Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!



Ask Slashdot: Best Way to Learn C# For Game Programming?

Shaterri Re:Play with Unity3D (254 comments)

To reinforce this: Building your own engine is a great way to fall into a trap that you won't escape for years if not decades. If you're interested in building a game, then you should build a game, and use the toolchain that lets you get to your game as quickly as possible. Right now that's a race between Unity and Unreal Engine 4, and while neither one has perfect support, I'd say the userbase for Unity is sufficiently deep that it's a better starting point. Don't worry, you'll still get plenty of opportunity to code (and to learn C# - another reason to go with Unity over UE4, if that's the language you really want), but there'll be enough that you don't have to code that you can focus on the fundamentals of building your game.

about a month ago

Regex Golf, xkcd, and Peter Norvig

Shaterri Is the problem actually NP-complete? (172 comments)

My reading of Norvig's blog post is that he suggests his specific approach (stapling together short regexps with ORs) requires solving the NP-Complete Set Cover problem, but he doesn't actually say anything about whether the core problem (match everything in list A and nothing in list B) does; it's conceivable that e.g. some sort of dynamical programming approach could do the job more efficiently than Norvig's algorithm does. Does anyone know whether the root problem (to avoid having to do the optimization, just phrase it as 'is there a separating regexp for the sets A and B of length less than k?') is specifically known to be NP-complete?

about 7 months ago

Does Software Need a Siskel and Ebert?

Shaterri Does the NYT review wrenches? (169 comments)

With the exception of entertainment and the rare 'culturally relevant' application, the vast majority of software is primarily a tool to get its job done, rather than an item of artistic merit in its own right. The New York Times reviews are — for the most part — cultural reviews; they're not the appropriate venue for most software reviews.

With that said, there are those exceptions where one can speak about the artistic or cultural merits of a piece of software, and my strong impression is that the Times has never really stopped speaking about those. The difference between the '80s and today is that at that point, there was so much less understood and so much more that was new in the world of software that a lot of what came out was of cultural relevance and worth talking about on those merits.

about 8 months ago

California's Surreal Retroactive Tax On Tech Startup Investors

Shaterri Re:California (514 comments)

I'm not going to argue with 'severely over budget' (thank you, Prop 13) but the last information available for California suggests that federal spending in the state was substantially less (by roughly 25%) than federal revenues from the state; California is, on a per-capita basis and certainly on an overall basis, one of the largest net givers to the federal budget, not a taker. Do you have any specific reason to believe that that's changed in the last few years?

about a year and a half ago

Why Ray Kurzweil's Google Project May Be Doomed To Fail

Shaterri Re:You have to start somewhere. (354 comments)

Not just mammalian neurons, but invertebrate neurons too. I think that until we surpass what MomNature has already bioengeineered and abandoning the VonNeumann/Turing model of how a computer is "supposed to be" that we will not construct anything AI that is more performant than what already exists in biological systems.

Almost every day I move around in a vehicle that's faster on land than anything 'Mom Nature' has produced. Several times a year I fly through the air in one that's almost an order of magnitude quicker. We took one of Nature's apex predators, carefully crafted through millions of years of evolution, and in maybe _one one-thousandth_ the time we turned it into the Pomeranian. I'm not sure why you believe we're so far behind nature, or why 'artificial' approaches are so doomed to failure compared to a natural simulationist approach, when we have overwhelming evidence to suggest the opposite.

about a year and a half ago

Ask Slashdot: Mathematical Fiction?

Shaterri Try Borges's short stories (278 comments)

While not often directly mathematical, several of Jorge Luis Borges's short stories are interesting efforts on his part to grapple philosophically with many of the concepts of infinity: The Library of Babel most famously, but also great stories like The Book of Sand, The Aleph, and even Death and the Compass. They won't necessarily tickle you in the same way that Stephenson's work did, but they're still a fine jumping-off point into fascinating and deeply philosophical mathematics.

about 2 years ago

Hulu To Require Viewers To Have Cable Subscriptions

Shaterri Where's the evidence? (648 comments)

Everyone else on the net seems to point to the article in the NY Post (not exactly known for its careful fact-checking) and the Post article talks about Hulu 'taking its first steps' without a single mention of what those steps are. No other news stories I can find in the last several days talk about any changes occurring to Hulu's model (other than more original programming) or the Hulu user experience. So what the hell is the Post talking about, exactly? What evidence is there — beyond some editorial negative-wishcasting — that anything like this is going on?

more than 2 years ago

What's Not To Like About New iPad?

