Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!



Study Shows Professors With Tenure Are Worse Teachers

gsiarny Study only talks about Northwestern freshmen. (273 comments)

The study supports some popular beliefs about tenure-track professors, but people shouldn't be too quick too generalize. This study was very limited.

From the Atlantic article:
"Now time for a few disclaimers, some from the paper, some my own. As the authors note, this paper only looks at freshmen. Tenured professors might very well might do better in advanced junior and senior-level courses where they can incorporate their own research and special expertise into their curriculum and have a chance to work with students who've accumulated a bit more specialized knowledge. Also: Northwestern is a tony private university that attracts highly qualified faculty to work as adjuncts and non-tenured instructors. Who knows if these results would hold up at a typical state university. "

What holds for Northwestern freshmen may not hold for other populations. Such cautions are being ignored by a media (and a few intelligent commentators who should know better) too eager to confirm preconceptions.

about a year ago

Lord Blair Calls for Laws To Stop 'Principled' Leaking of State Secrets

gsiarny Re: Government vs terrorists (395 comments)

It's not the custom in the last hundred years for a hereditary lord to be the prime minister. The last was the Marquess of Salisbury, whose third term ended in 1902.

But, historically, quite a few lords were prime ministers. Nineteenth-century examples included Lord Liverpool, a political survivor who was the prime minister for 15 years, overseeing the final defeat of Napoleon and the continent-reshaping Congress of Vienna. Napoleon's great rival, the Duke of Wellington, was given his Irish dukedom before he was prime minister in the 1830s. Viscount Palmerston, a major figure in British policy in the second half of the 19th century with an Irish peerage, was the prime minister during the American Civil War.

As far as I know, there isn't any formal obstacle to a hereditary lord becoming a prime minister. In the crisis of the first year of WWII, the Earl of Halifax was a strong candidate to replace the increasingly unpopular Neville Chamberlain. Despite the backing of the king and several political parties, Halifax gave way to the most famous prime minister of the 20th century, Winston Churchill.

about a year ago

Are Amazon Vine Reviews of Technical Books a Joke?

gsiarny Physician, heal thyself (126 comments)

Is this really a meta-review which indicts an entire system based on 12 reviews of one book?

If only the summary had reported that the reviews relied too much on anecdotal evidence...

about a year ago

Professors Say Massive Open Online Courses Threaten Academic Freedom

gsiarny Re:Professors whining.... News at 11. (284 comments)

Professors do not set the prices for their textbooks. Publishers do.

Authors' royalties are only rarely much more than a small slice of the purchase price. Publishers, distributors, and bookstores each get as much or more than the authors.

about a year ago

Chicago Sun Times Swaps iPhone Training For Staff Photographers

gsiarny Re:The equipment isn't the story (316 comments)

Your linked story isn't directly relevant. The Chicago Tribune isn't the same as the Chicago Sun-Times, and Tribune Co. doesn't own the Sun-Times.

about a year ago

Gene Therapy May Protect Against Flu

gsiarny Re:scrambling? (72 comments)

Do you mean remapping each of the codons to a different amino acid? How would this be possible? Once you move beyond the schematic idea of "scrambling the letters," how would this be "simple"? The amount of synthetic biochemistry would be mind-boggling.

Completely changing the orthography of the English language and republishing everything that has ever been printed in English would be a walk in the park compared to this.

about a year and a half ago

MIT To End Open-Network Policy In Response To Recent Attacks

gsiarny "Cybersecurity", "cyberwar", "cyberthis and that" (144 comments)

I'm dismayed that MIT, of all places, uses the thoroughly awkward term "cyber security" in its official correspondence. Outside of a few sci-fi novels, "cyber" seems to be the province of clueless congressmen and the reporters who love them. It's a buzzword for media outlets, politicians, and consultants who don't understand the net, want to profit from others' lack of understanding of the net, or both.

about a year and a half ago

New Pope Selected

gsiarny Plenty of "Vatican experience" (915 comments)

Contrary to the summary, the new Pope has had plenty of Vatican experience since his creation as a cardinal in 2001.
He's not a true insider of the Curia, but he knows his way around.

"As cardinal, Bergoglio was appointed to several administrative positions in the Roman Curia

        Member of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments
        Member of the Congregation for the Clergy
        Member of the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life
        Member of the Pontifical Council for the Family
        Member of the Commission for Latin America"

about a year and a half ago

US House Science Committee Member: Evolution Is a Lie From Hell

gsiarny Re:Why... (1113 comments)

Though this is way off topic, this bizarre abridgement of Ottoman history shouldn't be modded up to 5 without some sort of clarification.

It's unclear how the Ottomans were in any sense "Al Quaeda['s] grand-grand-grand parents". The two groups are in completely categories. The Ottomans were a collection of Muslim Sunni and Sufi Turkic groups who happened to move into Anatolia, not a loose international band of Muslim fundamentalists sprung from postcolonial Arab Sunni roots. The Ottoman Empire wasn't a predecessor of Al Qaida any more than the Holy Roman Empire was the predecessor of American Christian fundamentalists - which is to say that "group A came before group B, sorta near where group B would be later on, and maybe they both had the same general religion, sorta" does not mean that "group A were the antecedents of group B".

