Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!



Living On a Carbon Budget: The End of Recreation As We Know It?

Dantu Re:Lots of cheap carbon stuff (652 comments)

>And would it not be much more fair to look at per-capita numbers? i.e. stop harping on China/India, start worrying about Europe / NA

That's a good question. At first glance, per-captita consumption seems like the thing to focus on. Honestly, it's probably a good place to star; however, as that gap closes things get more subtle.

Consider 4 people, entitled to equal carbon emissions. They form 2 couples and the first decides to have 2 kids, while the second decides to have 6. Are the resulting families entitled to equal emissions, or is each person still entitled to equal emissions?
- It's unfair that children born into a large family should have less then those born into a small family
- It's also unfair that the actions of a couple choosing to have a large family should slice the environmental pie more thinly, reducing the share of those who chose to have a small family. Furthermore, the first option leads to the question of what's a fair baseline and basic human rights, while the second leads to a tragedy of the commons or lowest-common-denominator scenario.

about 4 months ago

Is LG's New Ultra Widescreen Display Better Than "Normal" 4K?

Dantu Of course 3K is better than 4K ....? (304 comments)

Of course 3440 x1440 is better than 4K, having only 56% of the pixels of a true 4K display (4096x2160) LG can make a lot more money on it. A true 4K screen cropped to 21:9 is still going to give you more pixels to work with. BTW: 4K cinema is 4096x2160, but when then want to show 21:9 they use the appropriate lens to change the aspect ratio without throwing out pixels.

about 8 months ago

Why Your Users Hate Agile

Dantu Re:doesn't work (597 comments)

"Proper software engineering" doesn't work.

As a Software Engineer in the formal sense (Engineering is regulated profession here in Canada) I can assure you that "proper software engineering" works great - and it's often Agile. Software Engineering is just like any other type of engineering, you have to pick the right tool for the job. That said, a lot of under-qualified people go around claiming to be Software Engineers and think that generating piles of paperwork will make their crap code (and crappier designs) smell better. They are just as bad as these people

about a year and a half ago

I'd rather my paycheck be denominated in ...

Dantu Pounds Sterling (868 comments)

Of course by pounds sterling I was referring to a given weight of sterling silver, not the GPB.

about 4 years ago

Dye Used In Blue M&Ms Can Lessen Spinal Injury

Dantu Re:Sound Methods? (324 comments)

Even from an evolutionary perspective, yes. Aren't rats kind pretty low on the totem pole?

Depends what totem pole. The totem pole of "most like humans", then they are a little ways down, but still FAR above the 1/2 way point if you include non-mammals.

In terms of "most evolved" rats are exactly where humans are. If there was any argument to be made, you could say they are MORE evolved, since they have a shorter life span and more children - more chance for natural selection to work it's magic.

Evolution works towards optimizing a species for survival; not for "becoming human" or "becoming smart" or anything else that puts people on top. I don't mean to be "anti-human", but evolution doesn't care about those things.

more than 5 years ago

Dye Used In Blue M&Ms Can Lessen Spinal Injury

Dantu Re:Sound Methods? (324 comments)

I happen to prefer the consensus method to the imaginary deity method.

Amen brother!

But seriously, I wish I had mod-points today.

more than 5 years ago

Expanding the Electricity Grid May Be a Mistake

Dantu Re:The quarter wave problem (412 comments)

I'm not very familar with this sort of thing at all, but I thought the problem with DC in powerlines was you'd need absolutely massive lines to properly transmit power any sort of real distance.

Actually, HVDC can carry about 40% more power over the same lines, compared to AC. The main drawback is that you need to convert to/from AC on either end. See:


(I know, not that authoritative, but it cites lots of sources I can't be bothered to copy).

more than 5 years ago

Plastic Circuits Designed To Enable Tough, Green Computers

Dantu Re:Recycling Circuits (67 comments)

Allready you shouldn't just be throwing away your electronic devices when they stop working.

Have you ever tried to recycle your electrics?

I know I'm supposed to do something with them, but honestly, they expect me to drive to one location in the city, during business hours, and pay just to get rid of an old cell phone? Even for a computer, I'd feel guilty, but it'll go in the dumpster. I did take batteries back to one of the local stores that is part of a group that claims they take batteries back to recycle:
Me: Can you take these batteries for recycling, like your website says
Help Desk Guy: Ummmmm... (looks around).. I suppose I could throw them out for you..

When I can recycle my electrics as easily as I can recycle my tin cans, I will. Until then the land-fills are going to keep getting more toxic crap.

more than 5 years ago

Chinese "Web Addicts" Get Boot Camp, Therapy

Dantu Re:Mod up (279 comments)

I know plenty of people who don't get very much activity, eat things loaded in sugar and fat, yet are incredibly skinny and healthy looking. I know other people who exercise a ton, eat extremely healthy food choices, yet are very, very large. There are some reasons for obesity that go way beyond just what you eat....

