Beta

Slashdot: News for Nerds

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:Great... (526 comments)

He is a politician. So no.

But when judging whether a pol's statement is true, the best policy is to try to figure out what would be most convenient for him. If he's telling you what he wants you to believe then it's difficult to figure out whether he's lying. If he's saying something completely different, for example he's trying to justify cutting the defense budget he probably wants you to believe the world is a safe place and we have too many troops.

Which is directly contradicted when he says that Ukraine is being attacked by the Russians.

Therefore he's almost certainly telling the truth about the Russian military in Ukraine.

6 hours ago
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:Great... (526 comments)

They Nuland videos are quite interesting if you insist that everything the United States does is by definition evil. Otherwise they're good examples of how easy it is to over-complicate things when discussing foreign affairs.

The first, for example, says nothing about subverting anything, despite the fact that is the Youtube headline. It says we've spent $5 Billion trying to prepare Ukraine for the EU. That's not necessarily subversion even if you think Ukraine should not be in the EU, because "ready for the EU" includes a lot of things everyone likes (ie: reduced corruption, somewhat fair justice systems, democracy that only sucks a little, etc.).

It's very interesting that the second video you included was the same woman working around Europcratic ineffectiveness. She's not saying "fuck the EU"because she thinks the EU should go off and die, she's saying "fuck the EU" because she's pretty sure whatever plan they come up with in their ginormous 28-Excellency committee will suck, and therefore the US should go ahead with it's plans regardless of the EU.

Which makes me curious:
Are you a fan of the EU?

As for Obama, he's President. He IS US policy. Pretty much the entire reason his job was created was that when we let our ginourmas committee of 13 run it it was a fucking disaster. I'm always skeptical of someone who uses the phrase "Imperialist" because it stopped meaning anything several decades ago, and people started throwing it at any political movement they happened to disagree with. See every political movement has a foreign ally, and if you like the movement the ally is clearly a benign state promoting good things. If you dislike the movement it's all an Imperialist front for the foreign ally.

In this case there is literally no logical reason to oppose Obama's policy on grounds of Imperialism. He has done nothing to Libya's internal politics except blow up the guy who wanted to massacre a bunch of protestors. He doesn't pick a militia leader for Secretary of Defense. He hasn;t gone over their Constitution looking for areas where it differs from ours, and then trying to force them to fix it. He just blew the shit out of an asshole and went away.

6 hours ago
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:Great... (526 comments)

So your argument is that a rebellion that boasted about blowing multiple Ukrainian military aircraft out of the sky couldn't possibly blow an aircraft out of the sky?

That's kinda my problem with all the rebel justifications. They're very clearly reaching, and reaching far.

7 hours ago
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:Great... (526 comments)

Yeah, but if we send a battalion or three it'll be even harder to convince the Republicans to go along with force cuts.

More importantly for Obama, if Obama's demanding we fire a substantial portion of the Army while he's mobilizing troops to rattle their sabres in front of fucking Russia, it looks really bad. And in a few months we have a midterm election.

What Obama wants right now if for Putin and Bibi to shut the fuck up, go the fuck home, and stop talking foreign policy so Obama can get everyone talking about how evil the Republicans are for opposing a major minimum wage increase.

7 hours ago
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:This is patently false. (526 comments)

Are you high?

The tactic the civilians're describing would only work if Malaysia Airlines agreed to fly right over the Ukrainian Air Force's target area. And if they did that, and the Ukrainians repaid the favor by destroying their plane, why the fuck wouldn't they be all over CNN with the betrayal?

Sensor data is really easy to fake.

7 hours ago
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:Great... (526 comments)

The easiest way top tell the BS propaganda from reality is figure out who has a motive to lie.

In this case a) Putin obviously has a motive to shell Ukrainian military units fighting ethnic Russian separatists, b) Putin would have clear reason to lie about that shit, and c) Obama's trying really hard to convince everyone foreign policy is perfectly fine.

I wouldn't be totally shocked if it turns out some idiot is misinterpreting satellite photos in DC. But I would be totally shocked to learn that the photos themselves are fake.

yesterday
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Re:Great... (526 comments)

Great, more Mericans who believe whatever the media-military complex tells them.

I don't believe everything they tell me. But generally when they're making shit up (ie: Saddam's WMD) it's because somebody important has a real interest in promoting the lie.

Putin has an interest in promoting the separatists in Eastern Ukraine. He's using them to counter-balance the pro-Western forces in Kiev. We know this because he actually promotes the separatists. Which means having his artillery nail the Ukrainians who are fighting said separatists is plausible. More plausible then that, some low-level artillery officer who happens to be stationed in the region thinks his boss will be very pleased if the Ukrainian Army has trouble retaking Donetsk.