The Ottoman Empire was large, but they never ruled even the whole Islamic world, let alone the whole world. There were two or three other contemporary Islamic powers of comparable size and wealth, not to mention the various European and South Asian powers. Ottoman power didn't wane because they "started acting irrational", whatever that might mean. The explosion of Atlantic trade routes, in which the Ottomans participated little, had a clearer effect, comparatively enriching its Western European neighbors. As for bigoted, Turkey, the much-truncated successor state to the Ottoman Empire, is one of the more tolerant and secular of Muslim countries. Lastly, there is no contemporary Ottoman Empire and hasn't been since the end of World War I. It isn't a place where people live, bigoted or no.

about 2 years ago

Skype To Feature Giant Ads

gsiarny Re:Can't Wait (178 comments)

Takes the notion of a "landing strip" to the logical conclusion. For nighttime approaches.

more than 2 years ago

SEC Decides Telcos Must Give Shareholders a Vote On Net Neutrality

gsiarny Representative democracy and corporate democracy (107 comments)

Regular old representative democracy has had a hard time enshrining network neutrality in law. It will be telling if shareholders manage to secure it through "corporate democracy".

Whether a push for network neutrality through shareholder activism succeeds or fails, however, this appeal to shareholders on such a basic social issue is just a symptom of the creeping corporatization of American politics. The surrender to corporations of the right to make decisions on matters of fundamental social importance is frightening, but hey - corporations are people, right, and AT&T's just this guy who means well, you know?

more than 2 years ago

Journalist Arrested By Interpol For Tweet

gsiarny Re:and where is exactly the problem? (915 comments)

It wasn't just momentum. They occupied the Balkans for hundreds of years. The Ottomans had a sophisticated legal, fiscal, and administrative system - for the standards of the time - that helped them govern the Empire.

more than 2 years ago

Journalist Arrested By Interpol For Tweet

gsiarny Re:Fuck you all (915 comments)

That's a pretty broad brush you're waving around. I hope you're more subtle when you're calmer - it's a lot easier to change people's minds when you don't piss them off first.

more than 2 years ago

Journalist Arrested By Interpol For Tweet

gsiarny Re:and where is exactly the problem? (915 comments)

You seem to conveniently forget that the Crusades were a response to 400 years of aggression which included the unprovoked invasion of Spain and Portugal. Show me any modern society that would wait a year let alone centuries to counter attack.

Be careful when projecting notions of a European society back a thousand years or more. The Latin Christian response (Visigothic, Frankish, etc.) to the Umayyad invasion of the Iberian Penninsula and southern France in the 8th century wasn't that of a coherent single group. They didn't even consider each other proper Christians. And yes, some of them did fight back, under Charles Martel and Charlemagne, almost immediately in the 8th century.

The crusades were not only a counter attack against the invasion of the holy land by the muslims and killing of peasants on a pilgrimage to the holy land but it also served to weaken the forces in Spain allowing the eventual reconquest of Spain and portugal by christian kings.

Crusaders overwhelmingly aimed at the Seljuk Turks, small Muslim emirates in the Levant, and eventually the Mamlukes in Egypt, when they weren't laying siege to Orthodox Christian Constantinople or killing Jews along their routes. Spain's all the way at the other end of the Mediterranean, and was ruled by completely different Muslim groups (Umayyads, Almoravids, and then Almohads) than those in the Levant (small autonomous Abbasid amirs, Abbasids, Mamlukes). Crusading in the Iberian penninsula had very different historical roots - there were existing Christian kingdoms in Spain which had been waging local wars of conquest and reconquest against various Muslim groups and each other long before the Crusades as such began in the 1060s.

Without the crusades, france and eventually the rest of europe might have fallen and been ruled under sharia law.

The freedom to be an asshole and attack religion exists in part to the crusades halting the advance of muslim armies in southern and eastern europe.

What's the evidence that the Crusades did anything to halt the spread into Europe by Islamic powers? The high-water mark of the Islamic invasion of Western Europe was the Frankish victory over the Umayyads at Tours/Potiters in 732. That's more than 350 years before the First Crusade. Crusaders had nothing to do with the defeat of the Umayyads in Spain and France. If you're thinking about the Ottoman threat from Anatolia and Southeastern Europe, the Crusades were long over when the Ottomans threatened Vienna in 1529 and 1683.

more than 2 years ago

The Headaches of Cross-Platform Mobile Development

gsiarny Solving the same problems three different ways (197 comments)

Slashdot's designation - "from the hard-stuff-is-hard dept" - and some of the comments here suggest that it's trivial, whiny, or both to complain that writing good code for multiple mobile UIs is difficult. Perhaps that's so, but that's hardly the whole story.

