Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!



The Joys and Hype of Hadoop

godrik Re:Embarrassingly Parallel (55 comments)

The main interest of Hadoop is that it makes it easy to do out of core computation if the computations are loosely coupled and are mostly IO-bound. For anything else, Hadoop is probably not the right tool and is overhyped and typically inefficient.

4 days ago

Want To Influence the World? Map Reveals the Best Languages To Speak

godrik Re:Let me be the first to say... (150 comments)

except the nearest bus station is not the world.

I am actually not sure how TFA comes to the conclusion that spanish would be a good second language. The question should be "assuming I already speak English, which second language should I speak." If 95% (pulled out of a hat) of spanish speakers also speak english, then learning spanish might not actually allow you to reach much more people.

about a week ago

The Sony Pictures Hack Was Even Worse Than Everyone Thought

godrik Re:$1tr question--Why is all this Internet-facing? (528 comments)

Well, it is probably linked to the fact most of these companies are international companies with employees all over the world needing some form of interaction with the data.

If you really want to get an internal network that is disconnected from the internet, it means that you will need an army of monkey copying data using memory sticks to feed the data bank and bringing reports back to the employee that needs it. And that induces super high latency in the system.

The problem seems difficult to me. Completely isolated networks might have an unreasonnable operational cost. (Though a massive data breach might just be as bad.)

about two weeks ago

UK Announces 'Google Tax'

godrik Re:Get rid of corporate taxes totally (602 comments)

How does this change anything? the shareholders of Google are not in the UK and so would not be paying taxes there.

about three weeks ago

UK Announces 'Google Tax'

godrik Re:Algorithm (602 comments)

You are exposing yourself to Hollywood accounting by doing this.
Say you want to pay taxes in country FOO because the taxes are better there. You choose to subcontract your wallpainting to a company in FOO that charge you an insane amount. Your big company no longer makes any profit, and the wallpainting company is making tons of profit at FOO's rate.

Of course, this one is obvious and will certainly be considered fraud. But there are more subtle ways of doing the same thing that will look legitimate.

about three weeks ago

Obama's Immigration Order To Give Tech Industry Some, Leave 'Em Wanting More

godrik Re:IT industry has no use of the illegal immigrant (186 comments)

The summary mention an extension of the OPT visa which are essentially granted to foreign students after completion of a degree in the US. This extension of OPT will certainly benefit these students as the length of OPT typically leaves little margin of error to move to a different status.

I don't know whether it is a good thing or not for the tech industry, but there are lots of STEM student directly affected by that.

about a month ago

"Barbie: I Can Be a Computer Engineer" Pulled From Amazon

godrik Re:holy crap (561 comments)

What makes it even worse is that Barbie is meant to be an image of a women that girl want to achieve.

about a month ago

Japanese Maglev Train Hits 500kph

godrik Re:500KPH - but what is the average *journey* spee (419 comments)

It really is a matter of infrastructure. When I was living in france, I never drove a car. It was not useful. Driving was typically not much faster than taking the train. I could go to my university in 45 minutes while driving took about 35 minutes. But that gave me the opportunity to read in the train and to take a daily walk.
Later I was studying in Grenoble and my parents were living in Paris. To go and see my parents, public transportation (bus+train_tgv+train_city+bus) was taking about 4 hours and a half, 3 of them were in the "main train" which gave me time to do homework, read a book, whatever. The total cost was under 100 euros round trip. The same trip driving would have taken me 6 hours of actual driving (plus pauses) and cost at least 60 euros of gas.

