Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Internet Explorer Vulnerabilities Increase 100%

Tomsk70 Which IE? 4, 5, 6.....10? 11? (137 comments)

Another 'news' article that contains almost nothing.

Still, at least it's not another news article by someone pretending that a reseller of hardware would have no interest in pushing old tin.

about a month ago
top

UK Cabinet Office Adopts ODF As Exclusive Standard For Sharable Documents

Tomsk70 Re:This a wheeze to get Office 2013/ 365 cheaper (164 comments)

>The obvious tangible benefits are that the documents will no longer be locked into some stupid proprietary format

That's not a tangible benefit when the overwhelming majority (arguably all) of the country is already using it and has done for the past thirty years.

>that can never be converted due to ridiculous macros and scripts (quite why a static document needs to have macros and scripts is beyond me).

I think we'll leave it there.

about a month ago
top

UK Cabinet Office Adopts ODF As Exclusive Standard For Sharable Documents

Tomsk70 Re:This a wheeze to get Office 2013/ 365 cheaper (164 comments)

>As a UK tax payer, I welcome the move

You are in the minority, I'm afraid. Any outlay of this size really needs to provide tangible benefits from the outset, of which there aren't any.

>I would imagine that someone at GCHQ could easily convert the documents for a tiny fraction of the budget that they've got.

Nobody can easily convert documents. There are macros, scripts and so on that just don't convert.

>Plenty of money for spying on UK subjects, but no money for protecting their interests in not being tied to a predatory US company.

Apple are more predatory. Be sure to point that out to the schools buying iPads.

about a month ago
top

UK Cabinet Office Adopts ODF As Exclusive Standard For Sharable Documents

Tomsk70 Re:This a wheeze to get Office 2013/ 365 cheaper (164 comments)

Short term it may cost more, long term it should save a lot

Short term it'll cost a great deal - money we don't have that could be spent on more immediate benefits. If it's put to the public as '100 nurses, or a file format for an office suite nobody uses?', you can imagine how that'll play out (and even if it's spun, people will still see the bottom line). Long term...it will also cost a lot, as the rest of the world is not going to stop using MS Office just because you have. Munich didn't exactly start a snowball, despite spending ten years doing it. Macros, scripts and the like that can't migrate/ convert = more cost. It's not something that can be changed on a whim, and if there was actually any real tangible benefit, private corps would have been paying me to do it by now.

>As someone who fully expects to still be paying taxes in 10 years time, i welcome long term savings.

For *you*, yes - but right now, I'd argue that most won't be so keen when there's no immediate return or benefit, as well as the long term costs when the rest of the world carries on using MS Office. I'm also unsure of what the long term savings would be - all your incoming staff will have to be cross-trained. All 3rd-party apps have to be re-written or re-purchased. Support has to be purchased. Even if we ignore those costs, the 'savings' on the license fee for MS Office via a open source app are almost nothing - a combined CAL or license for MS stuff is still a big, big saving on the subsequent costs for going with multiple third-parties (as long as we're talking on-site - Office365 & hosted desktops still work out to be three times the cost of buying machines/ owning the software yourself for businesses of any real size).

>As for interoperability, they are the government... You either want their business (eg suppliers), or you have no choice (eg taxpayers)

Can you give an example of this happening with a UK council or government-run body previously? It's generally the other way round, I'm afraid - they adapt to what the standard is ('standard' being what everyone uses rather than what someone has arbitrarily decided). I've worked for hospitals, the police, councils and the goverment - if you want to go for a different format, the cost of conversion is on *you*. It's not that big a stretch to imagine it reaching the point where someone sues the government for forcing them to spend £££ for making an arbitrary decision to change formats.

Also, looking at the article - 500 comments were taken into consideration? That's not even a linux fan-club in terms of numbers.

about a month ago
top

UK Cabinet Office Adopts ODF As Exclusive Standard For Sharable Documents

Tomsk70 This a wheeze to get Office 2013/ 365 cheaper (164 comments)

We (the UK) are about to embark on another round of austerity, regardless of who wins the next election. I'd like to see what the public thinks about mass conversions of Word/ Excel/ PP docs - because it's not going to be quick or free, and once we reach the stage of 'well, what benefit will this give us right now?', there isn't one - in fact, it's the opposite.

If the cabinet office wanted to do this with purely internal documents, they might have a chance - but if any docs come in or go out of the office, it's MS or bust. The conversion issue won't go away, and local Councils *certainly* don't have the money to implement this sort of thing (it took Munich ten years, and supposedly didn't cost much. Have you ever heard of a council project that took that long but didn't cost anything? Me neither). Then there's third-party apps - again, most of these aren't going to export in the format needed.

