Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!



Inception, The Social Network, TS3 Get Oscar Noms

cyberon22 Re:Thanks (201 comments)

Thanks for the reply. I agree the self-referential bits about movie-making were actually the best parts.... :) I only caught the Matthew 7:24 reference because I was seeing it in translation and the last line by the kid was subtitled. What bizarre dialogue, I remember thinking and then had one of those moments of realization where it is like something hits you.

A fantastic movie anyway. And a blast to watch even without thinking about the intellectual side at all!

more than 3 years ago

Inception, The Social Network, TS3 Get Oscar Noms

cyberon22 Re:I vote for Inception... (201 comments)

Of course it was intentional.... He deliberately asks "is this real or a dream" because he wants you to think about it.

You only get to the answer "neither" by understanding the film. :)

more than 3 years ago

Inception, The Social Network, TS3 Get Oscar Noms

cyberon22 Re:I vote for Inception... (201 comments)

Cobb didn't put the spinning top down and walk away. He looked at his family, he let them go on ahead of him, then he spun the object on the table and stared intently at it.

Watch the ending again:

Cobb walks in and spins the top, then sees his family and walks away. We get the line about the kids building a house on the cliff (nonsensical in any other interpretation) and then everyone disappears. The camera closes on the spinning top in an empty room.

Once he had enough room to accept the possibility that it was real, he didn't want to ruin it by finding out it's not.

The seduction offered by Mal (malevolent?) in limbo is exactly what you describe above. I'm paraphrasing here, but what she essentially says to him is, "you don't *know* there is anything else out there, so why not enjoy being here with me and the children." Cobb rejects it, and we see the wisdom of this as Limbo is subsequently destroyed as per the parable.

more than 3 years ago

Inception, The Social Network, TS3 Get Oscar Noms

cyberon22 Re:I vote for Inception... (201 comments)

If the film started and ended with a reference to Plato's Republic, I agree it would make sense to discuss Greek philosophy on Slashdot. Otherwise... let us just agree that there is a lot of water in the film.

There is so much water in fact that someone who took film seriously might even ask if it is being used symbolically. Perhaps it isn't coincidental that the opening shot to Inception is basically the same as that to A.I.. or that water has been a standard literary symbol for the subconscious since the nineteenth century. Maybe it isn't accidental that Nolan even has his characters talk about the "shores of our subconscious" while the camera is showing a shot of the ocean.

So no... I don't worry about over-interpreting when I see a film about death and faith reference a well-known parable about death and faith. Where I wonder if I'm over-interpreting is when I notice things like it being a glass of water that sends Fischer to sleep on the plane.

more than 3 years ago

Inception, The Social Network, TS3 Get Oscar Noms

cyberon22 Re:I vote for Inception... (201 comments)

I'm not sure what the plot holes are. The film is a Christian parable and the plot makes sense if you take it at its word.

I thought the linked video was funny, but if people are complaining seriously about whether "kicks" transcend levels in shared dreamspace is silly. The film deals with all of this stuff on the level of metaphor anyway.

more than 3 years ago

Inception, The Social Network, TS3 Get Oscar Noms

cyberon22 Re:I vote for Inception... (201 comments)

Respectfully, I don't think you understood Inception... let me try to explain:

Inception opens with a shot of children building a castle on the beach. This is a biblical reference to Matthew 7.24 and the parable of the wise and foolish builders. The film closes when Cobb's real children tell us they are building a castle “on the cliff”. So we start and end with a biblical story about how getting to heaven requires faith in God. This encourages us to read Inception as an allegorical journey towards redemption through faith, not an action film. Having failed to “buy his way” to heaven, Cobb gets there by taking a “leap of faith”.

If you are confused by the spinning top or self-referential nature of the movie (films are also dreams, and who is to say what message the audience will find in the safe?), that's because you aren't thinking critically about what you saw. People who argue about the spinning top for instance miss the point. The ending of the film is a heaven sequence depicting Cobb’s reunion with God. We have the forgiveness of sins (immigration), the family reunion and the return to the heavenly garden. In order to get there Cobb simply needs to forgive himself (for his complicity in his wife's death) and sacrifice his own life to rescue Saito from limbo. The point of the spinning top is that Cobb ignores it -- he has faith.

One more paragraph because in case you still think that this is a stretch, consider that Michael Caine plays a master architect (creator). Or consider the scene where Cobb stops by Paris to ask his father for guidance. After being chided for his worldliness and corruption (“I never taught you to steal”), Cobb argues he is doing the best he can in a fallen world. But when he asks for help, help is given in the form of a woman whose mythological name suggests her role is guide Cobb out of the maze that is the mortal world (“all dreams are mazes”).

