Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!



Google Project Ara Design Will Use Electro-Permanent Magnets To Lock In Modules

HobophobE Re:They talk very big (62 comments)

Or, "you're going to the Grand Canyon for the day, so why not rent a higher resolution camera module." If you don't do photography every day, maybe the cost would be too great for a high-res camera mod (i.e., over time camera will no longer be a discrete instrument, but will become part of the mobile kit (don't worry, you will still be able to get a camera-like platform for the usability it offers)), but if you're taking a special trip (or going to a wedding), it might make sense to rent the mod for something as low as $10 per day.

about 8 months ago

Does Net Neutrality Violate the Fifth Amendment?

HobophobE Tortious interference of contract (341 comments)

Even if it were taking place entirely on private property (which it isn't: their lines run across public land, and they are already giving up some rights to control that property due to that fact), they still must not interfere with the individual's right to contract. The exchange of information via IP is a voluntary exchange between two legal entities, and the exchange amounts to a contractual relationship (ie, the initial request is a unilateral contract). For an ISP to do any more than simply route that exchange is tortious interference of contract.

Even though the ISP might block the relationship before it exists (ie, preemptive network bias such as forging packets or simply dropping the initial request packets), it will still fit the terms. The contract is unilateral, so in the initiator's view the contract exists unless the receiving party fails to act of their own accord (letting the request time out, for example) or explicitly declines (sending a HTTP status code in the 400 range, for example).

Tortious interference, in the common law of tort, occurs when a person intentionally damages the plaintiff's contractual or other business relationships.

Wikipedia: Tortious interference

more than 4 years ago

Best Alternatives To the Big Name Social Media?

HobophobE Barnacles. (451 comments)

A lot of the comments here say that the ... let me just quote one:

The thing that makes "social media" useful is its userbase. You could never have found/kept in touch with your old friends if you weren't signed up for a service they were also signed up for. Trying to find a smaller service by definitions means it's not going to be as useful to you.

slashdot.org: #31978746 Missing the Point by thePowerOfGrayskull

But e-mail is a federated medium. Anyone can run a server, and anyone can send/receive. Their argument wouldn't hold water for e-mail, but it currently does for social networks.

That needs to change, and it will change in time. Many of the technologies to make it happen already exist: RSS, OpenID/OAuth, pingbacks, etc. They just haven't been coordinated and solidified.

There are certain artifacts of the old web that remain affixed like so many barnacles. They include the little buttons that litter major websites, beckoning you to spread their content for them. Not to say you shouldn't, but that it shouldn't be button-based. That's where the user agent is supposed to do the work, not each website implementing its own sharing widgets.

Like I say, it'll go away, but it will require a federated system. Your friends will subscribe to an RSS of your statuses. If they comment, it'll send you a pingback. And so on.

more than 4 years ago

Blind Soldier Uses Tongue To "See"

HobophobE Old Tech, improved (107 comments)

Though Google seems to have lost most of the articles, I remembered this from back in 2002, and I was able to find at least a few results such as Eyes in the Back of Your Mouth. It sounds like this article is talking about improvements (more refined matrix, portability) and deployments of the same technology. A quote from the link above:

His latest technology sends visual data through the tongue, which is jam-packed with nerves and coated with conductive saliva. A video camera worn on the forehead sends images to a laptop, which dumbs down the picture to 144 pixels. That signal is sent to a soviet-gray box, called a Tactile Display Unit, which converts the image to electrical impulses. The current winds up on a matrix of electrodes that tingle the image onto the tongue. In lab tests, the system enabled blind people to recognize letters, catch rolling balls, and watch candles flicker for the first time.

more than 4 years ago

A Warming Planet Can Mean More Snow

HobophobE Re:Science or Religion? (1136 comments)

All I've heard from people that are "skeptical" of the current climate science is that the science is faulty/incomplete/etc. Where is their alternative?

My understanding of science is that it works a lot like the kids' game 'king of the hill.' Whichever hypothesis/model fits the data best is the king, and remains king until either a better hypothesis/model (ie, one that fits the data better) arises or new data comes along that either fits the king so poorly or fits an existing contender better.

Various scientists get ideas for experiments that could knock the king down or help it stay up, others have ideas that could get their contender to the top, and they fight to do just that.

Science is about alternative possibilities. There's the way things are, and there's the way things look. The latter a shadow of the former. It's in our best interest to try to extrapolate from shadow to form, but it's tricky. We go with the best we have for now, and we improve as we continue. If you've got a better idea, let's hear it.

