Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

The Odd Effects of Being Struck By Lightning

Prune Re:thanks for that great information (185 comments)

The only assumption made is that of standard semantics of the use of a qualitative term to indicate a quantity in an imprecise or relative manner. In the case of your post, "fragile" stands for "fragile relative to the average expectation of a population relevant to the context of this subject or discussion". Of course, the assumption of standard language semantics presupposes a more basic one: that one's interlocutor is an entity to which assignment of semantic understanding is apropos; I must admit, though, the possibility that in this assumption I have erred, and you're but a chatbot.

2 days ago
top

The Odd Effects of Being Struck By Lightning

Prune Pretty bad example of a radical change. (185 comments)

I know this is Slashdot, but even here the level of stereotyping and hateful crowd mentality exhibited by your post is an eyesore. So let me take this occasion to mirror your posting style by reminding you that, if you perhaps on occasion ventured out from your parents' basement, you might find that there's little basis to your intimation of a statistically significant correlation between involvement in the financial industry and being a "mean, ornery son of a bitch".

2 days ago
top

The Odd Effects of Being Struck By Lightning

Prune thanks for that great information (185 comments)

BS. The nervous system is an electrochemical system, not an electrical one; and, while it is physically fragile, it is not nearly as electrically fragile as you suggest, exactly because it is electrochemical rather than electrical in nature. This is a significant reason why 90% of lightning strike victims survive (the skin's lower resistance being another), and why execution through electrocution is nowhere close to being an instant process.

2 days ago
top

Breakthrough In LED Construction Increases Efficiency By 57 Percent

Prune LEDs have better spectrum than CFL, but still crap (181 comments)

Even high CRI (color rendering index) LED lighting has a nasty spike in the blue region. See: http://www.ecse.rpi.edu/~schub... This is very different than the smooth blackbody spectrum of solar radiation, though not nearly as bad as the many narrow spikes of a CFL bulb. Color reproduction still suffers, even if not as much as in the case of fluorescents. Compare to a high-end incandescent bulb (such as used in museums and galleries, and in my house), which use filtering reflectors to match daylight spectrum very closely. You can only do this with the smooth spectra of blackbody radiators (such as incandescents) because we lack sufficiently specific (narrow band) filters to deal with the spikes in LEDs, fluorescents, and HIDs, at least without going to extreme expense. So for those of us to whom it matters that artificial lighting should strive to reproduce natural lighting reasonably well, incandescents remain a necessity. At the same time, I do realize that to others efficiency matters, and that is becoming an increasingly significant factor, especially through the actions of the anti-nuclear power lobby.

3 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Mod parent down--talking about wrong paper (356 comments)

You're discussing a paper by Rovelli and Vidotto, whereas this discussion is about an unrelated paper by Mersini-Houghton and Pfeiffer. They're unrelated because in the latter an event horizon never forms. Moreover, the Rovelli and Vidotto paper is garbage--see http://backreaction.blogspot.c...

5 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Re:That's not what she's saying (356 comments)

Nothing new under the sun. Look up the old term for a black holes resulting from stellar collapse, "frozen star" (after all, to an outside observer, the collapse takes an infinite time to reach the formation of an event horizon due to time dilation--and according to this paper, even that doesn't happen).

5 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Mod parent down (356 comments)

Black holes are observationally indistinguishable from dark grey ones (the non-observational difference being whether there is an event horizon).

5 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Re:But do we see them? (356 comments)

Black holes are observationally indistinguishable from dark grey ones. There's no conflict between astronomical evidence on the one hand, and the paper and its thesis of non-formation on the other (a thesis that is part of a decades-old lineage of arguments, going back to the fact that an event horizon takes infinite time to form from the viewpoint of an outside observer).

5 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Mod parent down (356 comments)

Because a black hole is understood as something with an event horizon. You don't get to define astrophysical terms; they mean what they're understood to mean by those versed in the art. My suggestion is that we go back to the old and just-as-relevant-today term "frozen star", but I'm not arrogant enough to push for it in the way you want to redefine terms just because you will it.