Obama making this shit up is not particularly plausible. He wants foreign policy to go the fuck away for a few months so he can make an economic case for firing Boehnor to the American people. If Putin is actively operating in Ukraine, bordering Romania (which is in NATO) deserves to know we'll send troops to Bucharest on short notice. But Obama's latest budget includes force reductions. One of Hillary Clinton's foreign policy initiatives was a reset of relations with Russia. That actually worked pretty well, for her term as Secretary of State.

yesterday
top

Satellite Images Show Russians Shelling Ukraine

NicBenjamin Great... (526 comments)

The side that apparently blew a 300-civilian passenger jet out of the sky because they're too dumb to know what a Boeing looks like is getting direct military support from a major regional power which just happens to have nuclear weapons.

And I thought my hometown of Detroit was fucked.

yesterday
top

Ars Editor Learns Feds Have His Old IP Addresses, Full Credit Card Numbers

NicBenjamin Re:This is news? (216 comments)

Protip: Any statement that starts with "I just pointed out" is a restatement of your position.

Hopefully next time you'll be able to switch from debating to insults better, you nabob-faced cogswillet.

yesterday
top

Private Data On iOS Devices Not So Private After All

NicBenjamin Re:Expectation of privacy (100 comments)

That works, when you remember to do it.

Lots of these little privacy tips are like that. They work great, as long as you specifically remember to do them even when it's 3:30 AM and you've had a few too many to drink.

yesterday
top

In France, Most Comments on Gaza Conflict Yanked From Mainstream News Sites

NicBenjamin Re:War that cannot be settled (485 comments)

We agreed to support Israel when we made them a "Major Non-NATO Ally" back in the 90s.

So pretty much the only thing we can do is cajole the hell out of them, and pray that someday the EU makes itself a cohesive enough block that the threat of an EU blockade will actually get them to the negotiating table.

On the Palestinian side Abbas would already be at the table, if he thought Netanyahu had any intention of making a single concession. Since all Bibi seems to want is zero terrorism within Israel, and he seems to have achieved that solely by relying on military force, he'll continue to create ridiculous distractions like "the Palestinians won;t recognize us as a Jewish state,*" and invades Gaza whenever the assholes running the place figure out a new chink in Israel's armor.

*This is ridiculous because the phrase "Jewish state" is meaningless under international law. If you're a state you set your own religion. The whole point of Westphalia was that states don;t judge other state's religion Which means if Abbas recognizes Israel as a state, and it's head of government (currently Netanyahu) says ISrael is Jewish, Abbas has already recognized Israel as a Jewish state. This is why no country has ever recognized Israel explicitly as a "Jewish state," in those terms.They frequently go on with long sentences about the Jewish people setting up their own country, but under international law the phrase Jewish state is meaningless BS so none of them will ever use it.

yesterday
top

In France, Most Comments on Gaza Conflict Yanked From Mainstream News Sites

NicBenjamin Re:The Muslim world cares so much for the Palestin (485 comments)

Bullshit.

Jordan is majority Palestinian. Lebanon has a huge Palestinian minority.

They don't give the refugees citizenship, but the refugees generally aren't asking for citizenship. They're asking to be allowed to go home. And home is currently controlled by Israel (mostly in Israel proper, but the rest of the former mandate created a lot of foreign refugees, too).

yesterday
top

In France, Most Comments on Gaza Conflict Yanked From Mainstream News Sites

NicBenjamin Re:Meta-problem (485 comments)

You can say the same about literally any conflict.

If only the UK had been willing to give up six counties, or Irish Catholics had been willing to abandoned those counties en masse; or Lebanese Muslims had not minded that they were second-class citizens, or Lebanese Christians had been willing to recognize that the majority changed; or Iraqi Sunnis/Sh'as were willing to give up everything they hold dear; etc. It's really easy to sit in air conditioning and write peace proposals which would make everyone better off, the trick is convincing them that said proposal is better then continuing to fight. Which is fucking hard because if there was some obvious compromise then neither side would have bothered fighting in the first fucking place.

The intractable issues ion the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are that a) Israel demands an unrealistic level of security in return for peace, and b) the Palestinians really hate acknowledging that they aren't gonna get all of the East Jerusalem. The problem with a) is that all peace deals result in an immediate uptick in terrorism as assholes seek to murder their way back to full-scale war, which means if you want long-term peace you have to put up with an Omagh Bombing. But whenever that happens the Israeli's fire the PM who just signed the damn peace agreement and elect Netanyahu. Which feeds into b), because Netanyahu gets a lot of votes from the 180-190k people who live in territory Israel would have to cede.

