Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Why Do Humans Grow Up So Slowly? Blame the Brain

indeterminator Re:not so fast (126 comments)

Try behaving like a seven-year-old in grown man's body (on the webs doesn't count), see how that works for you. Your older peers will be a bigger threat to you (and you to them) than disesase and predators.

2 days ago
top

UK Government Report Recommends Ending Online Anonymity

indeterminator Re:Legitimate concerns (282 comments)

Perhaps not, but the supposed "crime" was falsely shouting "fire", and the panic would have happened even if there really was a fire. In any case, no one forced the other patrons to panic. If they did, it was entirely their own fault, and they—not whoever shouted "fire"—are wholly responsible for the consequences.

My understanding of the "shouting fire" metaphore is that it generally assumes it's a false alarm, but I may be wrong. If there really is a fire, the situation becomes very different (there is damage potential for announcing the fact, but there is a larger damage potential for not doing it).

I see this boils down to free will of pepole in a situation they perceive threatening. My understanding about panic (a physical reaction turning off the decision making parts of your brain in a threatening situation, since the decision has already been made: there's a fire, get out now), is that you don't choose whether you get it or not. It depends on how prone you are to get in panic (something you do not have a choice in), and how threatening exactly you consider the situation (in which you do have some choice, by of practicing the situation beforehand).

If we look at the situation statistically, in a full theater there's likely several people who panic at the prospect of being burned alive while queuing for the exit (or by the fact that they may get trampled by other panicing people). The situation is set up in a way that there's direct damage potential from someone shouting a false alarm.

about a month ago
top

UK Government Report Recommends Ending Online Anonymity

indeterminator Re:Legitimate concerns (282 comments)

Shouting "Fire" in a crowded theater necessarily leads directly to the harm of others

Nope. Wrong. Panicking and trampling over people does that, but it's not the speaker who directly made them do that.

So that mass panic in the theater would have happened anyway, without anyone shouting "fire"?

Looking at the events after they're happened, we can conclude that someone unnecessarily shouting "fire" in a crowded theater was a sufficient condition (thus, leading) to people getting hurt. Was it a necessary condition for people getting hurt that way? Common sense says it was.. also anyone who's looking someone to blame.

Before someone shouts it out? No way of knowing what will happen.

If you offer an incentive (survive a theatre fire / money) to someone for committing a crime (trampling someone to death / shooting someone), did you cause it, or was it all on the person who committed the act?

about a month ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Is Running Mission-Critical Servers Without a Firewall Common?

indeterminator No Excuse really these days. (348 comments)

How about this: If you find yourself needing a firewall, your system design has already failed. Every single system should assume actively hostile environment.

I can only repeat your original subject.

about a month ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Is Running Mission-Critical Servers Without a Firewall Common?

indeterminator Re:Fire(wall) and forget (348 comments)

This is network security for Windows 101.

FTFY.

about a month ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Is Running Mission-Critical Servers Without a Firewall Common?

indeterminator Re:Every stupid idea is common (348 comments)

Your username claims you can read, but makes no such claims about writing. Making a spelling mistake and then noticing it yourself seems logically consistent with that.

about a month ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Best Rapid Development Language To Learn Today?

indeterminator Re:Python (466 comments)

I expect server side JS to be about as passing fad as writing operating systems in C.

It's not great for typical cron jobs or admin scripts. What it is great for, is small server damons. The single threaded everything-is-asynchronous model works so well for that, you don't want to go back once you get started.

about 2 months ago
top

Seattle Approves $15 Per Hour Minimum Wage

indeterminator Re:What if you already make $14? (1040 comments)

I admit that your government's spending may be excessive, at least it seems to be driven more by partisan politics than rational thinking. The point I was trying to make was a different one: increasing the minimum wage to match actual minimum living costs won't be cause of hyper-inflation. The point I tried to make in my reply to OP was to present some counter-arguments for the unfairness he saw in raising the minimum wage. My view is that the status quo where people end up working on such a low compensation that their personal finance situation is unsustainable, is already unfair. When the market doesn't fix that by itself, someone needs to step up and take action. I'm not confident that a blanket minimum wage is the correct action, but it's an attempt.