TL, DR: Councils don't have the money, the Government doesn't really have the money, and the benefits don't amount to much outside of getting a warm cosy feeling because you're using an open format, meaning questions will then be asked as to why this was given priority/ money when the rest of the world is still using the app/ format you've abandoned.

Souce; I've worked UK government IT for twenty years.

about a month ago
top

Buying New Commercial IT Hardware Isn't Always Worthwhile (Video)

Tomsk70 Really Slashdot? Really? (92 comments)

Next Week; Linux rubbish at server tasks says Microsoft Reseller

about a month ago
top

French Parliament Votes To Give Priority To Free Software

Tomsk70 Laughable, hollow vote-winner (98 comments)

....that won't change the commercial market place (or the number of government systems that run under MS).

Of course, the back-doors are a hot-potato - at least, they are to anyone that hasn't been aware of them since NT4.

about a year ago
top

Google Retiring Chrome Frame

Tomsk70 Re:Die already! (104 comments)

Gah, just realised you weren't talking about just IE. my bad

about a year ago
top

Google Retiring Chrome Frame

Tomsk70 Re:Die already! (104 comments)

Which I'm sure will be the desktop OS of choice *next year*, just like it always is. Until then, in the real world....

about a year ago
top

NHTSA and DOT Want Your Car To Be Able To Disable Your Cellphone Functions

Tomsk70 Re:First (405 comments)

Or alternatively, be careful of picking holes instead of examing/ googling how much evidence is against you;

Also from the first page - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atwater_v._Lago_Vista
"Texas law provides for police officer discretion in arresting any person caught committing a misdemeanor, such as violating its mandatory seat belt laws."

I was actually trying to help you avoid having to defend why it *wouldn't* be an arrestable offence...but never mind

about a year ago
top

NHTSA and DOT Want Your Car To Be Able To Disable Your Cellphone Functions

Tomsk70 Re:First (405 comments)

Well, I was giving a rather base idea - it's not very hard to do facial recognition/ heat detection/ etc. - sure, there will be people who try to circumvent it, but then when seatbelts were made law there was always some wag who connected the seatbelt before sitting down because 'nobody tells me what to do'...but after a few arrests, that attitude didn't really last.

about a year ago
top

NHTSA and DOT Want Your Car To Be Able To Disable Your Cellphone Functions

Tomsk70 Re:First (405 comments)

If the car detects more than one person in the front seats, viola

about a year ago
top

UK Government Spending £6,000 Per Computer Every Year To Maintain Desktops

Tomsk70 I've worked for several London councils.... (193 comments)

...and I can tell you, this is not surprising at all.

All the desktops are the lowest CPU version possible - usually with not enough memory either. Because you can't put a value on waiting for bootup/ apps/ etc., but you can show how much money you've saved by going for a Celeron instead of an i3/ i5, you can guess which one happens.

Then there's citrix, and other money-saving wheezes that ultimately do nothing to lower the TCO, rather just shift the expense to the server-end instead of the desktop. And that's before we get to staff (or rather, senior managers etc.) that then demand a PC anyway.

And let's not forget the stupidly low money that gov. techs get paid - see peanuts/ monkeys, because anyone that has a real aptitude for the job will be gone within a year because this. As a result, contractors do very nicely out of it but the value-for-money aspect goes out of the window.

And remember, the decision to save-money-now-even-if-it-costs-more-tomorrow are legion - I just finshed a domain refresh, where I had to replace all the DC's across a London borough with brand-new HP boxes...loaded with Win2003 because the client 'didn't want to change anything'.

What's annoying is when politicians start complaining about the system they preside over and are ultimately responsible for - I suggest we remove them and replace them all with contractors :-)

about a year ago
top

450 Million Lines of Code Can't Be Wrong: How Open Source Stacks Up

Tomsk70 And betamax was better.... (209 comments)

...and look how that turned out.

about a year ago
top

SendGrid Fires Employee After Firestorm Over Inappropriate Jokes

Tomsk70 Re:Really? (1145 comments)

'Drama Queen' still has only one gender? Where have you been?

about a year ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Mac To Linux Return Flow?

Tomsk70 Windows 8 - Start8/ClassicShell changes everything (965 comments)

I utterly hated the Metro interface. Actually, that's 'I utterly *hate* the metro UI'.

However, use either of the above and you get to enjoy Windows 7.1 (to give it its' proper name) without the bolted-on second OS designed for hardware nobody owns getting in the way :-)

about a year and a half ago
top

What If Manning Had Leaked To the New York Times?

Tomsk70 It is not called the Times... (348 comments)

...second time today that I've seen someone do this. It isn't the Times. That's a London newspaper. It's the New York Times. Shortening the name after the first referral only works if nothing else already has that name....and ultimately, a real Journalist would not need this pointed out to them.

about a year and a half ago

Submissions

Tomsk70 hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

Tomsk70 has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>