Some programmers may see the UI as the necessary-but-uninspiring gloss over the more interesting, more important core functions of a program, and resent having to apply the gloss more than once. But even if a well-designed UI is an integral part of your vision, having to solve the same set of UI problems in multiple incompatible ways may not be as interesting as solving a conceptually fresh problem. Since UI libraries include some of the more fiddly and arbitrary portions of a platform's API, it's not surprising that programmers would dislike having to code more than one. It's not the difficulty that frustrates, but the multiplication of idiosyncratic difficulties which admit only of incompatible solutions.

more than 2 years ago

Human Brain Places Limit On Twitter Friends

gsiarny Not all social interactions are Tweets. (176 comments)

The Dunbar hypothesis isn't a limit on group size. It argues that an individual can maintain only some 100-200 regular social contacts. Yet if, as the article suggests, a Twitter user stabilizes at a maximum of 150-200 regularly-maintained contacts, they're using up most, if not all, of their Dunbar-space on Twitter alone. So does this mean that people with 150-200 regular Twitter contacts must lose their pre-Twitter real-world regular contacts, or that their pre-Twitter contacts must become Twitter contacts? That seems a bit much to assume without evidence.

I suppose further research will explore how the real-world-and-non-Twitter social life of the twitterati changes as they near their Dunbar limit on Twitter. Perhaps, as the article boldly suggests, "social networks [do] not change human social capabilities" (Conclusions, 7) and the Dunbar limit is indeed resistant to technological circumvention. But this article doesn't make that clear. By not examining the full social space of its subjects, the study does not actually address the possibility that Twitter has increased the number of regular contacts - of all types - that an individual can maintain.

more than 2 years ago

Robots Retrieve Your Books At U. Chicago's $81 Million Library

gsiarny Plenty of browsing just next door (202 comments)

The new glass-and-robots Mansueto Library, with its capacity for 3.5 million books, is right next to the older Regenstein Library, which still has roughly 4 million books in open stacks. Within a five minute walk of these two libraries is the Crerar Science Library with some 1.3 million books in open stacks. The two older "open-stacks" libraries, built in the 70s and 80s, aren't going away anytime soon. The majority of the University of Chicago's collection will therefore continue to be easily browsable by students and faculty alike for decades to come.

The new library will house rarely consulted books and the tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of serial volumes in the University's collection - journals and pamphlets which have already been digitized and need only rarely be consulted directly. The Mansueto is therefore more like a stylish reading room on top of a warehouse of rarely-consulted books - remote storage with five-minute retrieval times.

more than 3 years ago

Robots Retrieve Your Books At U. Chicago's $81 Million Library

gsiarny Re:And this is why tuition rates are out of contro (202 comments)

Now, whether you want to trade a building full of beautiful old books which you can peruse at your own convenience, and staffed with generally knowledgeable bibliophiles, for a mechanized building with 5-minute delay times on book requests and far fewer human employees... that's not so straightforward I hope.

The new building is right next door to the old building, and will be used to store rarely accessed books. The old building is still in use, and holds several million volumes.

more than 3 years ago

How Much Math Do We Really Need?

gsiarny Re:Demonstrable results (1153 comments)

Indeed, in my profession, I use my math education on a daily (if not hourly) basis, while I can't remember a single instance of literature, history, politics and music having any utility or relevance.

Not a single instance? What do you do for a living? Do those in your profession ever interpret a difficult or unclear piece of writing? Do they judge subtexts, written or verbal? Does your profession have a history? Do members of your profession allocate finite resources in society at large? Do they face government certification? Are they subject to government legislation?

Literature, history, politics and music are, frankly, just enrichments

I hope you'd agree that your opinions about what's useful for your profession, and what's useful for your sister's profession, shouldn't be taken as the standard for all professions. Some professions don't use literature, history, politics, or music overtly, or frequently. But you're overreaching to assert that because you don't use them, and because you think your sister doesn't use them, that they're mere "enrichments" for everybody.

more than 3 years ago

Publishing Company Puts Warning Label on Constitution

gsiarny Re:Interpret it correctly (676 comments)

A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State - this means that in order for a country to exist it needs an army to defend itself, yes?

I'm afraid not. A militia and an army were very different notions in 18th-century Britain and the colonies. A militia was composed of the mass of the adult male population which received semiprofessional training once or twice a year. They were rarely "well-regulated," which meant well-organized or well-trained in the arts of war. An army was a professional force of soldiers, paid, maintained, and trained by the state.

See the 1789 debate on the Second Amendment where there were clear distinctions made between standing armies paid and directed by the state and militias composed of the mass of the people.

If you read the other writings of the founders from that time period, you will understand that the point of the 2nd amendment is to ensure that the people retain at least some ability to defend themselves from the militia of the oppressive government.

In the hundred years of debate from the 1680s to 1800 about the necessity of a standing army in peacetime, it was the army that was the agent of government tyranny, not the militia.

more than 4 years ago


gsiarny hasn't submitted any stories.


gsiarny has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?