×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Do We Need a Longer School Year?

Knave75 Re:No (729 comments)

I have a question for you, why was education better when the relative salary of teachers was lower than it is today? The armies that fought the U.S. Civil War were the most literate armies in history (as evidenced by the many letters and journals that they wrote), yet at that time school teachers were generally paid a pittance.

So, when I first read the above, I figured you were just trolling. However, a quick google search turned up the following:

Civil War armies were the most literate in history to that time

Emphasis mine. I'll leave it as an exercise to the reader to ascertain the precise mistake made by the parent post.

about a year and a half ago
top

Do We Need a Longer School Year?

Knave75 Re:No (729 comments)

We can't talk about the single major factor in the deteriorating education system in this country. Teachers Unions. How was it we successfully educated generations of students prior to the unions and now we consistently produce students which can barely read, write, and spell.

In my opinion, you guys started demonizing and drastically underpaying your teachers. At first, that certainly saves money, but over time it encourages talented people to seek employment elsewhere. Will raising teacher's salaries make them better? Of course not, but it will attract people to the profession that might actually be good.

Most of my friends who have smart kids are seeing them go into finance. Why? Talented people follow the money. Yes, it would be nice if people became teachers for the love of education, but we live in the real world.

My own experience in the California public school system was HORRIFIC. Some of the newer teachers were good, however they lacked funding to really do anything, that said, the rest of them where HORRIBLE and should have been fired long ago.

You get what you pay for.

about a year and a half ago
top

Iranian Players Blocked From World of Warcraft Due To Trade Sanctions

Knave75 Re:When I was a kid we thought America was free (475 comments)

Actually, GenCon asked to see my ID every single time I walked through the door. It is easier to walk into a casino.

about a year and a half ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Why Aren't Schools Connected?

Knave75 Re:"Reply" is the problem (568 comments)

It takes a lot more time for a parent to pick up a phone or write a letter to contact the teacher... and I think that's how a lot of teachers like it.

I agree completely. The very act of picking up the phone and finding the correct number to dial filters out 90% of the parent calls, of which 99% are of no value to the student. Even when parents email me, I give them my phone number and ask them to call.

Also, I would never "comment" online. Anything written has to be extremely factual and to the point. Anything I write to a parent, I write under the assumption that this piece of communication could end up in court somewhere, and I word it appropriately. On a phone call, the parents will hear the unvarnished truth, I almost never sugarcoat. An email message however will contain much as much jargon, waffling, and ass-covering as I can fit in the 4 or so sentences I'm willing to write.

For example, I'm willing to write a parent to say that Johnny got a 43% on his last test, but I will never write that Johnny got that 43% by texting his girlfriend in class and not completing his homework. If they want to find that out, the parents have to call. Why is that? Johnny's parents will point out that homework is not part of the curriculum, the texting is irrelevent, and that clearly I am punishing Johnny for not completing his homework and because I have some weird problem with cellphones, being a luddite like all teachers. Then they will appeal the mark to the superintendent, claiming that I have a clear bias against their son as evidenced by the email I sent them, and threaten legal action.

The previous paragraph is a true story, happened to a coworker. Parents turned a failure into a pass.

So yeah, I very rarely write to parents due to logistical (can't answer all parents, serves as a good filter keeping away those that don't really care) and legal (written stuff is dangerous) reasons.

about 2 years ago
top

Facebook, Twitter, and Myspace To Google: Don't Be Evil

Knave75 Re:Wait...who told whom what? (208 comments)

Facebook? Facebook is telling Google not to be evil? FACEBOOK?

That was my initial reaction. If it were Mozilla or Wikipedia telling Google to be less evil, that would be one thing. But Facebook, one of the more evil companies on the planet, beseeching Google not to be evil?

This is why I could never work in the corporate world. I understand that spewing this type of bullshit is par for the course, but I would have never been able to stomach it.

more than 2 years ago
top

2011 Was the 9th Hottest Year On Record

Knave75 Re:There is no denying the Earth is getting hotter (877 comments)

That is a much better way of evaluating the value that people ascribe to their own life. If you use your metric, the value of a life would probably plummet far below $50,000 that I rather arbitrarily used in my previous post.