Shaterri Re:Fragmentation (617 comments)

Compared to Windows as of 15 years ago, maybe. The Windows APIs the last few years have been mature enough that while diverse hardware testing can still improve the user experience, it's gotten substantially less necessary for game developers. That just isn't the case for Android games.

more than 2 years ago

What's Not To Like About New iPad?

Shaterri Re:Let me know when it can compile. (617 comments)

I already have half a dozen different devices in my house that I can compile on, most of which have better storage and faster CPUs. Why do I care if I have another one? My iPad isn't trying to replace one of my computers and it seems silly to judge it by the same standards.

more than 2 years ago

Verizon Makes It Easy To Go Over Your Data Cap

Shaterri Any Quantitative Data? (166 comments)

TFA seems to be long on speculation and short on actual data. Obviously streaming video isn't bandwidth-cheap, but does anyone have real figures on how much data streaming, say, a standard 24-minute TV show would take, and how many episodes it would take to hit the 2GB monthly cap? If they can, for instance, stream a low-quality episode in 10-20 MB then this seems like much sound and fury over very little...

more than 2 years ago

Court: Domain Seizures Don't Violate Free Speech

Shaterri Re:The Supreme Court disagrees (96 comments)

Isn't this effectively the core purpose of copyright law? A hundred years of precedent suggest that my free speech rights don't extend to, for instance, performing my own stage production of Spiderman for all the world to see, or for writing and selling (or giving away) my word-for-word version of "Arguing With Idiots", and I'm not sure why anyone would expect results in the digital world to be any different.

more than 2 years ago

Bitcoin Mining Tests On 16 NVIDIA and AMD GPUs

Shaterri Re:folding@home etc (403 comments)

Strange, then, that the 'bitcoin isn't worth the energy it's minted on!' article isn't the one that made Slashdot headlines...

about 3 years ago

BitCoin, the Most Dangerous Project Ever?

Shaterri Re:Magic: The Gathering (858 comments)

The fascinating thing there is how Wizards "tricked itself" by misreading how certain cards form gamebreaker combos. So then they embarked on an elaborate "currency value adjustment" program, aka Type 2. (With all the spinoffs etc. In my areas "1.5" and "Legacy" and so on were never very popular.)

By being relegated to "Type 1" All those power cards were effectively cordoned off into a backwater, and lost most of their effective value. Then as the years rolled on, once cards left Type 2, they also dropped in value like a stone.

Well, except that this didn't happen. Yes, a number of cards definitely lost value once they fell out of Type 2 - but the price of the core type-1 power cards has never actually gone down, and in fact Legacy has meant that a number of secondary cards from that era have now skyrocketed. A white-border Black Lotus will set you back more than a thousand dollars; a black-border one you'd be lucky to find under two thousand. All the dual lands are north of $50 in white-border now and more than $200 in black border; half-blue duals are at least $5-600 each in black border. Some of the cards from the earlier sets (esp. Arabian Nights) have seen corrections, but that's more a matter of the market realigning itself around playability rather than just rarity - old out-of-print cards that see any tournament play at all (or even saw tournament play at one point) have skyrocketed (Karakas at $50-60, Sylvan Library at $25, etc.)

more than 3 years ago

Apple's Secret Weapon To Win the Tablet Wars

Shaterri Re:Don't think so (716 comments)

Apple stopped being a software company when the iPhone because the hottest ticket in the geek market.

Why do you think the iPhone was/is the hottest thing going? Hint: it's not the hardware, and it's sure not the carrier...

more than 3 years ago

Sony Wins Restraining Order Against Geohot

Shaterri Misleading summary/article? (397 comments)

'Pretty much he can't talk or think about the PS3 for some time.'

