Slashdot: News for Nerds


Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!



Building an Open Source Nest

braeldiil Re:This is great (195 comments)

Since I have a Nest (and love it), here's the scoop: It doesn't have to be connected to the internet at all. It would work just fine as a standalone thermostat. Most of the functions would be harder to use (only so much you can do when you have 1 button and a wheel), but as far as I can tell they're all there. The web access provides an easier-to-use interface to the Nest. I don't use it much - it did a good job of learning my schedule, so mostly I use the web interface to turn stuff on at the airport after trips. There's some reporting and statistics, but those are mostly fluff.

about 6 months ago

Engineers: Traffic Studies Use Simulation Software, Not Lane Closings

braeldiil Re:In other words ... (265 comments)

And this is a perfect example of how, if you repeat your false story enough times, people will believe it. The IRS office in question flagged groups from all over the political spectrum to determine if they were engaging in political activities that would prevent them from being tax exempt charities. Yes, they used "Tea Party" as a flag for further investigation, but they also used "Occupy". They were attempting to enforce the law passed by Congress, albeit in a very bad, possibly illegal way. For the record, they started these investigations after specific requests from Congress to make sure these nonprofits weren't breaking the law. But the House very carefully tailored their requests to make it appear that only conservative groups were targeted, and attempted to supress testimony that demonstrated groups from all over the spectrum were affected. Once the full testimony transcripts were released, the press realized there wasn't really much of a story and mostly dropped it. But low-information voters like you never bothered to follow the story to its end.

about 6 months ago

US Treasury Completes Bailout of General Motors

braeldiil Re:I think... (425 comments)

No, if GM had collapsed it would have taken the rest of the auto industry with it. See, first GM goes down. Then the GM suppliers start falling, because they're close to the edge and GM defaulting on payments breaks them. There's no funding available to restructure, so they're all getting liquidated at pennies on the dollar (remember, we're in a massive banking crisis with a liquidity crunch). The failures cascade down the supplier chain, and then start taking out other automakers (because they can't get parts anymore). Pretty soon you've blown up most of the industry. The correct anology isn't a a tree falling, making room for new, younger trees. This would be more akin to a massive forest fire (or even a volcanic eruption). Sure eventually you'd recover, but it would take years to decades and meanwhile it leaves a massive patch of utter devastation to deal with.

about 7 months ago

Orson Scott Card Pleads 'Tolerance' For Ender's Game Movie

braeldiil Re:Really?!? (1448 comments)

Tolerance is not approval. I tolerate his view by allowing him to have it, and by allowing him to freely state his view in public without government interference. That's tolerance. I may think he's an idiot, or a bigot, or pond scum, but I don't stop him. The tolerance he (and apparently you) want is actually a freedom from consequences. He should be free to say whatever he wants, but no one else should have the right to respond to him. He's an intellectual bully, wanting to hit at powerless groups, but running and hiding when they start to hit back.

1 year,13 days

Lincoln's Surveillance State

braeldiil Re:Except, in that case there was an actual war (343 comments)

The Confederacy was never a separate nation, because they lost. They were merely territories in rebellion. Until you win (and convincing the other side to stop might be a win) you're not a separate country. Them's the rules. And in any case, the definition of "civil war" most definitely includes pieces of a former country fighting against each other.

1 year,16 days

Why DOJ Didn't Need a "Super Search Warrant" To Snoop On Fox News' E-mail

braeldiil Re:What did Fox News do? (330 comments)

Essentially, the reporter in question wrote an article just to say that we had a high-level asset inside the North Korean government. There was no new factual information in the article otherwise - just the need to out a spy in an article about North Korea responding to sanctions. Similar to the AP case, where the reporter felt the need to out the fact that the British had an undercover operative inside Al Qaida who delivered them a sample bomb for analysis.

about a year ago

Bezos Expeditions Recovers Pieces of Apollo 11 Rockets

braeldiil Re:Duty of a CEO (119 comments)

Or, perhaps That everyone is entitled to vacations or Have fun with your hobbies, no matter how weird You know, positives.

about a year ago

SimCity 5: How Not To Design a Single Player Game

braeldiil Re:EA at it again (569 comments)

I'll agree, but only if there's also a way for me to take money from people who make mindbogglingly stupid internet comments. I expect you'll lose a lot of money under that system.

about a year ago

Dell Going Private In $24.4 Billion Agreement

braeldiil This is tax avoidance (217 comments)

The primary purpose of the deal is to repatriate a bunch of cash without having to pay corporate taxes on it. A lot of the money originally started in the US, but was hidden overseas. This brings it back. The shareholders all get a premium on the share price, giving them their cut. Dell borrows a bunch of money to pay the shareholders, then uses their offshore accounts to pay the banks back, because loan payments are tax-free. And since it's all capital gains, the shareholders are all paying less on it than you pay on your wages. It's how the 1% rolls - good for them, not so much for you.

about a year and a half ago

The History of Visual Development Environments

braeldiil Re:VMS and Atari ST development tools (181 comments)

Considering Turbo Pascal came out two years before the Atari ST, your timeline is quite a bit off.

about a year and a half ago

GNU Grep and Sed Maintainer Quits: RMS and FSF Harming GNU Project

braeldiil Re:Software liberation not necessary for open sour (476 comments)

