×

Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Pirate Party Leader: Copyright Laws Ridiculous

FroBugg Re:not totally ridiculous, just too much (543 comments)

You touch on another flaw in the original article's reasoning: By eliminating copyright protection of all kind, you make it harder for people to reward the original artist.

Right now, people who want to get a copy of a work for free know what they're doing. They're going to Pirate Bay or some other website instead of Amazon, while people who are happy with paying artists can do so relatively easy (how much publishers are taking is another issue). If you were to eliminate attribution requirements, I'd be free to republish your works on Amazon uncredited or even (depending on the laws that do remain) claim them as my own. Now people have to do additional research to determine just who the actual artist is and whether they're rewarding the right person. Your legal recourse may be limited.

more than 2 years ago
top

Tweeter To Be Prosecuted, Twitter Now Censoring?

FroBugg Re:A suggestion (195 comments)

But this isn't about a right to privacy. If this was about a right to privacy, then whoever uncovered the information in the first place would be the target of legal action, not everybody talking about it. This is the age of the internet and vast, multinational communication. Trying to stop information that's already out there is just a lot of flailing about that's going to hurt a few people and have no real effect.

Whether we should care or not doesn't enter into it, because the laws he wants to use to silence everyone are the same ones politicians or other actually important public figures will use when we find out about things they don't want in the public.

more than 3 years ago
top

Is Wired Hiding Key Evidence On Bradley Manning?

FroBugg Re:Whats Greenwald's angle? (381 comments)

I was mistaken then, my mistake. But although he has been charged, Manning still has yet to be convicted, and his incarceration certainly seems excessively harsh in a country where people are presumed innocent until proven otherwise.

more than 3 years ago
top

Is Wired Hiding Key Evidence On Bradley Manning?

FroBugg Re:Fallout... (381 comments)

Here's something to call into question Poulsen's integrity: Lamo has continued to make claims about what Manning told him and how Manning first contacted him. Some of these claims seem to be contradictory. Not only has Poulsen not released the remainder of the logs, he has so far refused to use them to fact-check Lamo's more recent accusations.

more than 3 years ago
top

Is Wired Hiding Key Evidence On Bradley Manning?

FroBugg Re:Whats Greenwald's angle? (381 comments)

Greenwald's agenda is that Bradley Manning has been held in solitary confinement for seven months without yet being charged with a crime. The chat logs (which the federal government has copies of) may contain evidence that helps to exonerate Manning or to prove his guilt. Outside of Lamo, Poulsen, Manning, and the government, nobody knows.

However, Lamo has continued to make (sometimes conflicting) statements about what Manning has told him, and Poulsen refuses to so much as confirm or deny whether the logs support any of these statements.

more than 3 years ago
top

Why the Web Mustn't Become the New TV

FroBugg Re:14 years too late (240 comments)

Are these the same kids that just won't get off your lawn?

more than 4 years ago
top

US Says Plane Finder App Threatens Security

FroBugg Re:That's what ADS-B is supposed to do. (524 comments)

Not very low budgets. I mean, they've got to afford the surface-to-air missiles first. But after the missiles all they had left was enough to buy an iPhone, a two-year contract, and a $2 app.

And hopefully some lunch, because they're just gonna walk outside and wait until a plane shows up overhead in range, and they're gonna get hungry sitting there.

more than 4 years ago
top

US Says Plane Finder App Threatens Security

FroBugg Re:Did Anybody Read the Fucking Article?? (524 comments)

Maybe they speak English and read this from the article The programme, sold for just 1.79 pounds in the online Apple store, has now been labelled an 'aid to terrorists' by security experts and the US Department of Homeland Security

You need to finish reading sentences. The actual line reads, "The programme, sold for just 1.79 pounds in the online Apple store, has now been labelled an 'aid to terrorists' by security experts and the US Department of Homeland Security is also examining how to protect airliners."

That means security experts have called it an aid to terrorists, and that the DHS is looking into protecting airlines (which they're kind of always doing, since it's their job). It does not mean that DHS has called it an aid to terrorists.

more than 4 years ago
top

Price Shocks May Be Coming For Helium Supply

FroBugg Re:Someone owns stocks in major helium producers (362 comments)

Wrong again, rtb61. A mine in a poorer country that dumps toxic waste into a river is bad news. A modern mine, with all it's emission controls and neutralization processes is not. You really have to understand the difference between an open coal fire and highly emissions controlled one.

Just because a mine is modern and in a first world country doesn't mean it's clean and safe. I don't have any examples from precious metals on hand, but the BP gulf disaster, the continuing poor safety record of American underground coal mining, and mountaintop removal coal mining are all excellent examples.

more than 4 years ago
top

Geologists Might Be Charged For Not Predicting Quake

FroBugg Re:What were they planning on doing? (375 comments)

Exactly. And if the tremors really were strong indicators of a following quake, everyone would only have to put their lives on hold for about a week or so. Maybe less if the quake comes soon!

more than 4 years ago
top

What Scientists Really Think About Religion

FroBugg Re:Religion versus Spirituality (1123 comments)

"Spiritual" is the ultimate in content-free words when it comes to breakdowns like this. Lots of people like to say they're atheist or agnostic but still "spiritual," but I'd be surprised if more than one in five could clearly describe what they mean by that.