Either way, nothing close to the $13 million nonsense, which was used for the $3.3 trillion price tag. Using a value of $130 000 per life (still pretty high in my opinion) and using the logic of that post, that would put the value of stopping global warming at something around $33 billion dollars today, which may seem like a quite a bit, but pales in comparison to the cost of actually fighting this global warming.

Which is not to say that my numbers are right either, I have no idea where that $3.3 trillion estimate from the GGP post came from, but he was a warmist, so I think it would be rather safe to use his numbers in my calculations.

more than 2 years ago
top

2011 Was the 9th Hottest Year On Record

Knave75 Re:There is no denying the Earth is getting hotter (877 comments)

Since according to US actuarial tables, a human life is worth about $13 million, 500 million people is worth about $6,500 trillion. Given a 1% chance of this happening, this is an opportunity cost of $65 trillion. Given the time value of money over 100 years (the average between now and 200 years from now), it's worth about $3.3 trillion today to prevent those deaths.

Obviously, I'm just making these numbers up, but it illustrates the point. This is a rough calculation that a rational liberal economist might put on the value of trying to reduce the impact of anthropomorphic climate change.

The idea that a life is worth $13 million dollars is complete nonsense. The average american (who is vastly wealthier than the average human) will earn, on average, something less than $2 million dollars over his or her entire working life. This does not take into account the food and shelter that was required to keep that human productive over the course of those 40 something years. As far as I am concerned, I'm worth about $900 trillion dollars, but the reality is that I value the life of other (non-family) people at something substantially less than $13 million dollars.

I would estimate that Americans value the lives of other Americans at a maximum of something around $50,000 to $100,000. In other words, if a measure would cost $1 billion dollars and would save about 10,000 people, it would pass, but if the billion dollars would only save 1000 people, then the measure would not pass. When I say saving people I mean "saving random people who would not know that they were saved by that measure". In other words, if it costs a billion dollars to save 1000 people statistically, it will not be done.

Note that politicians are willing to spend a lot of money to save specific people. A law that provides health care to people injured due to being victims of the production of child pornography could easily be worth $20 million per life saved.

more than 2 years ago
top

The Doomsday Clock Is Moved Closer To Midnight

Knave75 Re:Zeno (313 comments)

Not yet, but I imagine that, when Iran actually gets nukes, they will think twice about wiping out Israel (at least from a missile launched from within their borders). That provides a certain measure of security to Israel.

Israel, on the other hand, has had nukes for a few decades now and hasn't done anything stupid... so far so good.

more than 2 years ago
top

The Doomsday Clock Is Moved Closer To Midnight

Knave75 Re:Zeno (313 comments)

Doesn't Israel have them? Oh, you specified sane.

If your implication is that the only democratic country in the region is not sane, then your standards are, to be honest, extremely high.

more than 2 years ago
top

The Doomsday Clock Is Moved Closer To Midnight

Knave75 Re:Zeno (313 comments)

From your own linked wikipedia article:

although Canada stipulated, and the U.S. supply contract for the heavy water explicitly specified, that it only be used for peaceful purposes. Nonetheless, CIRUS has produced some of India's initial weapon plutonium stockpile,[3] as well as the plutonium for India's 1974 Pokhran-I (Codename Smiling Buddha) nuclear test, the country's first nuclear test.

My point stands. India was sold a reactor for "peaceful" purposes, and made weapons. I suspect that Iran would do the same.

Please get your facts right before putting India and Iran in the same sentence.

Which fact did I get wrong?

more than 2 years ago
top

The Doomsday Clock Is Moved Closer To Midnight

Knave75 Re:Zeno (313 comments)

I think Canada sold some reactors to India that could not be used to create weaponized material. India then promptly used those reactors to make weaponized material.

more than 2 years ago
top

Verizon Backtracks On $2 Convenience Fee

Knave75 Corporate speak (281 comments)

From the press release...

which was designed to improve the efficiency of those transactions.

The fee was designed to increase the efficiency of the online transaction. I have to give them credit, I would never have the balls to say something like that, which is probably why it is a good thing that I am not in business.

more than 2 years ago
top

Go Daddy Loses Over 21,000 Domains In One Day

Knave75 Re:Spellchecking (356 comments)

lol... touche.

But my comment was not a summary on a major website.

more than 2 years ago
top

Go Daddy Loses Over 21,000 Domains In One Day

Knave75 Spellchecking (356 comments)

Seriously, this is a high traffic site. A two-line summary should not contain two spelling mistakes.