Fair enough - but you seem to be making a classic mistake. It's not so much what you eat, but how much of it, that determines your weight. Now, as someone who has to work to control his weight - yes, I envy my fiance, who can eat whatever he wants. But the difference isn't that he can magically eat way more than I can - it's that his appetite is more easily sated. Sure there are also metabolism differences, but in reality a very obese person is almost certain to be burning more calories than a thin person at a similar level of physical activity, because all that fat takes energy just to keep alive, and more still to move around.

Where I'm going with this is: sure, life isn't fair. It's more difficult to control eating for some than for others - but at the end of the day what you eat is a conscious choice. Helping teach, encourage, and in some cases force (depending on age, we "force" young kids to do everything) people to eat in a way that will lead to a healthier life can be justified.

more than 5 years ago

Rhode Island Affiliates Banned From Amazon.com Sales

Dantu Re:fuel tax (532 comments)

the more your drive the more you should pay. Now this presents a problem with more fuel efficient vehicles.

Depends a bit on your perspective. To some extent less fuel-efficient vehicles tend to put more wear on the road (eg a pickup-truck vs a sub-compact). If you're thinking "Hybrid Prius" then consider that many places go out of their way to subsidize/mandate fuel economy. Between those two factors, a higher gas-tax kills 2 birds with one stone:
1. Tax for wear on highways that automatically factors in vehicle size
2. Subsidy for fuel-efficient vehicles (and penalty for gas-guzzlers)

more than 5 years ago

Lenovo Tinkers With Larger Delete and Escape Keys

Dantu Re:HERE'S AN IDEA (586 comments)

Try checking out the HP laptop keyboards on Canadian laptops. Dear god the layout on those things is terrible.

You do realize that "Canadian"keyboard layout refers to the special bi-lingual layout (mostly for use in Quebec) ? This isn't some recent HP invention, as it's been around for more than a decade (I quite clearly remember it being supported by Windows 95, because I accidentally selected it). The "normal" keyboard layout that you're probably used to if you are an English-speaking Canadian is the US keyboard layout.

more than 5 years ago

Researchers Find Gaps In Iranian Filtering

Dantu Re:The 1 in 200 bit is garbage (156 comments)

48 heads and 52 tails!

Seems pretty reasonable. The question is, now, how likely is it that I flipped exactly 48 heads and 52 tails?

If you know something about a binomial random variable (which is what we just sampled from), you know that this is (100 choose 48)*.5^(100) = .0735!

Wow...and that was with only 100 random coin flips. A 1 in 20 chance that, by their metrics, this was a fair set of coin flips (see where the logical incongruity happens?)

You've used quite the wrong metric, asking "what are the odds of this EXACT outcome in a fair contest". The right question is "what are the odds of at least this this much deviation from the expected outcome in a fair contest". In the case of your coin toss your questions would be "how likely is it that in 100 flips, I will get 52 OR MORE of either heads or tails" (note that if you were asking only about tails, you'd just get 1/2 the number, but considering the odds of 50 or more tails is only 50/50% it's a bit misleading that way).

To get this you would sum all probabilities in the range, eg
(100 choose 0)*.5^(100) + (100 choose 1)*.5^(100) + .... + (100 choose 47)*.5^(100) + (100 choose 48)*.5^(100) + (100 choose 52)*.5^(100) + (100 choose 53)*.5^(100)+... + (100 choose 100)*.5^(100)
which is about 76.4%.

That is, about 3/4 tosses of 100 coins will differ from 50-50 by at least two flips, this is very similar to the probabilities for these events in the recent US election, held up in the article as an example of 'normal' results.

Now if you'd gotten something like 38-62 you'd have results about as unlikely as this election (2%).

If you're familiar with stats at all, in general it's when the odds fall below 5% that you have an interesting result, 2% is quite interesting (though it depends on how often the event happens - 2% in an election that happens once/4 years or so is going to happen by chance with a mean period of 200 years).

more than 5 years ago

Student Who Released Code From Assignments Accused of Cheating

Dantu Re:Teachers wrong here (333 comments)

Personally I think universities should abolish practices like course buyouts and TAs doing the actual teaching, and strictly require faculty to spend X amount of hours in front of a classroom every year.

I went to a university (Waterloo) that more-or-less does this. It has it's up side - you sometimes get taught by research profs who are amazing at why they do, on the cutting edge, and have amazing enthusiasm to impart. On the other hand, you also get research profs who begrudge every minute of actually teaching - student complaints fall on def ears (even more than normal) because "he's a research prof" (who may pull in millions worth of grants). I think that for the senior courses, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks; but the entry-level material is best taught by a good teacher who is competent in the subject.

more than 5 years ago

How Software Engineering Differs From Computer Science

Dantu Re:Perspective? (306 comments)

Engineering is in deep real world, with human nature and business requirements intervening all the time. Science (like religion) is in some sort of ideal world, vacuum, where all is simple and described by a formula.

Definitely on side here. I agree with all of your points but think you missed just two

In engineering you think not only about getting something to work, but (usually) how to keep it working. That same pragmatism that says "it needs to work" also says "the developers will make mistakes" - which means you need to study how to avoid mistakes, how to catch mistakes, and how to deal with mistakes. There's definitely a science component, but again the human component is also critical.