Given that the film has lines like "you have to die to wake-up" I don't think Nolan can be accused of subtly. But if he's made a film that goes over the heads of most filmgoers, it can only be because people have been trained out of having any expectations from movies by the very sorts of films you criticize. So whatever you want to say about Inception go ahead, but calling it a logically inconsistent film with mundane action sequences is about as far off-mark as you can get. This is a film about ideas (it doesn't always give answers -- where does Cobb get the "genesis" of the idea of salvation). If you watch it with the right mindset, I think you'll have a lot more fun and realize how much better it is than anything else released this year!

more than 3 years ago

The Web Way To Learn a Language

cyberon22 Re:Some more resources (165 comments)

The 3000 figure is misleading, since Chinese words are bigrams and knowing them in isolation doesn't help. I think is the best way to train for reading Chinese newspapers. Otherwise it is painful.

more than 4 years ago

Schools To Get Their Own DARPA

cyberon22 Re:I nominate... (151 comments)

I agree. I run an educational business that teaches how to learn Chinese. Advancing to fluency myself and now engaging with students day after day who are struggling to learn has convinced me that the major obstacle to student progress in most places outside China is institutional torpidity, and the fact that the structures that have emerged to organize and cheapen learning (classrooms, textbooks, etc.) don't allow students to learn at their own pace, or - in some cases - to learn at all.

People are frustrated and they are looking for alternatives. There are an increasing number of them available and I share the sense with you that a lot of these are happening outside existing academic channels. Given that systems to issue educational grants are already online, so it is unclear what this organization adds that the existing system doesn't.

more than 4 years ago

All-You-Can-Eat College For $99-a-Month

cyberon22 Re:Won't take over top schools... (272 comments)

I can't disagree more. Traditional classrooms and textbooks are designed to make educational institutions economical to operate. The textbook standardizes the class to the point where an intelligent undergraduate could run it. The reason students need to commit to several months of learning in advance is to amortize the costs of running a physical school.

Everyone moves at the same pace because you only have X lectures per week and the material is canned. Huge classes have evolved to make the system inexpensive to operate. So where is the focus on learning? What about student convenience, or the ability to move at your own pace? Why not let students explore their interests and take more responsibility for their courses? The competing economic model is the gym. But you can't run an educational business that way if everyone has to proceed at the same pace.

Online learning isn't going to displace traditional universities but it will change the point of going to class, because paying top dollar for huge lectures will seem like a waste of time and money. It's also silly to say it will never dominate the top X schools because you don't know what those schools will look like. Full disclosure: I run an educational company that teaches how to learn Chinese. We have more students than are studying mandarin at any university in the United States. But you can't compare the approaches because the business model is different and what students get out of it is totally different too.

Maybe that's why this StraighterLine company focuses mostly on freshman courses...

Easier explanation: education is a pyramid and the majority of the students are at the bottom. Freshman courses are the biggest market opportunity and the space in the market most open to adopting non-traditional study methods.

about 5 years ago

China Aims To Move Up the Food Chain

cyberon22 Re:great (257 comments)

Stick with it. The fact that you've already started puts you seriously ahead of the game.

At risk of sounding spammish, I'm running a company from Beijing that specializes in online Chinese learning at We are pretty exposed to conditions in the local market and are still seeing a lot of growth in small and mid-sized businesses in northern China. These are the smart innovative companies. In contrast, it's the export-oriented manufacturing sector down south that are having a really hard time.

The job market is definitely a lot softer in Beijing than it used to be, but the problems are mostly hitting people who are monolingual and unskilled. Chinese university graduates are having an especially really rough time these days (you can get a fulltime hire for about $500 a month). People who are genuinely fluent are doing pretty well. We're certainly hiring (on the off chance anyone reading is fluent in mandarin or cantonese and a native english speaker and is looking for work in Beijing please get in touch).

more than 5 years ago

How Do I Manage Seasoned Programmers?

cyberon22 Re:Key Point # 1 (551 comments)


His first step should be getting rid of those so he can keep the staff under constant surveillance, and ideally packed four or six to a table to maximize team communication and learning. Follow agile development methods and experiment with seating arrangements before locking things down and setting up the camera so you can monitor from home if needed.

Make sure none of them have keys to the office and set up a punchcard machine. Link punctuality to pay and make sure they work weekends once in a while too (a measure of team devotion). I'd also recommend keeping the washroom locked and having a signout sheet for the key so you can monitor whether they are wasting time or drinking too much coffee. Hover when possible.

more than 5 years ago

Getting Paid To Abandon an Open Source Project?

cyberon22 You are in a position to negotiate (654 comments)

My take? They approached you, and if it is a small project they are unlikely to find someone else with equivalent experience to work on the code base. Their alternative is building the project from scratch.

You would be an idiot to sign any open-ended non-compete clause. It is reasonable for the company to expect you to keep their modifications private, but their way of addressing this is not reasonable. A more reasonable compromise is for you to remain bound to non-competitive terms as long as you are employed by the company. This provides some teeth to your "employment at will" and gives them an incentive not to screw you over once you are working for them. Also remember that anything you sign that restricts your freedom to work on the project will also restrict your freedom to work on a consulting basis with other companies when you leave.

On a final note that comes from personal experience, "providing resources" isn't a tangible promise at all and you'll be lucky to get much of anything. If these guys had resources to throw around it seems unlikely they'd be trying to fork an open source project instead of building from scratch and trying to keep the whole thing proprietary.

more than 5 years ago


cyberon22 hasn't submitted any stories.


cyberon22 has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>