Now, in the US, it is much more difficult becasue even if you had a good train, there would still be no public infrastructure one you arrive. But I guess you could rent a car.

about a month ago

What Happens When Nobody Proofreads an Academic Paper

godrik Re:Error: They did not use LaTeX (170 comments)

exactly, if my student writes the paper, I might not read the latex file myself. What I typically do is that all things that are not meant to be part of the article is either a \note{} or a \todo{} which resolve to write in bold, red, and change background color to yellow (or green). That way, it is impossible for me to miss it before it is sent to the reviewers.

about a month ago

Duke: No Mercy For CS 201 Cheaters Who Don't Turn Selves In By Wednesday

godrik Re:type of assignment (320 comments)

I am teaching one of these classes right now (but in a different institution). And I can tell you that there is a lot of variability in students submissions even for very simple algorithms. When I accuse a student of cheating (which happens unfortunately quite often), I usually have NO DOUBT that the code was copied from somewhere else.
You find groups of functions which match exactly code found online and which are written in a style completely different from the rest of the assignment.
You find functions with variable name different from an online template and that group of function is not indented at all, while the rest of the code is. Soon after you realize that copy pasting from that website screws up formating. No student would write it that way.
Sometimes you find comments in the code from a language the student does not speak.

In my opinion, we (whoever teaches computer science) are typically VERY conservative before saying that a code stems from plagiarism.

about a month ago

It's Time To Revive Hypercard

godrik Re:No, it's not time to do that. (299 comments)

CS grads seem to need a professor, hand-holding and a cookie in order to learn anything new.

AH! Maybe that's what I need! Bringing cookies to my class. That's smart!

about 2 months ago

16-Teraflops, £97m Cray To Replace IBM At UK Meteorological Office

godrik Re:Can this stuff be farmed out? (125 comments)

Actually, this is misconception. The cloud can probably deliver 16Pflops. The problem with the cloud is not computation power. It is communication bandwidth and latency.

What makes a supercomputer is the balance between processing capability, communication capability and IO speed. For many applications, you need to be able to synchronize the processors with very little overhead. Many scientific application work under the following patterns: do a small computation, make a small communication with your neighbors, rince repeat for 10 hours. If you do not have balance capabilities, you are wasting lots of ressources. This is the type of computation the cloud can not really help you with.

Now if your application is: get 1MB of data, compute for 2 week, send 1MB of data. Then the cloud will be fine. Unfortunately, not many scientific applications follow that model.

about 2 months ago

Tech Firm Fined For Paying Imported Workers $1.21 Per Hour

godrik Re:Maybe we should actually penalize companies (286 comments)

I am not too familiar with US laws and regulations. But I assume that if the same company get caught twice or if DoL start catching one company like that every week, then the fines will become higher.

about a month ago

Systemd Adding Its Own Console To Linux Systems

godrik Re:Awesome! (774 comments)

This should not be tagged funny! This should be tagged depressing.
What I really don't understand is "why is this part of systemd and not a separate program?" I can only see two answers:

-Because it has to be tightly integrated with systemd. In this case, I would rather we do not clutter a critical system component with more unnecessary code such as a console implementation.

-Because it is a tactic to get it deployed as part of the systemd package. In which case, systemd really starts looking like a attempt at conquering the world. I feel like that is exactly what it is here.

about 2 months ago

Living On a Carbon Budget: The End of Recreation As We Know It?

godrik Re:Nuclear power--the no carbon solution (652 comments)

Not sure if it is true or not. But I had read there was probably not enough nuclear material (see how much I know by my proper use of vocabulary?) in the world to power the world using nuclear power plants for a significant portion of time.

We certainly need a mix of energy and should certainly not disregard nuclear. But I am a NIMBY too. There is not enough room in my back yard to build a nuclear power plant! :)

about 3 months ago

Hong Kong Protesters Use Mesh Networks To Organize

godrik How does mesh network works? (85 comments)

I am no expert in mesh networking, but I was under the impression that addressing in them does not scale well. The best technique seems to be BATMAN [1]. AFAIU it requires everynode to perform a full broadcast regularly and that each device stores a complete routing table to each other device. That will not scale to build a city wide network.

Somebody knows more?

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B....

about 3 months ago

Microsoft On US Immigration: It's Our Way Or the Canadian Highway

godrik Re:Is it just me... (365 comments)

Indeed, I am fairly disappointed by this video. This is pure BS. There is no actaul fact presented. Statements are not facts. You can do lots of that.

MYTH: the little girl droped the ice cream on the floor
FACT: In reality the cat made it fall.

Maybe it is a fact, but without any proof it is just a statement in the air.

about 3 months ago


godrik hasn't submitted any stories.


godrik has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?