×

Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Not to mention Audio Editing (223 comments)

Audacity does not have true surround support. The individual tracks can be mapped to a channel when saving. It's not a smooth way to support that feature but it's way ahead of the competition (i.e. GoldWave etc.)

5 days ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Article confuses "on Linux" with FOSS (223 comments)

If you actually read TFA, in the introduction he says that with a good video editor, video shops could be all-Linux shops. The intro doesn't say "free free free", it's about something that can do the job on Linux.

Quote from TFA: "I often ask myself what the current state of video editing is for free and open source software (FOSS)."

Does this wording really mean "proprietary software under Linux"? To me it does not but maybe that's because I'm not a native English speaker.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Not to mention Audio Editing (223 comments)

Audacity 2.0 introduced multi-track editing, but your comment still stands. It's not suited for any realistic workflow or editing audio synced with video.

Have you ever tried simple wave editing in a surround sound file?
Among the non-professional / low-end tools Audacity is apparently the only wave editor to support that at least to some degree (although the channel mapping window when saving is awkward).

In the end I used ffmpeg and SoX

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Not to mention Audio Editing (223 comments)

Sadly though, Reaper (for Windows only) is the DAW you want to use, not Ardour (Linux) or even Pro Tools (Windows, sort of industry standard for small / amateur projects). You can trust me on that one (because I've used different tools in real projects) or or have a look at a few forum threads to see what others say. No affiliation. It's just better and it makes things easier.

And others say Reaper, the product of former Winamp developers, sucks and you should use Ableton Live instead. Others say Logic Pro.

I'm not a musician myself but I know a few and each has their own preference.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Not to mention Audio Editing (223 comments)

In your opinion, which is obviously heavily skewed towards FOSS.

I had to do some simple editing (changing speed and so on) in a 2h audio file a few months ago. GoldWave 5 was completely unusable â" it just crashed. GoldWave 6 beta worked but at super slow speed on a 64 bit Win 8.1 Core i7 system. After 15 Minutes of waiting for the FLAC file to save, I just gave up. (GoldWave was my first wave editing love, so if anything my opinion was skewed towards that.)

Audacity was (and still is) not pretty but unlike GoldWave it worked. I prefer working software over non-working software and as simple wave editor Audacity does the job.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Attitudes (223 comments)

What kind of horse shit is this? I can think of at least 3 examples off the top of my head that make this false.

First, please provide proof that FOSS developers in general do not care about stability, as you claimed in your first post.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Article confuses "on Linux" with FOSS (223 comments)

and none of those are nlve's either, whats your fucking point

RTFA!
The article claims to list "6 free and open source video editing tools" and includes LightWorks in that list.
That's my point. And now GTFO.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Attitudes (223 comments)

So the expectation that an application doesn't randomly crash-to-desktop makes one "spoiled"?

Your attitude to claim that all FOSS developers just accept crashes makes you spoiled.
Not every bug is reproducible everywhere. If a bug does not occur or the developer's system, it's not his fault.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Not to mention Audio Editing (223 comments)

I'd still rather use Cool Edit from 1998 than Audacity. I'm glad we have a free tool like Audacity, but I currently use Adobe Audition 1.0 (they bought Cool Edit way back) running in Wine, which is a much better solution IMO.

If you want something like Adobe Audition, you should get something like Adobe Audition and not try to use a simple wave editor as DAW substitute. Get Bitwig Studio: https://www.bitwig.com/en/bitw...
I heard it's by former Ableton people, so they know their stuff.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Attitudes (223 comments)

Things won't improve until two things are addressed. First FOSS devs drop the attitude that "It crashes sometimes" is an acceptable condition for software intended for productive work.

Really? That's the attitude of FOSS developers? I call that BS.
I think chances are spoiled users of proprietary software mistake being able to communicate directly with the developers with entitlement that a developer has to jump directly when a user discovers a bug.
No, bugs are handled with different priorities and just because a bug annoys you the most, it is not necessarily the most crucial bug to fix first.

If you want bug priorities to change, just announce to give 100 bucks to whoever fixes a bug you run into.
Bug bounty programs are quite common in FOSS.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Re:Not to mention Audio Editing (223 comments)

Audacity is a simple wave editor, not a Digital Audio Workstation (DAW).
Audacity's direct competition are GoldWave, Nero Wave Editor, and so on and Audacity blows them all out of the water in areas that are objectively measurable, i.e. file compatibility, encoding performance, etc.

But comparing Audacity to a DAW is unfair. They are just different things with just some overlapping feature set – kinda like comparing a pure text editor with a word processor.

about a week ago
top

The Current State of Linux Video Editing

KugelKurt Article confuses "on Linux" with FOSS (223 comments)

LightWorks is not FOSS. It works on Linux but so do Maya, Bitwig, RenderMan, and so on. Neither of those is FOSS.
There is professional software available for Linux in this market but just like OSX and Windows you have to pay for them.

about a week ago
top

Google Sees Biggest Search Traffic Drop Since 2009 As Yahoo Gains Ground

KugelKurt Re:Isn't Yahoo search just Google? (155 comments)

Yahoo search was powered by Google circa 2000.
It then changed to Inktomi a few years after.

Yahoo used Google in 2000 but bought them and Overture/Altavista in 2002.
Yahoo did not switch from a Google back-end to Bing's.

about a week ago
top

Google Sees Biggest Search Traffic Drop Since 2009 As Yahoo Gains Ground

KugelKurt Re:Isn't Yahoo search just Google? (155 comments)

Yahoo has "Powered by Bing" at the bottom of all their searches. It's not that hard to check.

So? The claim was that before the Bing switch, Yahoo used Google. That's false. Yahoo had their own search technology which they then licensed to Microsoft.

about a week ago
top

Google Sees Biggest Search Traffic Drop Since 2009 As Yahoo Gains Ground

KugelKurt Re:Bling... (155 comments)

The only reason Bing has 12.5% of the market is because it is the default search engine for any MS-based product, including (especially) its cell phones. Most people switch to Google as quickly as possible, but some just keep the defaults.

I doubt Windows Phone has a market share big enough to make a dent. More likely Siri from iOS.

about three weeks ago
top

Google Sees Biggest Search Traffic Drop Since 2009 As Yahoo Gains Ground

KugelKurt Re:Still not part of the lexicon (155 comments)

Good for them but I highly doubt the phrase "Yahoo it" will catch on.

Why shoukd it? Search is not Yahoo's primary product. The web portal is.

about three weeks ago
top

Google Sees Biggest Search Traffic Drop Since 2009 As Yahoo Gains Ground

KugelKurt Re:Duck Duck Go (155 comments)

No. There's really no benefit. Your personal browser fingerprint can identify you, so what does it matter?

Browser fingerbrinting relies on stuff like installed fonts, screen resolution, etc. – i.e. things not tweakable on many mobile platforms.

about three weeks ago
top

KDE Releases Frameworks 5

KugelKurt Re:What's been removed,dumbed down,made incompatib (87 comments)

What's been removed,dumbed down,made incompatible?

You know this is a release of the Frameworks, right?
Nothing has been dumbed down, kde3support is gone but other than that KF5 is mostly source-compatible with kdelibs4.

about 7 months ago
top

Which desktop environment do you like the best?

KugelKurt Re:icewm (611 comments)

Can't say I ever experienced those issues. No idea which distro and which DE you used.

about 8 months ago

Submissions

KugelKurt hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

KugelKurt has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?