Do they mean they believe there's things in the universe we still don't understand? That's practically a given. Do they mean they think that certain things (life in general, self-aware life, etc) is "special" and should be accorded some extra respect? That's fine as an ethical position, but without attributing that specialness to something, it's another waste of a statement to call it spiritual.

This is Slashdot, so I think I'm required to not actually read the article, but a valid and informative followup question for this survey would have been for people who claim "spirituality" to try and explain that stance in an actual substantive way. If you say you're Evangelical or Catholic or Jewish or Humanist, those are descriptions with meaning and descriptive power. Saying you're spiritual doesn't mean a damn thing unless you explain it.

more than 4 years ago
top

The Futurama of Physics

FroBugg Re:My favorite line from Futurama... (150 comments)

Three errors: First, I've always seen the conversion given as either 33 feet or 10 m (which is actually 32.8), never 33.7. Second, the actual pressure varies slightly based on temperature and salinity. Third, you forgot to add the 1 atmosphere from the surface. So even if your 33.7 is accurate, it'd be 149.4 and fails to account for local variability.

more than 4 years ago
top

Games Workshop Sues Warhammer Online Fansite

FroBugg Re:Trademark is a tricky thing (182 comments)

Fair use has nothing to do with trademarks, it's a doctrine of copyright law. GW may have a trademark on Warhammer, but not a copyright. If this fan site is republishing copyrighted materials (rulebooks, background documents, etc), then there may be an issue. But unless you're intentionally trying to confuse people into purchasing a competing product, there's nothing wrong with using a trademark regardless of whether you're a private citizen or a commercial entity.

more than 4 years ago
top

Apple Blocks Cartoonist From App Store

FroBugg Re:Absolutely! (664 comments)

Does Apple have the legal right to do this? Certainly, they do.

The point of stories like this is not to have Apple brought up on charges, but to educate the consumer. If I were a consumer considering a new smartphone (which I am), I'd be grateful for stories like this that document how buying an iPhone or iPad will lock me into a horribly restricted app environment.

Is it "censorship" in a strict legal sense? No, but do you have a better description that's more concise than "not permitting things that violate a license agreement onto things that are restricted in terms of what they can load?"

more than 4 years ago
top

Federal Appeals Court Says Sex Offender's Computer Ban Unfair

FroBugg Re:Let's keep this in context (478 comments)

Yes, actually. If you think he's a danger to society, throw him in jail. Don't let him out with some kind of ridiculous restrictions on what technology he can use and where he can live.

In South Florida, where I used to live, nearly every municipality had passed ordinances restricting registered sex offenders from living within certain distances of parks, schools, daycares, etc. To the point where there was basically nowhere for these people to live. They either had to abandon their families and leave the area (For where? Many other areas have similar restrictions.) or live under a bridge.

Seriously. There's large numbers of sex offenders living under bridges in the Miami area because there's nowhere else for them to live. Their parole officers know they're there, some of them have family that brings by food and supplies, etc.

These are people that the government has deemed to dangerous to live near places children congregate, but not dangerous enough that we need to keep them in prison. So they're homeless. And from the bridge, many of them simply give up and disappear. Off the radar. Gone. Poof. Living somewhere we don't know.

It's ridiculous. Either they're a danger to society or not. Make up your mind.

more than 4 years ago
top

BC Prof Suggests Young Children Need Less Formal Math, Not More

FroBugg Re:Set Theory (427 comments)

http://www.wnyc.org/shows/radiolab/episodes/2009/10/09 was where I heard most of it.

An example of the endpoint thing, specifically dealing with Amazon tribesmen: They'd ask them what's halfway between one and nine, and the answer would be three. These are experiments dealing with adults, not children, who've never been exposed to the type of math used worldwide. It's much harder to do this sort of thing with children, because we don't let them grow up isolated and "corrupt" them with modern math as soon as we're able.

more than 4 years ago
top

BC Prof Suggests Young Children Need Less Formal Math, Not More

FroBugg Re:Set Theory (427 comments)

Even more interesting is that the way we count is completely unnatural. Research with both small children and isolated Amazon tribes indicates that our natural inclination is to count logarithmically, but we train our kids away from this shortly after they learn to talk.

more than 4 years ago
top

Of the options below, I'd most like to learn more ...

FroBugg But I'm a Geologist (515 comments)

Dammit, I'm a geologist. I've already had to learn math and physics and chemistry and biology and archaeology and psychology and climatology and engineering. Well, psychology less than the others, but yeah.

more than 4 years ago
top

How Students Use Wikipedia

FroBugg Re:Credibility (170 comments)

Established, peer-reviewed journals?

more than 4 years ago

Submissions

FroBugg hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

FroBugg has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?