The current hold-up seems to be that Israel honestly believes that they can keep virtually 100% security forever, as the rest of the world won;t call them on abusing Palestinians and whenever anybody on the other side figures out a way to break through the bars and kill a Jew they can just "mow the lawn." If you offered Abbas the deal that Arafat took home from Camp David (technically he didn't reject it, he said he was gonna consider it back home) he'd immediately take it, but there's no way in hell Netanyahu would ever make the offer because Netanyahu want's 100% perfect security.

yesterday
top

In France, Most Comments on Gaza Conflict Yanked From Mainstream News Sites

NicBenjamin Re:Meta-problem (485 comments)

International law is pretty vague on whether you actually have to kill every member of an ethnic group in a territory for it to be called "genocide." The reason is pretty simple: if you insist everyone actually has to die for it to be genocide that creates a huge loophole. The bad guy simply has to kill enough of them that the rest know they damn well better run and it's not technically genocide because almost all of them successfully ran.

But since a lot of inter-ethnic conflict involves one asshole threatening to kill every member of another group, succeeding at some much less evil goal (ie: getting them evicted, beating up a couple hundred activists, maybe a mass rape campaign, etc.), which convinces everyone to run away rather then be killed, scholars have a continuum of evil, starting at ethnic cleansing and running up to actual genocide.

What actually happens in Israel is frequently on the low end of ethnic cleansing. There's a lot of unofficial, and officially deplored Jewish violence against Palestinians and suspected sympathizers that the authorities never seem to be able to stop. In '47 and '48 it was really bad. At Dier Yassam 107 civilians were massacred by the Israeli military, which released numerous press releases claiming that was evil, but never actually charged anyone with a crime for it. Similarly the first UN envoy to the region (Count Bernadotte af Wisborg) was murdered by Jews in the Lehi. Their military formation was disarmed, and a couple were charged with membership in a terrorist organization, but everyone was immediately pardoned and sent off to war. It created an atmosphere in which Arabs made the fairly logical assumption that some Jewish asshole would murder them and get away with it when the Israeli Army won, which in turn meant almost all Palestinians living within what is now the Green Line fled the Israeli War of Independence. That's textbook ethnic cleansing. You make an ethnic group feel unsafe, and they go away.

Today it's quite a bit better, but there's still a very influential section of Israeli society dedicated to ensuring that the Palestinian population knows they are non really wanted. Price tag attacks, the Israeli Courts total inability to protect the only Palestinian in the country with paperwork proving he owns land there, etc. prove it. Somebody in Israel wants Palestinians to think moving out is a real good option, the rest of the country ain't stopping them, and if they succeed it will be (by definition) ethnic cleansing.

Don't get me wrong. I'm not claiming that Hamas are wonderful saints, or freedom fighters, or that they would not do worse to Israeli Jews then the Israeli Jews are currently doing to the Palestinians, or even that they wouldn't end up treating Palestinians worse then the Israeli government does. Same with the PA. But none of that has any bearing on whether the Israelis are being honorable.

yesterday
top

In France, Most Comments on Gaza Conflict Yanked From Mainstream News Sites

NicBenjamin Re:maybe (485 comments)

But it's not new so nobody cares. It may not be right, but that's how it works.

Think about it. In the past year or so South Sudan, the Central African Republic, Syria, Iraq, Libya, Ukraine, and the Israel-Palestine-Gaza-mess have all been on the news. Most of these will have annual casualties well above the Israel-Palestine-Gaza-mess, but most of that does not matter on the 27th of July, because only Israel and the Ukrainians are currently new.

More importantly if you;re a Westerner the only one of these crises where anybody will actually care about your call to action is Israel, because Israel is the only one that participates in the global economy. Syria isn't going to spawn a Tesla anytime soon, so if the west threatens to prevent Syrian electric car companies from selling vehicles the Syrians won't give a shit. They'll actually like it, because that gives them one more excuse for when they fuck up.

yesterday
top

In France, Most Comments on Gaza Conflict Yanked From Mainstream News Sites

NicBenjamin Re:Or maybe you're not so good at math (485 comments)

You're about half right here.

The fact these comments are banned probably means they're anti-semitic. But the closest thing the French have to a major anti-Semitic party is the national Front, they never get more then 25%, and that high-point only was only after their leader denounced anti-Semitism. Which indicates the Anti-Semitic percentage in France is probably under 5%. They seem to talk a whole lot, but in my experience the more a political ideology talks about itself the less relevant it is to reality. So Anti-Semitism is a problem France has to deal with, but that's true in every western nation and a lot of the non-western ones.

