Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Windows 7 Reintroduces Remote BSoD

botik32 Re:Local? (427 comments)

I am sure this is great relief for all system administrators out there. Thank you for enlightening us!

more than 5 years ago
top

DRM Take II — Digital Personal Property

botik32 Re:It is only DRM+ (356 comments)

I agree with your sentiment on the additional burden of "new property".

I have trouble keeping material things from getting stolen or deteriorated, why on Earth would I want more of the same? This is crazy.

Just a few weeks ago I got my car scratched by some bastard who did not even leave a note. I have to go the hassle of repainting it now. Why would I want the same problems applied to data that can be easily replicated? So that some corporation gets to rake in higher profits? No, thanks.

And, yes, I know, I could have paid more for car insurance covering accidental damage. But this just goes to prove my point. Digital stuff should not be turned into property. It would be a huge step backwards.

more than 5 years ago
top

DRM Take II — Digital Personal Property

botik32 Re:It is only DRM+ (356 comments)

If the original designer could copy anything, why would he need to be paid?

I see the opposite... designers going out of their way so other people could use their designs for free... would not that be the biggest dream of an artist? For his works to be enjoyed by as many people as possible?

more than 5 years ago
top

Court Allows Microsoft To Sell Word During Appeal

botik32 Re:Sauce for the goose. (106 comments)

Way to paint Microsoft as the victim here.

According to GrokLaw, this is what happened:

Whether or not the patent should have been granted is not the issue at this point. It was.
The plaintiff (i4i) had a successful add-on for MS Word that it was selling. In 2003, Microsoft added the same functionality to Word. Microsoft then refused all attempts on i4i's part to license the functionality.
The license fees requested were on the order of $25M. It was Microsoft's repeated refusal to negotiate that resulted in not only a large award, but punitive damages as well.
They (Microsoft) were found liable for willful infringement, so yes, they did steal the patented method.

The weird thing here is that this is actually a case of a patent working the way that patents are supposed to work:

Company A comes up with a reasonably unique and functional solution to a broad problem, patents it and starts selling it. They take it to mega-corp B who has a problem that can be easily solved with company A's product, and mega-corp B -- rather than negotiate with company A, simply steals their design, and incorporates it into their product in the expectation that this will be sufficient to run company A into the ground before any litigation can come to fruition.

The thing to note here, is that I4I's patent isn't just for an idea, it's actually for a real product and an apparently graceful solution to what had previously been an intractible problem.

The XML implementation is simply a specific implementation of their patent, but -- once you have XML -- it's not the only XML solution or even (for many people) the best XML solution.

It is starting to look like they didn't patent the general idea of adding meta-data to a file. They patented a specific way of organizing that meta-data to produce a specific result.

In the broader context of software patents being a bad idea, I would be inclined to classify this as an example of 'good case, bad law'. It is somewhat gratifying to see software patents put to a good use, for once.

more than 5 years ago
top

Steve Ballmer Directing "House Party 7"

botik32 Re:Pass (359 comments)

Helsinki syndrome?

more than 5 years ago
top

Steve Ballmer Directing "House Party 7"

botik32 Re:You have to be pretty nerdy (359 comments)

That's exactly the reason I would not touch anything but Gentoo and maybe LSB-based distros. I has such a hard time installing asterisk on a ubuntu machine it's not funny. No matter what I did, I could not get it to start at boot properly. It would start, but wouldn't work. Go figure. Had to add a cron job to start it, which did the trick.

And don't get me started on server-side distros. Compare installation of Horde+IMP on Gentoo and on CentOS.

on Gentoo: emerge horde; emerge horde-imp; edit a few config files in /var/www//htdocs/horde/config
on CentOS: about 20 manual steps (check it here http://wiki.horde.org/CentOS5InstallationNotes)

more than 5 years ago
top

James Murdoch Criticizes BBC For Providing "Free News"

botik32 Re:Threatening plurality? (703 comments)

But they are ALL biased, mostly in favor of hiding the inconvenient truth.

There, fixed it for you.

more than 5 years ago
top

Microsoft Finally Joins HTML 5 Standard Efforts

botik32 So... (280 comments)

So, they come late to the party, call the lead singer titless, and puke on the birthday cake.

