Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Low-Carb Diet Trumps Low-Fat Diet In Major New Study

HiThere Re:so adkins was basically correct? (323 comments)

No, he didn't get shouted down. And this doesn't say he was basically correct, either, it says ONE of his ideas was pretty good. If you go on an actual Atkins diet, expect your triglycerides to rise...which is not good, even if your weight goes down (which it is also likely to do).

FWIW, my doctor and the dietician she referred me to both said "Atkins is ok for the short term, I guess. But I'm not really happy with it, and don't stay on it for a long time." I think they were excessively chairitable towards him. Rising triglycerides is very not good, and I came off that diet "consistent with pre-diabetic", when before my only problem was weight.

OTOH, I still avoid refined carbohydrates, potatoes, etc. I'm hoping that the triglyceride levels will soon drop again.

37 minutes ago
top

Low-Carb Diet Trumps Low-Fat Diet In Major New Study

HiThere Re:Question #0 what were they eating? (323 comments)

FWIW, high fructose corn syrup is a carb.

OTOH, I don't think they counted which group ate more turnip greens, cabbage, etc. And those are carbs too.

43 minutes ago
top

China Gives Microsoft 20 Days To Respond To Competition Probe

HiThere Re:Free market escapades! (72 comments)

You're leaving out profit. Once you feel secure in your monopoly, then incompatible upgrades are a benefit, because they force users to upgrade.

about an hour ago
top

Deputy Who Fatally Struck Cyclist While Answering Email Will Face No Charges

HiThere Re:Manslaughter? Murder with intent... (423 comments)

You've shown negligence, not malice. To me this is clearly negligent homocide. I see no evidence of murder (intentional homocide) much less malice aforethought. This doesn't mean they aren't there, but you haven't even started to make that case.

yesterday
top

Deputy Who Fatally Struck Cyclist While Answering Email Will Face No Charges

HiThere Re:yet if we did it (423 comments)

No. The only way to hope to (re-?)establish order and honor in the police is to hold them to the very laws they are expected to enforce. If there are no consequences when they disobey the laws, then they will continue to become more arbitrary, dishonorable, an untrustworthy.

For that matter, they should be held to a higher standard. A police officer should be held more stringently to obedience to the law than a normal citizen, and the punishment should be harsher (though not by too much) when they break the laws.

That they are not is quite clear, so their powers should be reduced, because they have been repeatedly shown to not be trusted with the ones that they have. For this reason I am in favor of requiring a camera that they cannot disable to be upon them at all times, and that malfunction of the camera should mean that they are not paid for that period AND that an independent investigation of the case is launched. It should record sound as well as video, and should be immediatedly transmitted to a secure read-only cache. Also, they should be on leave without pay from the instant the camera is disabled until it is repaired.
This is clearly an onerous requirement, and if the police had been shown to be at all trustworthy I wouldn't consider anything this strict. They have, however, shown that they cannot be so trusted.

Also, any action that they take while the camera is known to be non-operational and they are in uniform should be considered taken "under the cloak of authority", i.e., if they commit a crime, there is an additional penalty because they are fraudulently claiming to represent the law. Because of this the camera should be equipped with a soft beep that plays intermittently while it is operational, and a louder chirp that plays intermittently (once every 2 sec.?) while it is non-functional. Perhaps the chirp could encode the camera id, so that others recording in the area would have information as to which one.

yesterday
top

Deputy Who Fatally Struck Cyclist While Answering Email Will Face No Charges

HiThere Re:yet if we did it (423 comments)

OK, then *I'll* say that the supervisor who said that was legal superior and ordered police to follow it should be charged with ... I want "conspiracy to commit manslaughter", but I don't think that's possible, so I'd settle for malfeasance. And I don't think that excuses the officer from negligent homocide....unless you want to argue that he did it intentionally.

The fact that this is a part of a pattern of behavior means that I don't think he should be exonerated even if the evidence were to show that in this particular case the bicyclist *did* swerve out in front of him.

yesterday
top

China Gives Microsoft 20 Days To Respond To Competition Probe

HiThere Re:Free market escapades! (72 comments)

Imagined? I doubt that. From what I read in the summary it sounded like they were pissed off when their old programs couldn't read the new file format. To me that sounds fair. I don't think very highly of breaking backwards compatibility. It's occasionally necessary, but extremely more rarely than it is done. Usually it seems a strategy to force a purchase of new versions. And to me that sounds like abuse of a dominant market position. (I'd say abuse of monopoly, but somebody always thinks that means there aren't any competitors.)

yesterday
top

Microsoft Defies Court Order, Will Not Give Emails To US Government

HiThere Re:That's nice, but... (403 comments)

There are all sorts of reasons why they might not want to admit in the open that they had such a backdoor, and the left hand might not want the right hand to see what it's holding, too.

2 days ago
top

Microsoft Defies Court Order, Will Not Give Emails To US Government

HiThere Re:This is huge ... (403 comments)

They aren't involved in anything except breaking the Europeran data protection laws, you mean. If it's an automated process then whoever set it up that way broke the law, and any manager who allowed the set up to continue also broke the law. And so did the corporation.