What's extremely unusual is the total lack of pro-Semites. Nobody in France is taking the view that Israel is being totally reasonable in attacking Gaza. Nobody is even taking the view that Israel is a respectable nation who should be allowed to do what needs to be done. They may think Israel's policy of "mowing the lawn" is justified, but clearly they don't like it so much that they'll take 15 minutes and write an online comment saying that.

Israel's core problem is that, while the Israeli people seem to have abandoned the Oslo process as unworkable, and adopted a policy of constant low-level attacks mitigated by occasional brutal offensives into Arab-controlled territory, literally the entire rest of the world is still a fan of Oslo. Re-invading Gaza every few years reminds them that Israel and the Palestinians are not making progress, and it also makes Israel seem like the roadblock. If all you hear about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is that two Israelis died, and then Israel started a campaign killing 900-odd Palestinians and a couple-dozen Israeli troops, you ain't gonna come away with the impression Israel isn't the bad guy.

yesterday
top

Ars Editor Learns Feds Have His Old IP Addresses, Full Credit Card Numbers

NicBenjamin Re:This is news? (216 comments)

I'm explaining my position because you keep restating yours. Last time I checked the international sign that one was participating in a debate was that one kept restating one's position in response to the other person's position.

If you want to end an internet debate, that's as easy as not getting laid. Simply stop trying to get the last word in.

2 days ago
top

Ars Editor Learns Feds Have His Old IP Addresses, Full Credit Card Numbers

NicBenjamin Re:This is news? (216 comments)

So you think I'm not acknowledging the government abuses power? I have done that quite a few times. It's just that, unlike you, I'm not basing this entirely on a theory I read in a SciFi book about the UK or Russia, or an 18th-century apologist for slavery's ridiculous claim that he cared about freedom. Note that last sentence? It was an acknowledgement of governmental abuse of power.

My argument is based on the actual track record of abuses the US government has done. This database is a lot less dangerous then almost any other for two reasons:

1) It belongs to the TSA, who don't really have the capacity to go out and oppress people themselves, and are never gonna turn over their information to people who do (ie: th FBI, Border Patrol, etc.). It just doesn't happen.

2) It doesn't contain much sensitive information. The info it contains is a lot less sensitive than the info Census and Social Security have on you, so even assuming that Federal agencies start leaking like sieves and reporting likely Jews to the KKK they probably aren't gonna bother searching for the guy who tried the kosher meal this one time in 2009.

2 days ago
top

Private Data On iOS Devices Not So Private After All

NicBenjamin Re:Expectation of privacy (100 comments)

If you're doing something incriminating don't use paper either. Governments have spent literally centuries figuring out how to make a piece of paper spill it's secrets.

At this point expecting the government not to be able to get it's hands on your data if it really wants to is pretty damn naive. Folks who think that are like the mid-17th century folks who tried to skimp on telling the King their last names. They could make it work for the first few decades, but eventually the bureaucracy figured out the technique and it got to be really hard to tell the authorities in Lincoln you'd paid your taxes back home in Lancaster using the name Alan Smith, while telling the guys in Lancaster "Oh I took care of that in Lincoln, just ask them about Alan Jones and his taxes."

Your devices leave fingerprints everywhere. It isn't physically possible to force the wi-fi network on the Wendy's you just drove past to destroy the record it has of your cell phone trying to connect. Your phone probably left some evidence linking back to you, unless you bought a burner and you're just gonna throw the damn thing out. But a) that doesn't work very well for large groups because if everyone's always changing their number there are massive co-ordination issues ensuring everyone can still talk to everyone else, and b) since you're using your phone exactly like a drug lord does the local police need to have some record of you in their files. Even if it doesn't say anything beyond "this dude is fanatical about his privacy, so he should be a low-priority suspect when the system points out that he a) lives in the same apartment complex the known drug smuggler lives in, b) makes extensive use of burner cell phones, and c) takes a couple foreign trips a year for which he pays cash on the day of the flight;" it has to exist.

2 days ago
top

Ars Editor Learns Feds Have His Old IP Addresses, Full Credit Card Numbers

NicBenjamin Re:This is news? (216 comments)

I don't think you're too dumb to process it.

I just don't believe you're emotionally capable of separating your desire to crush NSA databases from other government databases. Your inability to clearly articulate a potential abuse for this database, particularly any potential abuse that outweighs it's usefulness as a tool to cut down on smuggling endangered species/drug running/etc. is evidence of that point.

4 days ago

Submissions

NicBenjamin hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

NicBenjamin has no journal entries.

Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...