I wasn't aware that the only things one could say about the PS3 were related to cracking its protection schemes and pirate! (or, okay, 'traffic in copyrighted works'). He can talk about the games, he can talk about the OS, he can talk about the hardware, he just can't, y'know, talk about how to circumvent any of it. Really, this seems like a relatively reasonable restraining order all around, at least by the metrics for such things; it stops the specific (alleged) infringing behavior and doesn't strike much more broadly than that.

more than 3 years ago

Bicycle Thief Barred From Using Encryption

Shaterri He didn't ask to have the encryption overturned (449 comments)

Perhaps the reason the court didn't overturn the encryption restrictions is because the defendant didn't challenge those restrictions? The judgement in the linked-to article seems relatively clear (even if by omission) that the only restrictions challenged were the three restrictions (to use their lettering and wording) (A) on 'Use of Computer for Non-School-Related Purposes', (B) on 'Use of Instant Messaging or Social Networks', and (C) on 'Use of Computers Contaminated with Viruses or Unwanted Software'. If the defendant didn't request to have the restrictions on encryption (which are certainly there so that the juvenile justice system can track his communications) overturned and made no request for the total overthrow of his probation conditions, then I'm not sure the court even has standing to unilaterally throw out the encryption provision, and certainly it's little surprise that they wouldn't do so without being explicitly asked.

more than 3 years ago

The Best Video Games On Awful Systems

Shaterri Re:Tunnels of Doom (272 comments)

God, the 99/4a was a horrible system. Not bad as a games machine, but the worst possible machine to get a budding young coder (one of the most locked-down systems I've ever seen; even PEEK only came in extended basic and that still didn't get you POKE, and doing fast graphics was all but impossible unless you were an expert assembly coder and sprung the $100ish for their assembler). I still haven't forgiven my parents for that.

Parsec was also flat-out excellent, and it had one of the best versions of Miner 2049er out there, but that appeared on so many systems that it could hardly be called a hidden gem.

more than 3 years ago

Knuth Plans 'Earthshaking Announcement' Wednesday

Shaterri It's highly unlikely to be P!=NP... (701 comments)

So far as I know, Knuth has done essentially zero work related to the P/NP question; a lot of algorithmics and tons of fantastic work in combinatorics, but I can't think of a single significant result he's contributed to complexity theory. While it's not impossible that he could have some sort of 'outsider breakthrough', it seems almost infinitesimally unlikely given the mathematical context and techniques that have had to be developed for similar complexity problems. My money would be on either a formal open-sourcing of the TeX codebase or the development of a full HTML5 rendering engine for TeX along the lines of the system that uses.

more than 4 years ago

PageRank-Type Algorithm From the 1940s Discovered

Shaterri Re:linearity (108 comments)

The reason why PageRank 'has to be' linear is essentially mathematical; treating importance as a linear function of the importance of inbound links means that the core equations that need to be solved to determine importance are linear and the answer can be found with (essentially) one huge matrix inversion. If you make importance nonlinear then the equations being solved become computationally infeasible.

What's interesting to me is how close the connections are between PageRank and the classic light transfer/heat transfer equations that come up in computer graphics' radiosity (see James Kajiya's Rendering equation); I wonder if there's a reasonable equivalent of 'path tracing' (link tracing?) for computing page ranks that avoids the massive matrix inversions of the basic PageRank algorithm.

more than 4 years ago

Epic Releases Free Version of Unreal Engine

Shaterri Not a source release... (217 comments)

While it's unsurprising given that the current Unreal Engine is still in active development and a ton of commercial games are still being developed and shipped using it, it's worth pointing out that this isn't a source code release; instead, it's something much closer to an elaborate mod engine, with generous swaths of behavioral scripting but no real ability to get 'under the hood' as it were. Still, kudos to Epic for this; it'll be interesting to see who picks up the ball and runs with this.

more than 4 years ago



How do you detect cheating in Chess?

Shaterri Shaterri writes  |  about a year and a half ago

Shaterri (253660) writes "Which is more likely: that a low-ranked player could play through a high-level tournament at grandmaster level, or that they were getting undetected assistance from a computer? How about when that player is nearly strip-searched with no devices found? How about when their moves correlate too well with independent computer calculations? Ken Regan has a fascinating article on one of the most complex (potential) cheating cases to come along in recent memory."
Link to Original Source


Shaterri has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?
or Connect with...

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>