, whatever. I never look at the display. I never look at the controller when I switch tracks, change volume or stop/start. What else does she need to do? Why is this an issue?

one that doesn't cause it (1)

Russ Nelson (33911) | more than 10 years ago | (#8897916)

Hell, I just (xmms) want an mp3 player (xmms) that doesn't CAUSE (xmms) eyestraing (xmms).
Check for New Comments
Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?