Beta

Slashdot: News for Nerds

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

The Daily Harassment of Women In the Game Industry

doctor woot Re:And seeing the reactions so far... (906 comments)

Ignoring the petulance of some of the comments here (there's no point addressing them) the reception the article got isn't entirely unreasonable. Wu speaks with an undeserved sense of authority, comes across as a smug supremacist hand waving away criticism. She uses the article as a platform to broadcast her frustrations and masquerades it as a piece on culture. She can decide not to take her audience seriously if she likes, but sulking over the response is demanding you have your cake and eat it, too.

2 days ago
top

ChickTech Brings Hundreds of Young Women To Open Source

doctor woot Re:Kuhscheisse. (158 comments)

Either you're implying that you really don't know how "so" works as a conjunction or you're backpedaling. I'd believe either at this point.

about a week ago
top

ChickTech Brings Hundreds of Young Women To Open Source

doctor woot Re:Kuhscheisse. (158 comments)

You're a good statistician and sociologist. Strongly persuaded by the narrow anecdote you used to support your loosely worded presumptuous conclusion. This is the quality bullshit comment systems were invented for.

about a week ago
top

ChickTech Brings Hundreds of Young Women To Open Source

doctor woot This is sexually racist (158 comments)

I abhor the use of personal resources to aid any specific group of people for any reason. People should spend their money only in ways that further my own interest, I'm too insecure to have it any other way.

People trying to help others overcome inequality makes me sick.

about a week ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Future-Proof Jobs?

doctor woot Just stay unemployed (508 comments)

If labor is abolished in the future she can kick back and lounge around in her underwear all day eating junk food and watching Netflix. It's what I do.

about two weeks ago
top

What Happens When Gaming Auteurs Try To Go It Alone?

doctor woot Re:Outside of Valve I don't think many developers. (86 comments)

You're talking in circles because you're making a point that was already raised and addressed. Going back to it doesn't further this discussion.

It's irrelevant because it's only tangentially related and mentioned only as an antecedent to a completely different point. I'm not going to address your argumentum ad populum.

about two weeks ago
top

What Happens When Gaming Auteurs Try To Go It Alone?

doctor woot Re:Outside of Valve I don't think many developers. (86 comments)

Some games aren't necessarily built around win/lose conditions. Some games are sandlot building games.

You're talking in circles.

54 million in sales says that you aren't representative of everyone.

Irrelevant.

/I/ had literally hundreds of hours of enjoyable gameplay from my $15 purchase. By far one of my best ever game purchases.

Well I am very happy for you.

about two weeks ago
top

What Happens When Gaming Auteurs Try To Go It Alone?

doctor woot Re:Outside of Valve I don't think many developers. (86 comments)

You can make a city as elaborate as you like, it does nothing to determine your success as far as the game's win/lose conditions are concerned. It's just dicking around, the gameplay itself is incredibly unimpressive. Dwarf Fortress, by comparison, actually does involve the designs the player manages to come up with directly in determining their success or failure, and is by far the better game.

about two weeks ago
top

What Happens When Gaming Auteurs Try To Go It Alone?

doctor woot Re:Outside of Valve I don't think many developers. (86 comments)

Actually I hadn't even considered Portal. It's an entertaining game but offers a rather narrow difficulty curve.

I don't really care if a game is linear or not, infinite spawns, etc. All that really matters is what options the game puts in the player's hands and how well opportunities presented by those options are exploited by the game itself. I think the game could have been improved in a number of ways (in particular, the acceleration curves found throughout the game were awkward. Vehicle sections could have tested a player's attention to detail, instead you just awkwardly flop from point A to B. Rockets also seemed random but this i s a minor point.) but in general it was solidly designed, particularly with regards to weapon diversity and how each affected your positioning and timing in each engagement.

Valve knows how to find skilled developers and put them in an environment in which they can be creative but still focused. Dota 2, CS:GO, Left 4 Dead, these games show a lot of attention to detail while being embellished by unobtrusive fluff.

about two weeks ago
top

What Happens When Gaming Auteurs Try To Go It Alone?

doctor woot Re:Outside of Valve I don't think many developers. (86 comments)

> Outside of Valve I don't think many developers ... pay enough attention to game design to consistently produce quality games

That's because a game is too dependent on Art + Tech. You can have the world's greatest designer but if they don't understand how to capitalize on Tech & Art _tailored_ for their project you're dead in the water.

There are few Game Designers that are recognized as delivering the goods. Sid Meier, Shigeru Miyamoto, Will Wright, etc. How many of these game designers do the general public even know??

I don't see how that matters, the point is games are homogenized for the sake of market friendliness.

> Games are an awkward state of limbo these days,

AAA games maybe, but not indie.

Okay.

Content creation costs are spiraling out of control.

Why did you bold that and then not follow up on it

People are getting fed up with grind-for-gear ooh shiny with shallow gameplay.

Minecraft just reach 54 million across all platforms.
https://twitter.com/pgeuder/st...

