Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Facebook To DEA: Stop Using Phony Profiles To Nab Criminals

Antique Geekmeister Re:First (227 comments)

> Laws and customs are irrelevant, as I criticize those frequently

This is precisely what I referred to. If they were irrelevant, there'd be nothing for you to criticize.

If you want to draw legal or political conclusions based on your personal utopic ideal, please make that clear. Because in the real legal and political world, it doesn't work. There is _no_ human society where those in power do not set boundaries on the use of recreational chemicals.

yesterday
top

Facebook To DEA: Stop Using Phony Profiles To Nab Criminals

Antique Geekmeister Re:Too Easy (227 comments)

It used to be the House Committe on Un-American Activities hunting Communists. Before that, the Axis powers. Before that, rum-runners. Before that, the Anarchists.

There is always some group being pursued for political or criminal activity and innocent people crushed in the net used to catch them.

yesterday
top

Facebook To DEA: Stop Using Phony Profiles To Nab Criminals

Antique Geekmeister Re:First (227 comments)

They certainly have the right when "in loco parentis" to make medical and lifestyle choices for children or for those incarcerated. There's also a great deal of long established political and legal right to prevent fraud. So please, do not throw around absolutes so carelessly when discussing law and custom.

yesterday
top

Help ESR Stamp Out CVS and SVN In Our Lifetime

Antique Geekmeister Re:Not a religious war, but it sounds retarded ... (241 comments)

The part about ESR wanting to transform large public repositories to git, I understand. I only meant to explain why someone would want to take the original step of transforming a CVS repo to Subversion.

yesterday
top

Help ESR Stamp Out CVS and SVN In Our Lifetime

Antique Geekmeister Re:Not a religious war, but it sounds retarded ... (241 comments)

> Why would one in his sane mind convert from CVS to SVN?

Because Subversion really is "CVS done right". It scales much, much better, it's much easier to administer and manage, and it has much better support for large centralized repositories with limited access to specific parts of it for specific developers. My transformations from CVS to Subversion have been quite straightforward, except where developers manually edited old CVS files in the repository itself and broke things years previously.

If you need the local flexibility and to have source control access when disconnected from your central repository, the 'git2svn' interface has also been invaluable.

2 days ago
top

BBC Takes a Stand For the Public's Right To Remember Redacted Links

Antique Geekmeister How to find the articles (109 comments)

Deleting the Google links is a quite serious hindrance to scholarship and informed research today. One may as well put it here (with due credit to Douglas Adams for writing this.

        "But look, you found the notice didn't you?"

        "Yes," said Arthur, "yes I did. It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the Leopard'."

3 days ago
top

Cisco Exec: Turnover In Engineering No Problem

Antique Geekmeister Re:Cisco is just like the rest of them (148 comments)

>but when you apply for them you get a response that the job doesn't exist

Oh, dear. This is a quite old trick. It's even more fascinating when they say "we already have candidates", but when your colleague with a different age, gender, or citizenship applies with similar credentials at the same time their application is accepted for review. The classic example of this is tuning HR requirements to only hire H1B candidates, as shown at:

                            https://www.youtube.com/watch?...

4 days ago
top

Cisco Exec: Turnover In Engineering No Problem

Antique Geekmeister Re:Folks this is what happens with bad leadership (148 comments)

> They were suffering from price competition

Not just price competition: they were also suffering profoundly from fraudulent Cisco hardware.

          http://www.crn.com/news/networ...

Not only does it cost Cisco profits to lose the legitimate sale, but it costs them profoundly in customer support for the purchasers of fraudulent Cisco hardware. And Cisco support is a very large business cost to Cisco.

4 days ago
top

Cisco Exec: Turnover In Engineering No Problem

Antique Geekmeister Re:My company (148 comments)

Goodness, are you hiring? I'm doing a lot of partnership consulting with environments that have good people that have been trying to fix things for years. We respect them profoundly for their input and do our best to make sure they get full credit. But there is sometimes political infighting to get the work done and they wind up as sacrificial lambs. I'd love to send some your way: I wish _I_ could hire them, but my team is pretty well staffed and we often have non-poaching agreements.

4 days ago
top

Cisco Exec: Turnover In Engineering No Problem

Antique Geekmeister Re:The essence of enterprise (148 comments)

> Let me try to bring some perspective into the discussion. Lest somebody misunderstand, the very essence of an enterprise (any enterprise) is that it is a bundle of labour and capital whose essential structure and identity is independent of and more persistent than the labour it employs. The identity behind its labour component is no more important than the identity of its capital component.

I'm afraid, sir or madam, that your very opening statements show exactly why engineers will disagree with the entire rest of your statement. You've redefined a common word with a well understood social and legal meaning. Your definition reflects a business school philosophy that does not match either the common or the legal meaning. And it breaks down very, very quickly in the real world.

> It is for this reason that any contemporary HR policy is aimed at (and this is important) divorcing the work from specific individuals.

Nonsense. This guarantees failure in the long run for a tech business. It can work for Wal-Mart or even McDonald's or even non-technologically innovative business, such as spam advertising and domain squatting. There are profound evolutionary economic pressures against it for the more interesting or leading edge technologies. Networking tools and hardware, lab instruments, software virtualization, and systems security are examples that require insight and mastery to improve designs and remain effective and profitable..

> So it's up for debate really, and this isn't a new debate. It's a debate about a basic balance in our society that needs to be realigned from time to time.

And it's vital to know what the debate is really about. Please do not try to redefine basic terms in ways that obscure the actual debates. It's framing the question in a way that is misleading and helps prevent understanding of the underlying problem.