Were != Where

And, "Daddy" has a suprisingly large number of D's

more than 2 years ago
top

Sorry, IT: These 5 Technologies Belong To Users

Knave75 Re:BYOD? Then BYOS(upport) too (348 comments)

*snipped whining about the stupid things users do*

We all have jobs, and most of us have to deal with incompetent people. If a customer is causing me difficulties, I don't get to ruin his experience to make my life easier... I deal with him, and try to find a way to satisfy his needs and my own requirements. I find IT though has the general attitude of "well, we're not going to change, so you damn well had better do it yourself".

Yes, I know IT people are Gods amongst insects, doesn't give you the right to go around smashing us insects indiscriminately just because you can.

more than 2 years ago
top

Was Russia Behind Stuxnet?

Knave75 Re:Government responsible says, 'Look, commies'. (281 comments)

"even though Israel has never done anything bad to Iran"

Euh, you don't think that the locations that Israel occupies are of no importants to the people in Iran ? Because of their religion I mean.

You're right, Mecca and Medina are located inside Israel...

....um, I mean, I'm confused.

Wait, I know, it must be because Israel goes around destroying religious monuments sacred to Muslims, right?

...umm, well, let's move on.

It must be because Israel actively persecutes Muslims through their legal system...

........

Fuck it, we should just attack Israel anyway. We'll think of a reason later.

more than 2 years ago
top

For 1 kWh of electricity, I pay ...

Knave75 My government (Ontario, Canada) on the other hand (216 comments)

I may pay only 7 cents per kwh, but my government pays roughly 80 cents per kwh for the electricity that they then sell to me for 7 cents... to a select number and type of generators of course.

more than 2 years ago
top

Why Everyone Hates the IT Department

Knave75 Re:Like lawyers, impose unrealistic limits (960 comments)

So do you think that's because your IT staff sees your requests and says, "Hey you know would be really fun lets wait two weeks to get back with Knave75, so he will be really irritable and give us a hard time!"

Of course not, but as I said above, even if the delay is completely reasonable, it is still aggravating. Perhaps I should not be angry, but damn do I feel angry. And, should I get attitude from the IT guy when I (very reasonably) ask how long a certain procedure will take, then I get really pissed off.

more than 2 years ago
top

Why Everyone Hates the IT Department

Knave75 Re:Like lawyers, impose unrealistic limits (960 comments)

As for certain simple programs, and it takes them weeks to install those programs, costing me hundreds of hours in productivity a year.

Did you ever stop to consider that the things IT is working on have a much bigger impact to the company than your personal productivity?

The question was " Why are IT people disliked?", not " should IT people be disliked?"

I'm sure there are many valid and semi-valid reasons for all that IT does, but when I have to waste hours of time that I don't have, it pisses me off. Sorry for being human.

Also, I moderately resent the implication in a good chunk of this thread that just because I'm not in IT means I have no idea what's involved. That type of attitude also contributes to the hate-on.

more than 2 years ago

Submissions

top

Your home is your castle... unless you smoke

Knave75 Knave75 writes  |  more than 4 years ago

Knave75 (894961) writes "Increasingly, smoking has been outlawed in most public spaces. However, the fight is now being taken into more private areas. It started with an attack on smokers who use their vehicle for work-related purposes, and has now morphed into government officials musing about banning smoking for apartment dwellers. There is no mention on whether those people rich enough to smoke in their single family dwellings will be a target as well."
Link to Original Source
top

Censorship: Canadian-style

Knave75 Knave75 writes  |  more than 6 years ago

Knave75 (894961) writes "The Canadian Islamic Congress has launched a human rights complaint against Maclean's, a fairly old and established news magazine similar to "Time" published in Canada. The allegation: An article that was published did not say nice things about muslims. From the mouth of the CIC's lawyer:

Faisal Joseph is the CIC's legal counsel on the matter. "In Canada, we have 750,000 law-abiding Muslims," he says. "When you read that article, it sounds to some people [like] there's an attack from the 'Muslim' world against the 'non-Muslim' world. We take real issue with that type of characterization and the implications of it."
In other words, when letters to the editor don't work, try a human rights complaint instead."

Journals

Knave75 has no journal entries.

Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Sign up for Slashdot Newsletters
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...