×

Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Reaction To the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'

crunchygranola Re:Actually (573 comments)

Here is the relevant part of the exchange:

QUESTION: What kind of probability do you think exists that they currently have a nuclear device?

GEORGE TENET: I think we've unclassified the fact that they probably have one or two plutonium-based devices today.

QUESTION: And how about their, they fired missiles over Japan, what is the likelihood that they currently have a missile capable of hitting the west coast of the United States?

GEORGE TENET: I think the declassified answer is yes, they can do that.

QUESTION: So in all likelihood they have nuclear warheads and an ability to deliver them to the west coast of the United States. Obviously very, very troubling.

LEIGH SALES: Mr Tenet didn’t elaborate further, although US officials admit the ballistic missiles haven't been flight tested, which raises questions about how effective they would be.

Tenet confirmed that North Korean has a missile that could hit the West Coast. He did not confirm that it had a missile that could carry a nuclear warhead. The fact that North Korea has placed a payload in orbit indisputably shows that they have a launching system with intercontinental range that can deliver some sort of payload, so Tenet's comment is hardly surprising. But a limited technical capability does not an effective weapon systems make.

2 days ago
top

Reaction To the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'

crunchygranola Re:yea but (573 comments)

The theaters are contractually obligated to play the movie. Sony can claim publicly that they don't have to play the movie, but those legally binding contracts are still in place, and remember, the theaters still want to play the movie. That's cash in their pockets and the threats are likely fake. So they show the movie anyways, and if a real attack happens, the first thing they are going to do is point at that contract and say Sony forced them to show the movie, they had no choice. Viola, Sony is now liable.

First up. Sony voluntarily suspended enforcement of the contract clause. The theaters would have real difficulty arguing in the court that "Sony forced them to show the movie" when Sony publicly declared they did not.

Second. Are you trained in contract law? I would be quite surprised to learn that if both parties in a normal two-party contract agree to temporarily suspend enforcement of one clause in a contract they are "breaking the law" in some way. What would be the aggrieved party that would bring suit? Who would have standing? Or are you saying this a criminal act? Cite a statute please?

2 days ago
top

Reaction To the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'

crunchygranola Re: Never attribute to stupidity (573 comments)

NK is just a puppet state of China.

More like a case of China with Alien Hand Syndrome. North Korea is geographically an appendage to China, a fact that cannot be changed. The problem for China is that the Kim dynasty runs North Korea and is not going away, it has no choice to deal with it. China supports the North Korean regime, but the regime knows how to manipulated the relationship to its own ends. All of the other options are much worse for China, outright collapse of the state and attending flood of desperate refugees into China, etc.; loss of a buffer state with a U.S. ally, etc.

The U.S. has had lots of experience itself with unruly client states that learned to yank the "puppet master's" strings and make him jerk.

2 days ago
top

In Breakthrough, US and Cuba To Resume Diplomatic Relations

crunchygranola Re:Why not push toward collapse? (424 comments)

Yeah, we have them on the ropes! Another 55 years should do the trick for sure!

3 days ago
top

NASA Gets 2% Boost To Science Budget

crunchygranola Re:I for one (121 comments)

Those aren't your tax dollars. Our country spends twice what it takes in.

According to this Conservative-run Federal budget reference website the current Federal budget deficit is $483 billion on a $3504 billion dollar budget, or 13.8%. That is a far cry for "twice what it takes in". Smart to remain anonymous, you would not want to reveal your math skills to those who know you.

That notorious Marxist rag The Wall Street Journal concurs.

about two weeks ago
top

James Watson's Nobel Prize Medal Will Be Returned To Him

crunchygranola Re:Watson is a scientist (235 comments)

I was unaware that Watson had been "blacklisted". After 39 years as Chancellor of CSHL, a good long run, which is largely a public relations function - he did show himself unsuited to continue filling that role due to his 'unfiltered' public expressed opinions (which had been occurring for quite awhile, even when he was not-so-old). Still his punishment was 'promotion' to Chancellor Emeritus with a perpetual $375,000 salary, still with a free mansion to live in. Few 'blacklisted' people are treated so favorably.

He is still knocking down $30,000-$75,000 minimum fees for public appearances. Pretty good money for someone who is 'blacklisted'.

What You really seem to be saying is that he should be above criticism, and not accountable for anything he says. I disagree.

about two weeks ago
top

AI Expert: AI Won't Exterminate Us -- It Will Empower Us

crunchygranola Re:It will empower the few (417 comments)

It will empower the few - to put the majority of people out of work.

Seriously - we are in the early phase of the Cybernetic Revolution - whether you call it "AI" or not - that will cannibalize jobs like the First Industrial Revolution did. If you think automation has already done that, you ain't seen nothing. Between ubiquitous, cheap computing power, an always-connected-world, and robotics whole classes of jobs that still exist are going to be automated away over the next quarter century.

about two weeks ago
top

James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million

crunchygranola Re:Depreciation (201 comments)

And only two days later the medal is being returned to him just I suggested!

It might make "no sense" to you, oh AC, but the fix WAS in from the beginning, Watson knew the billionaire who was going to buy it.

about two weeks ago
top

High Temperature Superconductivity Record Smashed By Sulfur Hydride

crunchygranola Re:Oh Carbon (80 comments)

A rapid quench would destroy any magnet, sure, but a sacrificial safe quench system could probably be designed to handle this. Think of composite flywheels that can disintegrate safely. SCES can use conventional metal sacrificial busbar to dump energy into, kinetic energy absorbing materials, a strong case, etc.

about two weeks ago
top

The Failed Economics of Our Software Commons

crunchygranola Re:I am no economist, but as a geek ... (205 comments)

Look at just the last few years of Linux at all the guts being just ripped out rather than building on what was there, Pulse, KDE 4, Gnome 3, unity, systemd, why do you think every time it looks like Linux is gonna become mature and stable that some major subsystem gets ripped out and goes back to square 1?

