Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

How Do You Prove Software Testing Saves Money?

edw Wrong question. (312 comments)

"Can anyone offer suggestions for how to convince the owner that setting up a test suite is in his own best interest?"

What bullshit. Perhaps the question you should ask is, "How can I determine whether setting up a test suite is in his best interest?" But if you insist on pursuing an answer to your original question, you might want to dedicate some time to other questions, like figuring out how to convince people that humans and dinosaurs roamed the earth together, or that people's astrological signs play an important role in determining their personalities, or that ingesting colloidal silver is a solution to a wide range of health problems.

You are part of the problem.

more than 3 years ago
top

Are Consumer Hard Drives Headed Into History?

edw Godwin's Law, shame edition (681 comments)

The more trivial the topic under discussion, the more likely someone will attempt to shame people who hold a contrary opinion.

more than 3 years ago
top

HDR Video a Reality

edw The fatal flaw... (287 comments)

Unless they're somehow collecting at least twice as much light, assuming that the beam splitting is perfectly efficient, then I fail to see how what they're doing really helps, as both of the images (or image streams) are going to wind up being shot at at least twice the ISO that they otherwise would be. That would not be good for sharpness and noise. There better be a large lens collecting light for these cameras.

about 4 years ago
top

Ray Kurzweil Responds To PZ Myers

edw Re:The best resolution... (238 comments)

I believe you may be falling prey to what Kurzweil warns about in his response to Meyers: linear thinking. Things go from impossible to inevitable without us much noticing. The bottom of a parabola looks a lot like a horizontal line.

Let's say Kurzweil has been too optimistic about the rate of growth of our understanding of the way the brain works. Assuming the exponent on the rate of growth of our knowledge and technology is greater than one, and assuming that Penrose and Searle are full of it—which they IMO are—and there isn't some mystical quantum mechanical woo-woo that is just as irrational as the Silicon Valley Deepak Chopra mumbo-jumbo that Meyers's crew accuses the Singularity Crows of pedaling, Kurzweil will ultimately be vindicated, even if he—or his cyborg replacement body—is not around to say, "I told you so."

more than 4 years ago
top

Open Source Is Not a Democracy

edw Re:-1 Troll (641 comments)

This is a pointless argument over definitions, but since you're attempting to co-opt for your own purposes the definition of a highly valuable piece of definitional real estate, I'm going to bite.

What you describe as "democracy" is not democracy. That everyone has the freedom to take their marbles and go home (i.e. create their own distribution) is not democracy. It's freedom. Freedom and democracy are related in that the latter is often seen as a way of achieving the former.

Democracy denotes a broad range of methods for collective decision making, among them representative and direct democracy.

An open source project is whatever the hell you want it to be. "Whatever the hell you want" is not democracy. That is freedom, to a first order approximation. The organizational and social and economic dynamics of free software vis-a-vis proprietary code are subtle and multilayered and not suited to simplistic reduction to a term like democracy.

more than 4 years ago
top

Photoshop 1.0 Recreated On iPhone

edw Re:Photoshop of a Monochrome Mac? (103 comments)

Two-bit would mean four levels; I think you mean one-bit ie. black and white. Regarding the SE vs. Plus, the SE had a newer/bigger ROM in it than the SE; perhaps this was the factor. I don't think the SE had Color QuickDraw in ROM as the SE/30 did, so that probably wasn't the issue.

more than 4 years ago
top

Restructured Ruby on Rails 3.0 Hits Beta

edw Re:Apple and Rails (197 comments)

Maybe it works today, but it didn't work six years ago. Did you read the part of my post that mentioned Rails broke when I did what some know-it-all like you suggested I do? Hello?!

more than 4 years ago
top

Restructured Ruby on Rails 3.0 Hits Beta

edw Re:Apple and Rails (197 comments)

Yes, but while there may not be right and wrong opinions, opinions can definitely be either thoughtful or stupid. A case in point: Rails likes to give your database tables plural names. This is a stupid opinion. I explained this on #rubyonrails years ago, but it seems that the developers, DHH included, were so enamored with their pluralize method that they didn't want to rip it out and do the sane thing.

It's convention over configuration, not instead of configuration, I read in another comment. Well, I tried to configure Rails to not pluralize table names...and Rails broke. If the pull of tradition and convention is so strong that very few people stray out of the ruts worn into the beaten path, deciding to break with convention means fixing all the latent bugs in the system.

One of the reasons to prefer singular table names is that it improves Rails's interoperability with the applications that either want to supply data to or consume data created by Rails. Web apps do not exist in a vacuum. I was told by DHH that such things were outside the scope of Rails, and therefore those pluralize calls would stay for the rest of eternity. And thus everyone who has their first involvement with relational databases using Rails becomes brain damaged. Hooray for opinionated software?

I soured on Rails early, though I have tried to go back to it on occasion, only to find that the hype still exceeds the reality by a significant factor. I'm very much a right-tool-for-the-job kind of person, but I haven't come across a project where a feature in Rails makes it uniquely suited to the situation over something like Django.

Don't get me wrong, I think Rails gave web development frameworks a much-needed wake-up call. The Java way of doing things circa 2004 was horrible. But Rails has no monopoly on smart developers -- an understatement? -- and smart developers are quick to adopt good ideas.

more than 4 years ago
top

Saving Lives with Design

edw As a card carrying member of the AIGA... (430 comments)

Looking at the before and after designs, I don't see anything spectacular. It simply looks more designed. I don't have anything against highly designed documents - after all, as I mentioned, I am a member of the American Institute of Graphic Arts - but equating more designed with more usable is a mistake.

I wonder what the designer in question (Greg Storey) thinks of that most linear of documents, the novel. How might his tremendous design skills be brought to bear on the problem of more effectively presenting the information in A Tale of Two Cities than Dickens did?

At some point this obsession with presentation begins to look like the problem it's trying to solve. Compare Storey's modified presidential daily briefing to Peter Norvig's PowerPoint version of the Gettysburg Address. Not quite as bad, but moving in the same direction.

more than 9 years ago

Submissions

edw hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

edw has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?