As to particular data that would debunk the anthropogenic hypothesis, that is defined by the hypothesis itself. Data showing the emissions to be smaller than thought, or that the emissions from human activity have some peculiarity that exclude them from significant contribution to the climate, etc. would be necessary to take down the current hypothesis. Data would have to show that man's activities do not significantly contribute to climate.

more than 4 years ago

TSA Wants You To Keep Your Seat, and Your Hands In Sight

HobophobE Re:Congrats TSA/Al Queda (888 comments)

Back when I was in grade school some middle school kid in the same school district cut off the tip of his nose using scissors (it was reattached). They banned regular scissors for all kids through middle school and we all had to use these stupid, feeble scissors that barely worked. I assume that to this day the kids at those schools still are deprived decent scissors over what an outlier did a couple of decades ago.

As you say, it's asinine. It completely defies any understanding of science and statistics. But there's more to the story: they are doing this out of fear of lawsuits. If they hadn't banned those scissors and another kid had done a repeat, the parents would have sued and might have won. The lawyer would have stood before the jury and railed about how just months or years before the same thing had happened and the school did nothing. In this case, if they make no change and someone gets hurt in a repeat then there will be a lawsuit and the lawyer will do the same thing: paint it as if the airlines and government should have changed the rules.

more than 4 years ago

Microsoft Tweaks Browser Ballot As EU Deal Nears

HobophobE Happy (187 comments)

The object of this ballot system is to let users know that a choice even exists. It's not to promote any specific competitor. You seem to overlook the fact that there are people out there (and quite a few, I might add) that don't know they have a choice. They don't know what a browser is. They just know they click that specific icon to get on the internet. They don't know there is an internet separate from the web. A lot of computer users have very limited knowledge.

As to why they should know, that is everything to do with economics. You can go read about that in depth, but the gist of it is that information is the lifeblood of a market (particularly an information market). The more nuanced an understanding the average participant has of the marketplace, the healthier that market will be. This is because as sophistication grows in the market, the options must become refined to compete. To put that in terms of browsers, as more browsers compete they all become standards-compliant and have to differentiate on other factors such as speed, security, extensions, portability (both the browser and the data), and so on.

about 5 years ago

RIAA Awarded $675,000 In Tenenbaum Trial

HobophobE Didn't admit liability? (492 comments)

I would question whether he did admit liability. The quote:

"Are you admitting liability for all 30 sound recordings"

is a horrible question akin to "have you stopped beating your 30 wives?" One can easily intend to answer the numerical quantity without considering the issue of liability.

more than 5 years ago

Was the Amazon De-Listing Situation a Glitch Or a Hack?

HobophobE Re:Sigh (396 comments)

[...] tragicomic to see otherwise-intelligent people peddle false information and conspiracy theories when actual, real data is out there.

It's also tragicomic to see an otherwise-intelligent company not get ahead of a problem like this from a PR standpoint.

I can accept that it was a technical mistake and not a policy change or a gaming or breach of their systems. But it's very hard to accept that they wouldn't immediately cop to the problem and give an explanation. Other sites take pains to inform their users of technical difficulties and disabled features.

At the very least there should be a window of time after a title has been de-listed from sales rank that it includes a notice explaining that has happened. It's very difficult to trust a system that may change arbitrarily at a moment's (lack of) notice.

more than 5 years ago

Can the Auto Industry Retool Itself To Build Rails?

HobophobE Re:Extremely unprofitable (897 comments)

Which is, go figure, no different than an equivalent use-tax on public transportation.

more than 5 years ago

Can the Auto Industry Retool Itself To Build Rails?

HobophobE Re:Extremely unprofitable (897 comments)

Err, the road construction isn't heavily subsidized?

While I agree we can't just build a whole rail system overnight, I think there are places it makes a lot of sense (especially to take some burden off of heavy-traffic roads).

But no, I don't buy the subsidy argument when we're subsidizing the current system (and paying a lot of hidden costs to boot) already.

more than 5 years ago

Google Goofs On Firefox's Anti-Phishing List

HobophobE Re:Misleading desciption (168 comments)

Having a distributed system where individuals are responsible for rating resources (other individuals, websites, basically _anything_ with a unique ID or URI) would go a long way not just to combat phishing and malware, but other sorts of scams, trolls, etc. I call that system a "reputation system."

We need a system where I can rate a site as vapid (ie, experts-exchange is a waste of my time in search results) and then people who choose to subscribe to my ratings will see those sites may not be worth their time.

The key is to make it extensible such that it can encompass the internet at large and even things in real life like menu items in restaurants.

It's one thing to get feedback about something from one or a handful of people. It is more valuable to have a large graph of opinions which you can prune at will to give you the best information available.

more than 6 years ago


HobophobE hasn't submitted any stories.


HobophobE has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?