The other major component is that a Software Engineer, like any other Engineer, needs enough fundamental understanding of all other branches of Engineering to work with his counterparts. A Computer Scientist may not need to know anything about Physics, Chemistry, Electronics, Politics, or the environment, but a Software Engineer needs a little of each, so that he can work with his counterparts in those fields. Note that I'm not saying those things aren't good to have in a Comp. Sci. they just aren't really part of the 'baseline'.

more than 5 years ago

Record-Breaking Model Rocket Launch Set For April 25

Dantu Re:So..... (156 comments)

No sir. The FAA sets those areas at the request of the military. If it came down to a real legal turf war, the FAA must have the ultimate authority. Otherwise we are under military rule. As far as I know the US is not...yet.

Seriously, all getting a bit dramatic isn't it?

It seems pretty clear cut. You're right that the FAA sets those areas at the request of the military - however because they have been set aside the FAA doesn't have much say in the day-to-day goings-on. Sounds like a case of some minor bureaucrat not realizing that he should shut up when the big-boys (aka his boss and the military) already have an agreement in place.

more than 5 years ago

Obama Proposes High-Speed Rail System For the US

Dantu Re:In a word... (1385 comments)

I know myself I hate air conditioning, and I feel very happy in 35C degree heat. In fact I hate the feeling of air conditioning because it is a shock to my system.

Ah, but what humidity are you used to? I used to live in the British Columbia interior - very dry during the summer, and it didn't really matter if there was A/C or not. Bring on 30C+ at 15% humidity. I've since moved to Ontario.. at 90%+ humidity for most of the summer, even 24C feels hot if you try so much as a brisk walk, at 30C I'm melting.

Want to know something else, whenever I am in a hotel in Florida or Texas, I open the windows wide open and turn off the air conditioning. I am then happy as can be. I haven't been to Florida, but I'm guessing they get humidity too. If you can do that, all the power to you. For the rest of us mortals, there is A/C.

more than 5 years ago

Why IT Won't Power Down PCs

Dantu Re:IT is a customer service group (576 comments)

i know in my work place we use geological modeling software that's 20k per dongle and it needs a total beast of a pc to run, so the users of that sometimes need to log into their work station remotely, be it from head office or home.

Much the same things here. We used to setup people to install the software at home and just access data over the network. It turned out that simply having them RemoteDesktop over the VPN is MUCH easier to setup, and for most people it's actually faster: in most cases Remote-Desktop uses less bandwidth and our office machines are better optimized for the work load (mostly maxed-out RAM). With our latest VPN device you can do the whole thing with a java applet that does VPN and Remote Desktop with no setup (though it's a little sluggish).

more than 5 years ago

New Discovery May End Transplant Rejection

Dantu Re:So they're doing another type of immunosupressi (201 comments)

Which is why socialized medicine is great for minor and/or common problems, but not so good with rare/expensive problems. It is also why the rich from countries with socialized health care usually end up coming to the USA for expensive specialized treatments.

Hit the nail on the head. The trick though, is that by treating minor/common problems well, there are a lot less people with expensive problems. I'm a Canadian, and as such, love to bitch about our health care; but if you look at it, we have about 2 year longer life expectancy than our southern neighbors, yet we spend roughly half as much on health care. Actually, the Canadian government spends less on health-care per person than the US does - yet I don't pay a penny to go to the hospital or doctor. Why?

Two answers I think
1. Because Canadians are much more likely to get all those little things taken care of sooner because they are free.

2. Although a bureaucracy is not a great way to run heath-insurance (public) it's better than private companies who's job it is to screw you - particularly if you develop something chronic.

more than 5 years ago

CFLs Causing Utility Woes

Dantu Re:Still... (859 comments)

And don't get me started on the outdoor ones ... I live in a moderate climate that rarely dips below freezing and I've seen the 2 outdoor CF's I've tried fail in less than a year.

Strange - I've had a cheep one on my front porch all winter and haven't had any problems with it. I only changed it to a colored one at Christmas (also CFL) and back. I'm in Southern Ontario, we get a lot more than a few days below freezing... I'm just hoping that last weekend was the last snow for the season!

That said, I found that about 1/4 of my cheep CFLs died within the first couple of months after I put them in my new place last year - but I haven't touched one in at least 6 months. The problem seems to be more quality control (infant death) than average lifespan.

more than 5 years ago

Offshore Windpower To Potentially Exceed US Demand

Dantu Re:There's wind in them thar.... oceans? (679 comments)

If another country (or terrorist) wanted to seriously hurt the US, they'd just have to target a broad swath of these offshore windmills. A pretty easy target I'd think?

Did you really think? Of the VAST area these would be covering? I suspect that the generating capacity per unit area is far lower than any conventional power source (hydro, nuclear, gas/coal).

For comparison, a quick google suggests that the largest windmill in operation has a peak output of 7MW wheras a "small" commercial nuclear reactor has an output over 1000MW. Granted you could fit a few large windmills on the grounds of a nuclear reactor, but probably not a few hundred.

more than 5 years ago


Dantu hasn't submitted any stories.


Dantu has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?