×

Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

YouTube Considering an Ad-Free, Subscription-Based Version

NitWit005 Re:Ad free...until they reach critical mass (225 comments)

Premium cable TV you mean? Cable was originally mostly rebroadcasts of transmissions that already had ads in it for people that couldn't get a signal.

Most media companies dream of having everyone paying a monthly fee instead of relying on ads. You have to constantly seek out people to sell ad space to and you're always at the mercy of the price of ads and seasonal changes. The usual issue is that people are totally unwilling to pay anywhere near what advertisers will pay to show them ads. Youtube's per-person income is low enough that some people will probably happily pay.

about 2 months ago
top

Will the Google Car Turn Out To Be the Apple Newton of Automobiles?

NitWit005 Silly expectations (287 comments)

The expectation of this article is that Google will somehow shortly produce a car which will completely replace drivers in all circumstances. Clearly, that's the eventual goal, but that's not needed to produce something useful. Car companies are already churning out various incomplete solutions that help with highway driving or parking.

I expect their initial product to be something that works as a taxi in semi-controlled circumstances, or something that makes driving more convenient, but which requires intervention some of the time. Either of which would be a viable product.

Early cell phones were overpriced bricks, but they were still useful to some people. It took a huge investment from many companies and quite a bit of time to get to the point where people considered dropping their land lines. Replacing the old generation of technology is not usually a sudden process, but involves a lot of gradual improvement.

about 2 months ago
top

Why Do Contextual Ads Fail?

NitWit005 Low threshold for success (249 comments)

People run businesses where the *only* source of new customers are those targeted ads that apparently "don't work". Clearly, they work well enough, for some people.

If you look at engagement rings, the internet will be filled with engagement ring ads for a week. Obviously, you'll ignore most of them (unless you buy a thousand rings?), but those companies would have gone broke if it wasn't working. They're spending a lot of cash. The thing is, those ads might cost something like $5 per thousand "impressions". If the average sale nets you $300, it's worth your while if the ad works at a rate better than once per 60,000 views. A lot of these companies carefully tweak their bid prices, and sometimes make no sales for long periods because they've been outbid in the areas they're targeting.

Would it be worth running those ads with no targeting? Probably not. People don't buy that many engagement rings in their life. Jewelry companies have always carefully placed ads so that they'd be seen by people who were likely to actually buy jewelry.

about 3 months ago
top

EU Gives Google Privacy Policy Suggestions About Data Protection

NitWit005 Google is pretty good here (42 comments)

Read Google's privacy policy: http://www.google.com/policies.... It seems fairly readable to me. A list per-service might be theoretically useful, but I doubt a normal human would read through each of them.

But take a moment and look at what Google offers here. Google lets you see most of your data on your account dashboard, view and edit your search history, view and edit what ad categories are targeted at you, sign up for account activity reports, and has fairly readable multi-lingual help pages. That's better than almost anyone else.

Maybe Google's advertising practices or monopoly power are issues, but on the issue of data transparency, I think they passed the "good enough" level quite some time ago. The real issue appears to be that even if a company provides good information, no one will bother to look at it.

about 3 months ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Software Issue Tracking Transparency - Good Or Bad?

NitWit005 Remember the support costs (159 comments)

Everyone who self serves by using your bug website is saving you money, if it causes a support call to be avoided. That's not always going to happen, but it's probably avoided hundreds or thousands of avoided support calls.

A lot of people suggested making it only open to customers. That's fine, but recognize there is a cost there. Have you ever tried to get login info for a vendor website at a big company? It's often impossible. Some guy wrote it down on a notepad 7 years ago. What happens is you end up calling or emailing the company directly, possibly spending time confirming your identity, and thus wasting their money. Some companies have tried to mitigate that cost by allowing anyone with an email at a customer domain access, but that only works if they have such a domain.

You should be able to estimate these costs by talking to support and looking at the page view information and customer queries. Just present the information and let management decide. Whatever the outcome, you'll look good if you present the site (and thus you) as having been saving money all this time.

about 3 months ago
top

The Physics of Space Battles

NitWit005 Re:After working missile defense for years... (470 comments)

Yes, but remember that you can detect the missile you're trying to intercept because it's relatively close, and because it's giving off light/heat/smoke/etc due to its method of acceleration. In space the closeness goes away, and you're going to be extremely difficult to find. Giving a hint to your location by burning a bunch of fuel is going to be undesirable. Stealthy tactics, including a lot of boring drifting, will probably dominate.

about 3 months ago
top

Cable Companies: We're Afraid Netflix Will Demand Payment From ISPs

NitWit005 What? (200 comments)

What part of that suggests they're afraid Netflix will threaten them?

about 5 months ago
top

MIT's Ted Postol Presents More Evidence On Iron Dome Failures

NitWit005 Re:Iron Dome is clearly a conspiracy! (454 comments)

The problem is, history would suggest that you might be wrong, despite your firsthand experience. During the Gulf War, people were extremely confident that the American patriot missiles were shooting down Iraqi missiles, and they pointed to the clear rocket flying into the sky followed by a nice pop. It turned out that was often the operators detonating them after a miss to be safe. It's still not clear how many were shot down, but it's definitely not what was perceived (or claimed) at the time.