The "printer thing" is actually a red herring. The act that started RMS on his path was a lot simpler - all his coworkers at the MIT AI lab left. Stallman had finally found a place where he was comfortable, then thay all left to try and make a little money. RMS threw a hissy fit and set about taking all their original ideas and releasing them as free software. His stated goal was to drive them out of business - either to punish them for leaving or maybe to force them back to the lab. The printer story developed later, in an effort to make it seem not nearly so petty.

about a year and a half ago

Surfacestations: NOAA Has Overestimated Land Surface Temperature Trends

braeldiil Re:Oh dear... (474 comments)

You're only a sceptic if you can be convinced (by reasonable evidence) that the original claim is true. Otherwise, you're a denier, and discussing the issue with you is a waste of everyone's time. There are some classic signs that indicate you are a denier, not merely a skeptic. A general pattern is someone from completely outside the field making extraordinary claims that everyone else is doing it wrong. There's usually a conspiracy from the "experts" to shut them out. It's a constantly evolving theory, where the conclusions never change, but the reasoning always does. And, of course, there's usually a lot of funding from an organization with a vested interest in opposing the the original science. Watt is really no different from the Intellegent Design folks or Jenny Macarthy and the vaccine-autism folks, and he's only a short step from the Time-cube guy.

about 2 years ago

World of Warcraft: Mists of Pandaria Launches On September 25

braeldiil Re:The unfortunate state of gaming (247 comments)

WoW was never a "hard" game. It took over the market because it was the easy, casual-friendly alternative. That's always been Blizzard's mo - take a solid concept, polish out all the pain points and then take over a market. They make good products, but "genuinely hard" almost never applies.

about 2 years ago

US Labor Board: It's OK To Discuss Work and Pay with Coworkers On Social Sites

braeldiil Re:Pot, meet kettle (289 comments)

Actually, the NLRB was very specific. The entire point of the meme was to inform companies that their overly broad scial media policies would make a reasonable person believe they could not discuss their salary or working conditions. That's specifically against the law - a law he repeatedly sites in the memo. The easy way around the issue is to include repeated disclaimers that no part of this policy will in any way restrict the employee's rights to discuss their salary or work conditions. But they don't want to point out those rights, for fear their employees would use them. So they whine that the NLRB didn't give them a template for exactly how far they can push the rule and obscure their employee's legal rights.

more than 2 years ago

Red Hat Will Pay Microsoft To Get Past UEFI Restrictions

braeldiil Re:Would someone please explain to me... (809 comments)

Because there were several other paths they could have chosen to work with secure boot, but this was the most efficient? Because Microsoft is making a whole $99 to handle verification and signing for them? Seriously, this is sad. Microsoft will sign a boot loader for them for basically no money. This isn't a "Microsoft tax" situation - Microsoft will undoubtedly lose money on the arrangement, even if it's $99 every time Red Hat wants to update their "pre-grub" bootloader, and not the one-time registration fee the article implies that it is.

more than 2 years ago

Navy To Auction Stealth Ship

braeldiil Re:Failed experiment? (124 comments)

Actually, she was quite the success. While we're not building ships exactly like her, radar stealth has been a significant concern of the Navy, and current ships are designed to minimize their radar cross section. Reduced crew manning has also been a really big push, as had improved roll stability. About the only major design feature not in use is the catamaran hull. and really, figuring out something is a bad idea is still a successful experiment.

more than 2 years ago

Navy To Auction Stealth Ship

braeldiil Re:Other disposal options... (124 comments)

It's a 30 year old ship that was never really designed for extended operations. It has a max crew of 12, and they're roughing it. It's slow, with no weapons. Please describe exactly how you think this ship would be useful to the border patrol. Not "worth the cost to maintain an old, one-of-a-kind vessel", just useful.

more than 2 years ago

Navy To Auction Stealth Ship

braeldiil Re:Failed experiment? (124 comments)

It wasn't developed in competition with anything. It wasn't a warship, or really a working ship at all. It was a test platform for a bunch of different technologies. And, since the technologies being tested have since been incorporated into actual navy ships, I'd say it was a successful test ship. Calling it a failure is nearly as stupid as calling the Norton Sound a failure. After all, they didn't build any more of her, either.

more than 2 years ago

James Cameron Begins His Deep-Sea Dive

braeldiil Re:Godspeed! (162 comments)

The reason we didn't send a manned mission back is that there's really no point - a realization they came to on the first trip. The people in the sub can't directly interact with the environment in any way. They have to look at the world through cameras, and all work is carried out by robotic arms. Essentially, all you've done is take the control room for a remote vehicle and send it down with the robot. It's a lot of engineering work and no small danger for basically zero gain.

more than 2 years ago

US Research Open Access In Peril

braeldiil Re:Name and party affiliation (237 comments)

Why am I not suprised that you managed not to mention the actual sponsor, Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA). Rep Maloney is the other sponsor, but the bill was introduced by Rep. Issa. For reference, this is Rep. Issa's third bite at this particular apple - he was a cosponser on a similar bill in 2008 and 2009. Rep Maloney was also a cosponser in 2009.

more than 2 years ago


braeldiil hasn't submitted any stories.


braeldiil has no journal entries.

Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Create a Slashdot Account