5 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Re:Black holes can exist without a singularity (356 comments)

Mod parent down. He claims he hasn't read the paper, and then takes a guess anyway and not only completely misses, but also presents something absolutely wrong. I can only conclude he got modded up because he posted something appearing vaguely scientific and maybe-perhaps-kind-of-cool-sounding. The facts: Hawking radiation cannot prevent formation of a singularity once an event horizon has formed. Parent poster's appeal to time dilation is a red herring: ultimately this is a matter of geometry--if you start from a configuration that has no event horizon and then one forms, then inside the new event horizon, the geometry of space-time is such that a singularity is a requisite component. Note that the paper itself makes none of the crackpot claims that the parent poster does--it argues that an event horizon doesn't form in the first place because Hawking radiation dissipates the mass of the collapsing star sufficiently to prevent a horizon. And that is eminently plausible, unlike the outlandish proposition in the post I'm responding to.

5 days ago
top

Physicist Claims Black Holes Mathematically Don't Exist

Prune Re:Black holes can exist without a singularity (356 comments)

Mod parent down. Hawking radiation cannot intervene in such a manner _inside_ the event horizon and prevent a singularity. It dissipates mass-energy outside an event horizon only. There is no known or even posited quantum effect that would magically prevent a singularity inside an extant event horizon in the way the parent poster fantasizes. Moreover, parent poster would have saved himself the embarrassment had he actually taken a mere cursory look at the paper, which discusses something completely different: the dissipation of the collapsing star's mass before an event horizon can ever form.

5 days ago
top

US Revamping Its Nuclear Arsenal

Prune Re:Folks need to see 'The Day After' (336 comments)

Mod parent up--he is spot on that they should have been used against the Chinese troops supporting the North. This was even more justifiable in terms of the massive suffering that would have been prevented than even the savings in lives lost from an alternative of ground invasion by the decisive strikes on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

about a week ago
top

US Revamping Its Nuclear Arsenal

Prune Re:MAD (336 comments)

> he was going to suicide

"Suicide" is not a verb.

about a week ago
top

Apple's "Warrant Canary" Has Died

Prune Re:See Apple's privacy site for details (236 comments)

No, it is not "here in the open", because "250 and fewer" includes zero as an option. As per the Ars article someone already posted early on in this /. discussion, http://arstechnica.com/tech-po..., the 0-250 range is a reflection of new guidelines from the department of justice. A canary almost becomes unworkable for companies now because saying you have not received such a warrant in the given time period is equivalent to saying you have received 0 orders, which is more specific than the smallest allowable range of 0-250.

about two weeks ago
top

Sci-Fi Authors and Scientists Predict an Optimistic Future

Prune Re:Jean-Luc Picard is my idol... (191 comments)

Contrast this to the reboot of Battlestar Galactica , which paints a very
realistic portrait of advancement of science/artificial intelligence causing the downfall of humanity..


FTFY

about two weeks ago
top

UN Study Shows Record-High Increases For Atmospheric CO2 In 2013

Prune Re:I'm pro-global warming (427 comments)

So like a typical ideologue, when you fail to summon logical arguments to support your view, you turn in your desperation to your last resort: abusive language. I hope you realize that you're just revealing that for you, this is about emotional investment, not rationality.

about three weeks ago

Submissions

top

First commercial carbon capture project is failing

Prune Prune writes  |  more than 3 years ago

Prune (557140) writes "A Saskatchewan report that the world's first commercial carbon capture project is failing could be grave news for those involved in efforts to blunt humanity's contribution to climate change.
It's a story with global implications, potentially bad ones, for the energy sector: http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/greenpage/environment/carbon-injected-underground-now-leaking-saskatchewan-farmers-study-says-113276449.html"

Link to Original Source

Journals

Prune has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?