about 5 months ago
top

Yahoo's Diversity Record Is Almost As Bad As Google's

NitWit005 Re:Sexism (435 comments)

Ugh... except that Google said nothing of the sort. They plainly stated they want to hire more woman and see it as an issue.

about 6 months ago
top

Computer Game Reveals 'Space-Time' Neurons In the Eye

NitWit005 Re:Is this all that surprising? (105 comments)

Even just reading from that quote, the information did actually reach the brain first. It just didn't reach what the authors define as the "higher brain centers". You're not contradiction him. I'm not sure how the electromagnetic field strength of the heart was supposed to be relevant either.

about 8 months ago
top

Our Education System Is Failing IT

NitWit005 Cost and opportunities (306 comments)

He asks the question: "So why do we tolerate IT pros who don't understand the basics of how a computer or network works?".

If someone is skilled at IT, deeply understands computers and networking, and has critical thinking skills, they can get a better job. There are few people like that anywhere. Why would they be sitting around in IT? They should be designing a router.

And frankly speaking, they don't need to know the deep depths of how everything works. It would be silly for a hospital to demand that every staff member have the highest level of education. It's a waste of resources. The vast majority of work can be done by less skilled people. Just like in a hospital, if a diagnosis seems difficult, you can bring in the expert. You don't need a building full of experts. Sure, it would be nice, but the waste would be staggering.

about 8 months ago
top

Leaked Letter Shows UK ISPs and Government At War Over Default Filters

NitWit005 Not exactly great politics (142 comments)

You need someone's cooperation, so you send a letter demanding they do a bunch of things you know they object to on short notice and then demand money at the same time? Good luck with that.

about a year and a half ago
top

Math and Science Popular With Students Until They Realize They're Hard

NitWit005 No, the liberal arts are too easy (580 comments)

Every major field that's taught in university has vastly more information than can be taught to students. The STEM fields are hardly unique that way.

What's odd is that the science and technology majors make an effort to push students as hard as possible, and the other majors choose not to. Look back on the standards at schools 100 years ago and you'll often see that the liberal arts curium seems way more difficult and thorough than it is today.

about a year and a half ago
top

Student Project Could Kill Digital Ad Targeting

NitWit005 Assuming they use cookies (177 comments)

A lot of ad platforms already have a non-cookie mechanism working. Storing hashes of user agent and IP address is common. You have to go through a proxy or otherwise change IP address for that not to work. It's easy to find services advertising this as a feature: http://www.ipfingerprint.com/we_dont_use_cookies.aspx The truth is that cookies aren't that great for tracking. People want to know your activity across browsers and devices. That requires using additional information like phone unique identifier (sent by apps), website logins, billing address fields, coupon usage, and so on. That information can be tied together to track you. You're not going to be able to prevent that kind of tracking by messing with cookies.

about a year and a half ago
top

Can Ride-Sharing Startup Lyft Survive the SoCal Heat?

NitWit005 Re:Wait, what? (133 comments)

If a friend and I alternate driving each other, we've still made a financial transaction and are competing with taxis. It's just a barter based transaction.

about a year and a half ago
top

Can Ride-Sharing Startup Lyft Survive the SoCal Heat?

NitWit005 Re:Lyft's rating system is bonkers (133 comments)

You're falsely assuming they want average. They probably want excellent service only. If you want to ensure people only get excellent service, you're going to have to have a harsh cutoff built into the system somewhere.

about a year and a half ago
top

Bruce Schneier: Why Collecting More Data Doesn't Increase Safety

NitWit005 More basic issues (149 comments)

I suppose this is a problem, but we have to be realistic here. The FBI has failed repeatedly to complete large software projects. They have trouble handling even clear-cut data. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_Case_File

about a year and a half ago
top

Why Self-Driving Cars Are Still a Long Way Down the Road

NitWit005 Re:Computers can't bluff (352 comments)

Google's cars already have some social interactions like this built in. If it's at a 4 way intersection with stop signs and people aren't obeying the rules to let it through, it will eventually assert itself just like a human driver would. Any defensive behavior a human does is programmable. They're all fairly simple when you get right down to it.

about a year and a half ago
top

Electrical Engineer Unemployment Soars; Software Developers' Rate Drops to 2.2%

NitWit005 Reads like a press release (419 comments)

This reads like a press release from IEEE-USA. It doesn't sound like they have any clue why the employment numbers have changed, but they want to complain about visas.

about a year and a half ago
top

The Hypocrisy In Silicon Valley's Big Talk On Innovation

NitWit005 Perception Issue (208 comments)

There is definitely less risk taking, but there is a big issue of perception. Things just don't seem mind blowing after a while, even if there is tons of work left to be done in that area. You see this again and again: cars got boring, planes got boring, nuclear energy got boring, space flight got boring. Everything gets boring eventually. Most computing related areas have lost their cultural edge. It's hard to pitch things as being innovative, even if they really are, and have people buy the idea.

about 2 years ago

Submissions

NitWit005 hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

NitWit005 has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?