You hit the nail right on the head. It seems the Great New Thing in Linux is something for which there is no evident need, and often is undesirable in many ways, yet the desktop - even with a straight default install - is glitchy and rough in ways Windows (as much as I detest it) is not. The polish just does not go where it is needed. Who wants to detail someone else's car?

about two weeks ago
top

FISA Court Extends Section 215 Bulk Surveillance For 90 Days

crunchygranola Re:Hope and change (83 comments)

a million citizens revolting against their government with hand guns and rifles isn't even going to make a dent

Don't forget the great lesson of the Soviet debacle: all governments ultimately depend on the consent of the people. When that consent is withdrawn, the government collapses.

The great lesson of Romania is that a government shouldn't count on its armed forces to violently suppress their own people.

-jcr

Quite so. And in both cases the possession of small arms was utterly irrelevant. They played no role at all in the collapse of tyranny. Why do Americans suppose that they are less capable of peaceful overthrow than Russians or Romanians?

about two weeks ago
top

James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million

crunchygranola Re:Depreciation (201 comments)

The mass purchase of books written by right-wing commentators and politicos by right-wing organizations is well established as a form of support (aka "pay-off") is well established.

I do like the "rich fiends" bit though!

about two weeks ago
top

James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million

crunchygranola Re:Depreciation (201 comments)

Who in their right mind would pay 4 million for *his* Nobel prize? I know pure gold doesn't really tarnish... but that thing is tarnished.

Upthread the interesting theory is offered that the fix was in, and this was a way for rich fan of Watson's unsavory remarks to kick some money his way. The buyer was anonymous of course. It would be interesting to learn if the medal is eventually loaned back to him, or to CSHL, for display only of course.

about two weeks ago
top

Why Elon Musk's Batteries Frighten Electric Companies

crunchygranola Re:Are they really that scared? (461 comments)

You should pay attention to this technology: http://www.technologyreview.co... It might be able to eliminate the need for a generator completely.

All this material does is passively cool through radiation. If you want your house cooled all the time, and have no other need for electricity at all, then hafnium-shingling your house may work out for you.

about two weeks ago
top

Comcast Forgets To Delete Revealing Note From Blog Post

crunchygranola Re: only an idiot would buy services from comcast (114 comments)

i'm very wrong because your father has a very affordable and very usable service available to him?

...

AC industry shill. Color me surprised.

$180/month for a 3mbs link is a monthly charge of $60 per mbps. The EU average for this service unit is $3.50. Also a 2 GB monthly cap is "very usable"?! The average home use consumes about 25 GB of bandwidth monthly, the average mobile phone user is hitting 2 GB/month right now.

So the AC Shill, paying 17 times a competitive world service rate for only 8% of what a typical American consumes in bandwidth is "very affordable and very usable". But to anyone not taking industry astro-turf cash it is a rip-off.

about two weeks ago
top

James Watson's Nobel Prize Goes On Auction This Week

crunchygranola Re:Crushed Freedoms (355 comments)

... the fact he's being forced into giving up his Nobel (according to the first link in the summary)...

Forced? Forced??? The link says no such thing. He is selling this Nobel Prize because he wants to use the money to take up art collecting, and making philanthropic donations. This is the choice of a very comfortable man who wants to take up the hobbies of the rich.

Note that the link says that he "he has no income outside of academia" - given his multiple high level positions in academia over the years, those pensions could stack up into mid-six figures, making him wealthy by any normal standard.

Sorry, the poor, poor Mr. Watson shtick won't wash.

about three weeks ago
top

Stars Traveling Close To Light Speed Could Spread Life Through the Universe

crunchygranola Re:Title (184 comments)

The the term used in the paper is "semi-relativistic" - fast enough that relativistic effects cannot be ignored in even routine calculations about its properties. At 1/3 the speed of light the time dilation effect amounts to a 5.7% difference for example.

"Close to the speed of light" is the summary author's attempt to render "semi-relativistic" in sensible common place terminology.

about three weeks ago
top

How Intel and Micron May Finally Kill the Hard Disk Drive

crunchygranola Re:What about long-term data integrity? (438 comments)

One faction claims it's Apple trying to sabotage upgrades, making it so that if you buy an after-market SSD rather than paying their insane markup performance will become awful. Another faction claims it isn't deliberate sabotage, but rather a lack of interest in testing for unsupported hardware configurations...

Seems like a distinction without a difference.

about three weeks ago
top

NASA Offering Contracts To Encourage Asteroid Mining

crunchygranola Re:Self-expanding factories (153 comments)

...Since the laws of nature are the same everywhere, the Seed Factory concept works just as well on Earth, so our first generation design is for here. Later versions will be for more hostile environments like the oceans, deserts, ice caps, and space. Where it gets really interesting is using an expanded factory to make new starter kits. This is very similar to how biological plants reproduce. An acorn doesn't make another acorn directly. It grows into an oak tree first, then produces more acorns.

Good for you! You are proposing to build an actual von Neumann machine. Such things are obviously possible (given the evidence of living things) - but I have never seen a proposal to actual build one, or even a defensible estimate of what would be required to build Humankind's first one.

Any estimate on when we will see this is more than just an electronic document? Currently the WikiBook about this flys at such a high level that it is impossible to tell whether there really is anything here.

about a month ago
top

Nuclear Weapons Create Their Own Security Codes With Radiation

crunchygranola Re:Tamper Evident (106 comments)

The AC is right. This IUC tamper resistance scheme has nothing at all to do with launch authority controls.

about a month ago

Submissions

crunchygranola hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

crunchygranola has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?