So unlike the old Microsoft : )

more than 5 years ago
top

Free Web Content a "Myth," Claims Barry Diller

botik32 Re:I'd rather pay a small fee.. (294 comments)

You hit the nail on the head. Since corps took control of radio stations, commercial music went downhill really fast. They did the same to the programming industry recently. It reached a point where hobby works are better quality than enterprise stuff.

Corporations are the anti-Midas. Everything they touch turns to crap.

more than 5 years ago
top

Free Web Content a "Myth," Claims Barry Diller

botik32 Re:I'd rather pay a small fee.. (294 comments)

Exactly. The problem of the news industry is twofold: greed and sloth.

Since greed is promoted as a virtue in capitalism, I will leave that alone.

However, when the industry becomes so complacent that most of the professional journalism is full of mindless parroting of press releases, the problem is aggravated.

Nobody will pay for the current shoddy journalism. Press releases can be had for free elsewhere. Until the industry learns to provide a compelling, insightful analysis, people will not buy this mindless stuff.

And when you fail, please do not go crying to daddy 'the govt' saying the world is going to miss your public service if you die. We won't miss you.

more than 5 years ago
top

Free Web Content a "Myth," Claims Barry Diller

botik32 Re:I'd rather pay a small fee.. (294 comments)

There is a certain limit to how much content can be supported by subscription fees, after that subscription fees become increasingly unattractive in order to keep up the same revenue stream and after that subscription fees alone won't bring in enough revenue to keep some businesses afloat.

There. Something to think about.

more than 5 years ago
top

Don't Copy That Floppy! Gets a Sequel

botik32 Re:BILLY MAYS HERE... (523 comments)

Well, the key word here is 'taking'. When one downloads something they do not take, they copy.

more than 5 years ago
top

Browser Vendors Force W3C To Scrap HTML 5 Codecs

botik32 Re:Fuck Apple too... (640 comments)

I do not know why you think hitting a problem is only bad in Linux. Let me give you an example.

A co-worker of mine has been complaining about word opening documents very slowly after she's been upgraded to office 2007. Some documents opened fine, others took MINUTES to load( a 27kb document, at that). It was driving her nuts.

Guess what. Updating the chipset driver fixed the problem.

How in the whole world would a normal person know that? It took me days of checking for dead network printers, viruses, removing crapware, cleaning the registry, to finally try and upgrade the driver.

Example two: Out of our 30 or so computers in the office, two consistently refused to apply policies after we moved them to the domain. The reason: although the boxes were fairly new, the hardware guys loaded them with old drivers for the network card. As a result, the network started MUCH LATER than the group policy was applied, hence the domain controller could not be found during policy ran at startup.

Windows just isn't made for the common man. I don't know if it ever will be.

more than 5 years ago
top

Central Anti-Virus For Small Business?

botik32 Re:Bit Defender (359 comments)

I second that. Their management console is horrible - it does not hold computers in the group, is counter-intuitive, and fails to keep removed computers out - always adds them again to the main list. The management server is limited to N computers and if you get new users you have to install another management server. And they sell only in bulk of 10 or 25 licenses.

more than 5 years ago
top

Dutch Study Says Filesharing Has Positive Economic Effects

botik32 minor nitpick (336 comments)

[quote]Of course I haven't read the article, not knowing Dutch and not bothering with a translate this page thing, and I know nothing of the music industry - for all I know the Dutch distribute 99% of the world's music, though I doubt it.[/quote]

Fixed that for you.

But let me see what's in my playlist as a european at this moment:
De-Phazz - New Format Recordings, HQ Germany
Gotan Project - Beggars Group, London, UK
Buena Vista Social Club - Wold Circuit, London, UK
Cheb I Sabbah - Six Degrees Recordings, NY, US

While none of them are from the Netherlands, most of them are not from the "overseas" either, but more like next door.

more than 5 years ago
top

Ballmer "Interested" In Open Source Browser Engine

botik32 Re:At least he's honest. (410 comments)

Well, somehow I do not think that throwing, say, 100 people at the problem will get you anything usable in less than three years. Browsers are quite a complex piece of software, and, given Microsoft's track record of security bugs, three years is somewhat generous. Also, considering the competency level of microsoft programmers, getting 100 competent C++ programmers might be a tough task for the guys in Redmond.

more than 5 years ago
top

Ballmer "Interested" In Open Source Browser Engine

botik32 Re:Oh No! (410 comments)

Me thinks you are talking about patents.

more than 5 years ago

Submissions

botik32 hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

botik32 has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?