2 days ago
top

Microsoft Defies Court Order, Will Not Give Emails To US Government

HiThere Re:Globalization (403 comments)

Sorry, but I think you're wrong.

The problem here appears to be that the Irish subsidiary of MS is a wholly owned subsidiary, so MS (the US corporation) has control over it. If MS were an Irish corporation, and the US corporation were a wholly owned subsidiary of it, then the US corporation would not have control over the Irish corporation.

A secondary problem is that currently the US corporation is being ordered to force the Irish corporation (which it controls) to violate Irish law. Presumably if the ownership were inverted the Irish court would not do some equivalent ruling (being a bit less megalomaniacal). But even if it did something stricktly analogous, the US doesn't protect the data on consumers so there would be no law violated. (Which, of course, means that it's not strictly analogous....analogies are slippery.)

2 days ago
top

Microsoft Defies Court Order, Will Not Give Emails To US Government

HiThere Re:That's nice, but... (403 comments)

There's evidence, but I don't think there's any proof. And some of the evidence is pretty shaky. But do you have any reasonable reason to doubt that they have a backdoor?

2 days ago
top

US Government Fights To Not Explain No-Fly List Selection Process

HiThere Re:It'd be nice... (247 comments)

That's your metric. It's a fair one, but it's not the only one.

2 days ago
top

US Government Fights To Not Explain No-Fly List Selection Process

HiThere Re:Jail them for contempt (247 comments)

Your mistake is assuming monolithic intent. Even a single judge has intentions that vary from minute to minute...just as yours do. When you factor in a large number of judges you get a large variation in intent. Sometimes they are even worse than you are currently imagining. Sometimes they are focused on the rule of law. Sometimes they are of some idealistic bent or other.

So the kind of result that you are expecting is possible, but not inevitable, even with a judge that usually bends to the wind. And some judges rarely do that.

Even so, I figure that the trend toward centralized authoritarianism is designed into they sysstem, given the greatly improved speed of communication and transportation. And, of course, the closing of the frontier. There's now nowhere to go to escape them. This makes designs that were only a bit authoritarian at the start ("I smell a rat. It squints towards monarchy."--Patrick Henry on the US Constitution) much more authoritarian now. The British system, with all its faults, is a lot better, but then it *evolved* under tyranny. (Unfortunately, they've been disabling their safeguards over the recent decades. Now Lords can be members of the House of Commons, IIUC, and that's totally insecure. The change they *should* have made would be to continue the separation, but so automatically promote into the aristocracy anyone who is sufficiently rich and powerful. Possibly also a provision to demote from the aristocracy the heirs of anyone who loses their wealth and power...but with a time lag to allow them to recover without loss of "status".)

3 days ago
top

US Government Fights To Not Explain No-Fly List Selection Process

HiThere Re:THIS (247 comments)

There really *is* a difference. It rarely translates into action, but it infuses the rhetoric used. The Democrats want more people to like them, and the Republicans want more powerful people to like them. So they say the things they think will cause that to happe, while acting as self-serving greedy immoral power-seeking proto-despots (who are trying to lose the "proto-").

3 days ago
top

US Government Fights To Not Explain No-Fly List Selection Process

HiThere Re:It'd be nice... (247 comments)

I take it you haven't known many. I'll agree that many of them believe that "all rights belong to the proprietor", and many of them don't stop to think that the title to the property is given by the state.

Or maybe the people I knew were just anarchists who called themselves libertarians.

3 days ago
top

US Government Fights To Not Explain No-Fly List Selection Process

HiThere Re:It'd be nice... (247 comments)

You're neglecting the time element. After Obama is out of office expect shocking revelations...about something.

3 days ago
top

US Government Fights To Not Explain No-Fly List Selection Process

HiThere Re:It'd be nice... (247 comments)

Depends on your metric, and not everyone uses the same one.

Example: Do you count Snowden's revelations as a part of Obama's transparency? Some do. Some don't. You can argue either way. Arguments over "sound bite" ideas aren't worth much. And quantity isn't as important as quality, but how do you measure quality?

FWIW, I could Bush's Iranian missles as a strong and important example of lack of transparency. (Most people couldn't see through it...even years later many people still believed it.) It's hard to think of anything quite as "qualitatively important" that Obama has hidden...though we may find out one in a few years, or decades.

3 days ago
top

Fermilab Begins Testing Holographic Universe Theory

HiThere Re:Rural Illinois???? (247 comments)

I thought Fermilab decided to go with bison.

about a week ago
top

Fermilab Begins Testing Holographic Universe Theory

HiThere Re:Are we, America, butthurt? (247 comments)

Actually "egghead" was a creation of Mussolini. But it's true that the UStatians adopted it.

about a week ago
top

Exomoon Detection Technique Could Greatly Expand Potential Habitable Systems

HiThere Re:Who Cares? (66 comments)

Why not a generation ship? We are probably on 50-60 years from being able to build a generation ship, if we can handle the sociology. Perhaps up to a century. It's not clear that we'll *EVER* be able to do it in any other way.

If you're in a hurry, you were already born too soon.

about a week ago

Submissions

HiThere hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

HiThere has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>