Well that's a contradictory statement if I've ever seen one.

about two weeks ago
top

What Happens When Gaming Auteurs Try To Go It Alone?

doctor woot Outside of Valve I don't think many developers.... (86 comments)

...pay enough attention to game design to consistently produce quality games. Not that they can't, mind you, but it seems pretty clear to me that game devs tend to have their attention split between designing a game's mechanics and appealing to a broad audience. You end up with a game that isn't too far afield of what you tend to see these days, but that tries to compensate by having gameplay features designed to be marketed as 'innovative' and conducive to creative and emergent gameplay. A good example is Watch Dogs, marketed as a game centered around hacking but designed as a GTA clone with a hacking gimmick.

Games are an awkward state of limbo these days, publishers know they have to start pushing out the impression of creativity and devs try to figure out how to do that without alienating the average player. The mentality sticks, and developers everywhere end up glossing over technical details, focusing instead on the impression a game will make.

about two weeks ago
top

Gamestop's Ludicrous Idea: Require Preorders To Unlock Custom Game Content

doctor woot Re:This idea isn't ludicrous, it's sensible (86 comments)

Exclusivity deals aren't a problem either. This strategy is not hidden from consumers, as in the case of, say, a manufacturer lowering the quality of the materials in their products while taking steps to maintain the appearance of the former product. In this case consumer consent is necessary, the opportunity to obfuscate facts is not presented from the idea in question. The information consumers use in assessing whether the product is worth the cost goes unaffected.

about two weeks ago
top

Gamestop's Ludicrous Idea: Require Preorders To Unlock Custom Game Content

doctor woot This idea isn't ludicrous, it's sensible (86 comments)

Gamestop is depending on a market with idiosyncratic practices. These practices may themselves seem strange or senseless, but if one is to take these as cultural shortcomings then the fault lies with the consumer, not Gamestop. This is an industry where the cozy relationship between critics and publishers is no secret, where being excited regarding an event consisting entirely of three days of advertisements is considered normal. If this idea seems exploitative, it's only because they're serving a demographic that wants to be exploited.

about two weeks ago
top

Long-Lasting Enzyme Chews Up Cocaine

doctor woot Re:Daily lethal doses (73 comments)

Those mice love to party! They aren't white for nothing!

Please. A white mouse's idea of a party is a pint of Ben & Jerry's and a game of Jenga.

about 1 month ago
top

The Science of Solitary Confinement

doctor woot Re:isn't it used on violent prisoners? (326 comments)

So you're just suggesting once someone gets put in solitary, they're kept there until they die, without ever seeing another human ever again? The fuck kind of person are you?

about 5 months ago
top

The Science of Solitary Confinement

doctor woot Re:isn't it used on violent prisoners? (326 comments)

Hyperbole? What hyperbole? You show me how solitary confinement reduces harm to both bystanders and inmates better than other, less barbaric methods of rehabilitation and I'll consider not viewing such methods and the people who advocate them with disgust.

about 5 months ago
top

The Science of Solitary Confinement

doctor woot Re:isn't it used on violent prisoners? (326 comments)

Yeah, I like making sweeping generalizations about tens of thousands of people that I've never met to justify horrific and inhumane treatment too.

Oh wait no I don't because I'm not a piece of shit.

about 5 months ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Educating Kids About Older Technologies?

doctor woot Re:Is this for real? (208 comments)

Since when does somebody have to justify their premise to ask for advice?

This isn't asking for advice, this is forwarding an argument (" I think not being aware of the science behind such yesteryear technologies (or their histories) is not right.") without giving any reason as to why. You would think something posted alongside articles on current events including international politics and advances in science, engineering and medicine, on a site with "News for nerds, stuff that matters" as the tagline would be a bit more substantial.

To say it's worthwhile to teach kids about old technology is to presuppose that they'll even benefit from such effort in any way (preferably at least somewhat proportionate to the amount of time they're made to invest) but if your kid wants to become a dancer, a musician, a novelist, a racing driver, a sculptor, a composer, etc. etc. there are far better ways to allow them to explore their own creativity than forcing them to sit in front of a bench with wires and batteries.

Had the author of this article (paragraph) put any effort into procuring supporting details beyond "I think" I might have felt differently. But given the laziness with which the subject was approached, I find little reason to regard this question as anything more than a waste of time.

about 5 months ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Educating Kids About Older Technologies?

doctor woot Is this for real? (208 comments)

I feel it would be most beneficial to encourage kids to explore old technologies and perhaps even try simple simulations at home or school. So, what websites or videos or other sources of information would you reach out to that teaches the basics of say, telegraphy? Or, signalling in railways? Etc. etc."

Seriously? That's it? Just "I think" without even an attempt at justifying that statement? What difference would it make in a kid's life to learn about older technology?

It's already hard enough to get kids interested in education, and adults pushing their ideas of what's important onto young students with no regards as to the relevance the "education" bears to the kids' lives is why. If I ever have kids I'm leaving it up to them to decide what they find interesting, and will do whatever I can to educate them on it, even if it means I have to learn a bit about it myself. I certainly wouldn't force my kids to learn about something as arbitrary as older technology.

about 5 months ago

Submissions

doctor woot hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

doctor woot has no journal entries.

Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...