4 days ago
top

Federal Government Removes 7 Americans From No-Fly List

Antique Geekmeister Re:That whole list (124 comments)

The existing TSA has not presented a single successful prosecution, nor any "terrorists" successfully blocked by the terrorism watch list. The effective change in security has been the change in behavior of on board passengers and crew who no longer wait for the plane to land in control of the hijackers, and simple steps like better cockpit doors. There's little if any evidence that the enhanced check-ins are anything but security theater.

I've flown through dozens of airports since 9/11. Much like those attackers, I could easily pick the one with the worst security to stage a demonstration of just how simple it is to get weapns past their security.

about two weeks ago
top

Federal Government Removes 7 Americans From No-Fly List

Antique Geekmeister Re:What happens with no ID? (124 comments)

> the real cost is showing up to be photographed and present whatever records are required.

This is often not a small cost for someone on limited income, trying to take care of children or hold down a job with medical issues, long commutes, or poor transporation. Voter ID laws and poll taxes have a terrible history, and have been part of blocking poorer Amercians, especially black Americans, from being able to vote since the end of the US Civil War.

about two weeks ago
top

FBI Says It Will Hire No One Who Lies About Illegal Downloading

Antique Geekmeister Re:Lying, not downloading. (578 comments)

> The FBI is barring you from employment for _getting caught lying to them_.

"Fixed That For You".

If you commit illegal acts, need to lie about them, _and cannot beat a simple polygraph_,, I'm afraid you have no role in modern federal agencies.

about two weeks ago
top

Fusion Reactor Concept Could Be Cheaper Than Coal

Antique Geekmeister Too bad there's no fuel (315 comments)

The supplies of deuterium and tritum for powering all existing fusion reactor designs are far, far more difficult to harvest and supply in bulk than fossil fuels or solar. As best I can tell, the available supplies of those fusion fuels is limited by the production from ordinary fission reactors. Since the last large scale refiner of deuterium from other sources went out business in 1997, it's not an economically viable resource. Essentially, if we first scale up our fission power to many times its current volume, we could use the byproducts to fuel fusion reactors. Their maximum output would be only a few percent of that of the fusion reactors required to fuel them in bulk,

Unless someone works a way to fuse plain hydrogen in bulk, efficiently, there is no economic point to fusion energy research. The only source of bulk fuel for it is the solar wind. If you've got large scale fusion fuel collectors in orbit, simply collect the solar energy directly and cut out the very expensive, quite radioactive middleman of fusion fuel.

about two weeks ago
top

Lennart Poettering: Open Source Community "Quite a Sick Place To Be In"

Antique Geekmeister Re:Systemd (993 comments)

I do believe you've forgotten SELinux and requiring passwords for your particular tool.

about two weeks ago
top

First Birth From Human Womb Transplant

Antique Geekmeister Re:Adopt! (120 comments)

I must say that it is _completely_ ethical to discuss adoption with fertility patients. Depending on the medical issues, they can be dangerous for the mother and the fetus, draining for both parents, and hideously expensive whether or not covered by insurance. It is the doctor's role to explain the _options_ and their consequences.

There are many equivalents. A lifestyle change can often be more effective treatment than the most extensive medication or surgery, whether it be moving to a better climate to ease asthma, moving to a less sunny climate for people with a history of skin cancer, giving up smoking, getting exercise and improving diet for someone with early diabetes, getting enough sleep, etc. Discussion of lifestyle and the medical consequences of it is part of a doctor's responsibility.

about three weeks ago
top

First Birth From Human Womb Transplant

Antique Geekmeister Re:Amazing progress... (120 comments)

> I Doubt any kind of genital surgery was common in the 19th century

I'd certainly agree that the transplantation or reconstruction of working sexual organs was unavailable. But what, precisely, would you call castration, circumcision, clitorectomy, C-section, or genital piercings? Even abortions and surgical assistance with cysts, tumors, and physical trauma all existed, through they would have been emergency treatments rather than scheduled treatment.

about three weeks ago
top

The $1,200 DIY Gunsmithing Machine

Antique Geekmeister Re: the solution: (651 comments)

You've a point about state law. I was admittedly referring to federal law.

about three weeks ago
top

The $1,200 DIY Gunsmithing Machine

Antique Geekmeister Re:the solution: (651 comments)

Guns can be _extremely effective_ at changing governments, ranging from assassination of critical leaders to armed revolt. The assassination of Arch Duke Ferdinand of Austria triggered World War I, which reshaped Europe and governments and economies around the world.

about three weeks ago

Submissions

top

Twitter discards client UI community

Antique Geekmeister Antique Geekmeister writes  |  more than 3 years ago

Antique Geekmeister (740220) writes "Twitter has just decided to discard the community of developers who've created interesting, innovative, and exciting to start-up company applications. The announcement at http://groups.google.com/group/twitter-api-announce/browse_thread/thread/c82cd59c7a87216a?hl=en shows that they intend to switch from the "bazaar" model of development to the "cathedral", with much tighter control of user interfaces for "security" and "consistency"."
Link to Original Source
top

Oranges with THC Bio-Engineered

Antique Geekmeister Antique Geekmeister writes  |  more than 5 years ago

Antique Geekmeister (740220) writes "A biochemist, Irwin Nanofsky, irritated by the confiscation of his family car when his son was caught with drug paraphernalia in 1984, has wreaked biological revenge on Florida law enforcement 24 years later by developing, and releasing, fertile orange seeds for oranges that contain the major active ingredient of marijuana http://www.facebook.com/ext/share.php?sid=57839045341&h=3VR1O&u=IDqVi.

Revenge is a dish best served cold, in a tall glass, with a plate of waffles."

Link to Original Source

Journals

Antique Geekmeister has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?