Beta

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

What Google's Chromium OS Is Reaching For

brogdon Re:The real reason (216 comments)

Mmmm, so far, we've learned about traditional desktop software that

1- we can't trust desktops for availability: my PC needed repair last fall.
2- we can't trust desktops to not lose our data (my hard drive crashed that one time)
3- we can't trust desktops with our confidentiality (some spyware dudes haxored me once)

What more is there to learn? Clearly desktops can never work as a business model.

more than 4 years ago
top

Microsoft, Other Rivals Slam Google Chrome OS

brogdon Re:Play ChromeOS (Data) Jeopardy! (324 comments)

"Gee, thanks, but it doesn't run the software I need for my classes. Can you return it, and I'll put the money towards a mac | linux | winbox ? Also, I need something with a bigger screen, and more storage. This doesn't cut it."

I can certainly grant that there's no web-based alternative for Mathematica or Photoshop yet, so that's certainly likely to be an issue for a small number of students. Techies aren't going to want them, naturally, but if you're a history student who needs to use Photoshop twice for his digital media studies class, there are still computer labs.

I guess I'm basing this more on my own anecdotal experience. I know tons of people with netbooks, and I can't remember ever seeing someone using an application that couldn't be done through the web.

You think ChromeOS is a bad idea, but porting a cell phone OS back to PC is an obvious success? Really?

I think you had a brain fart on that one. I'm saying it's a FAIL.

Somehow I missed a connection with this. How does Android make ChromeOS obsolete? You've argued (I think) that ChromeOS won't work because it offers too few of the features afforded by a full PC. How does Android, a cell phone OS that might find its way onto some palmtops, encroach on ChromeOS's market at all?

Alex: The answer is "Business".

Me: Who won't be using ChromeOS?

Hey businesses who moved all their internal apps to ASP.net years ago, here's a $200 client for all of those. You'll never have to roll out software to it. Enjoy.

"Here's a free linux DVD that converts your obsolete hardware to a thin client." ... and ...

"ChromeOS is missing the plugins and functionality I need!"

Most businesses don't ever consider Linux because it's not packaged as a single solution behind a unified brand. Managers barely know what Linux is, let alone the difference between Slackware and Fedora. They know Google's name, though, and if the see these things marketed as simple, it-just-works clients backed by a company they trust, they'll get considered and purchased.

Netbooks are already razor-thin in terms of profit margin. Manufacturers have to sell 100 (or more) netbooks to net the same profit Apple makes off of 1 laptop. Look at Apple's cash balance. they NET 10% profit on every sale. A $2000 laptop is $200.00 NET, after all expenses. Netbooks? $200, 5% gross margin. Say 2% net. That's $4.00. So, to compete, a netbook running ChromeOS has to be even cheaper, which means even lower margins. That $4.00 per unit becomes $2.00 - or even less, because at the lower end, even a small incremental cost will kill you. 1 warranty support call kills the profit from a dozen other sales. 1 return kills 100. What are you going to do - try to refurb an returned ChromeOS "appliance" - they're just too damn cheap to be worth the effort.

This one I really don't understand at all. This is the exact same argument that someone would have given three years ago about why current netbooks won't work as a business model and it's obviously been disproved by the booming netbook market. I doubt anyone at Asus gives a crap what Apple's margin is; they're too busy selling millions of EEE PC's to notice. If the units suddenly need $50 less in hardware and no one has to pay Microsoft for the OS, they'll just knock $75 off the sale price. The sky will not fall down.

Open source has nothing to do with ChromeOS being a FAIL. Both my desktop and laptop are linux boxes. I'm thinking that I really want a Droid for my next cell phone. But ChromeOS? There's no business case for it. Thin client? Sun already mined that with SunRay. Netbooks? The market is already saturated, with full-featured ones at the $250 price point. So, are they going to sell this for $100? By the time it comes out in the fall of 2010, netbooks will be starting at $150 - $175. There's simply no market for it, and for $100, people will buy an iPhone instead (and I expect the Droid to be down to that by then as well) - and both of those are far more useful.

Again, you've been arguing that ChromeOS will fail because it can't replicate a full PC, but now you're saying people will just buy an iPhone or Droid and do their homework on that instead? A ChromeOS netbook, at least in the near future, is always going to be cheaper than a Windows netbook (lower hardware specs and no Microsoft royalties), and will always bring more features than a cell phone. That gives Google enough space in between for a viable market.

more than 4 years ago
top

Microsoft, Other Rivals Slam Google Chrome OS

brogdon Re:Play ChromeOS (Data) Jeopardy! (324 comments)

I'm surprised this got modded up so much.

Alex: For $100, "specific segment of hardware that Google is aiming for".
Me: Who are people too cheap to spend $200 on a netbook?.

Hey parents of new college freshmen, here's a $200 laptop that'll take notes in class, play movies and TV, do email, surf the web, and run both google's online office suite and Microsoft's so your kid can do homework. Oh, and it'll have a hundredth of the virus issues you other kid's HP laptop did. You're welcome.

Alex: The answer is "it obsoleted ChromeOS a year before ChromeOS was supposed to be delivered"
Me: What is Droid?

You think ChromeOS is a bad idea, but porting a cell phone OS back to PC is an obvious success? Really?

Alex: The answer is "Business".
Me: Who won't be using ChromeOS?

Hey businesses who moved all their internal apps to ASP.net years ago, here's a $200 client for all of those. You'll never have to roll out software to it. Enjoy.

Alex: They both don't let you run your apps your way.
Me: How is a ChromeOS-based computer like a Tivo?

Open source operating system. What can't you do your way?

Alex: The answer is, "100 times as much."
Me: How much more profit will Apple make off each computer it sells compared to vendors of ChromeOS-based computers.

Why can't people make money off of these machines? Hardware suddenly becomes unprofitable when you install ChromeOS on it?

ChromeOS bonus question, "We welcome our cloud-based data overlords", "In Soviet Russia, Chrome browses YOU" and "You can have my data when you pry it from my cold dead hands."
Me: What were the three most popular ChromeOS privacy FAIL slogans?

Again, it's an open source OS. If you don't like Google's shit, point it somewhere else. What's the problem?

more than 4 years ago
top

Facebook Beacon Privacy Issues Worse Than Previously Thought?

brogdon Is *that* what that was? (138 comments)

I was playing some rinky-dink flash game on kongregate.com and all of the sudden a little DHTML window panned up from the bottom of the browser and said "Tower Defense has added a story to your Facebook profile."

At that point I had three questions:

1) What is a flash game site doing talking to Facebook?
2) How do you know what my Facebook ID is?
3) Where the fuck do you get off?

I had to go several menus deep in Facebook to figure out how to opt-out of this crap. I haven't been back to kongregate since. Absolute crap.

more than 6 years ago

Submissions

brogdon hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

brogdon has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?
or Connect with...

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>