Busineses escaping when their operating environment gets worse, is always a risk. Then on the other hand, it's been a while since the US has been the cheapest place in the world to do anything, so it seems that risk is there anyway. And for a local economy, people moving out because they don't earn enough to live there (or alternatively, get hungry in sufficient numbers to riot on the streets), is a risk also.

about 3 months ago
top

Seattle Approves $15 Per Hour Minimum Wage

indeterminator Re:What if you already make $14? (1040 comments)

a) Congratulations, you're now more of a burden to your employer than you were before, and at higher risk of losing your job entirely when he/she decides it's no longer profitable to run a business.

What will the employer do after he shuts down the business, sit on his hands? I think he has to earn his living somehow, too. Entrepreneurs are not magic fairies (well, most of them aren't).

b) Um, inflation has to be managed, or else it wrecks the economy. Google Weimar or Zimbabwe hyperinflation and get a bit of an education on real world economics.

I didn't say inflation doesn't need to be managed. I said, inflation is inevitable. If you go to zero inflation, there's no incentive to invest. Money stops moving. Economy is screwed.

I know of hyperinflation. To get into one, you need serious economy mismanagement. A 100 million americans going from $10/hr to $15/hr is not going to have that effect. Assuming 40 hour working weeks, 52 weeks a year, the difference is about 1 trillion, or about 6% of the GDB of US (2012). Spread that over a couple of years, and you're well within "normal" inflation, and nowhere near hyperinflation.

c) Slacking in any job long-term doesn't help anyone. The employer gets less value, and the employee's skills don't develop. It's the formula for mediocrity, which you are advocating for gleefully.

Wait, what? Did you even read my post before replying?

about 3 months ago
top

Seattle Approves $15 Per Hour Minimum Wage

indeterminator Re:What if you already make $14? (1040 comments)

If you have spent the past few years busting your ass at a job, and managed to make your way to $14/hr (say, you got promoted to a manager position at a restaraunt)... then what? Do you essentially go back to making minimum wage? Do you now make, as a manager, the same hourly wage as the dishwasher? Increasing the minimum wage is great for people that already make it, but I have always felt like it has screwed those who have worked hard to get a few raises over minimum wage.

(a) Congruatulations, you just got 7% ($1) raise with zero effort. Enjoy.
(b) Others got a raise too. It's not out of your wallet. Inflation is inevitable anyway.
(c) It's not like you can work hard to get raises, and then just start slacking off. In order to keep getting paid that rate, you still need to continuously work hard or smart, or most likely, both.
(d) The manager position you have earned through your hard work is in the long term much more important than the immediate compensation you're currently getting from it. Switching jobs (and yes, that will happen, there are no more for-life careers at single employer), you're likely to start off at similar (or higher, considering you can show ability to start from bottom and work your way upwards) responsibilities than at your current job, along with appropriate compensation level.

about 3 months ago
top

Huawei Successfully Tests New 802.11ax WiFi Standard At 10.53Gbps

indeterminator Re:Nyquist (116 comments)

For data transmission rates, you'll want Shannon's channel capacity, which is not contradicted:
(a) SNR is a factor of channel capacity
(b) It applies for a single channel. With MIMO you have multiple channels (not independent from each other, but with smart channel coding you get gains over SISO).

about 3 months ago
top

How Does Heartbleed Alter the 'Open Source Is Safer' Discussion?

indeterminator Re:Open source was never safer (582 comments)

You do realize that encryption is security through obscurity ... right?

No, it's not. The major difference is, that with a proper cryptosystem, if someone discovers your key, you can just switch to a new key and you're as safe as you were (not considering collateral caused by key leak). With security through obscurity, the once the genie is out of the bottle, you won't make it safe without changes to the design of the system.

As someone said, the ignorance runs deep here.

about 4 months ago
top

How the Internet Is Taking Away America's Religion

indeterminator Re:Good. (1037 comments)

Can god make a stone so heavy that he cannot lift it?

A god could make a stone that he cannot lift, and then lift it, should he want to.

No reason why an omnipotent being could not defy logic.

about 5 months ago
top

Prototype Volvo Flywheel Tech Uses Car's Wasted Brake Energy

indeterminator Re:Safety issues? (262 comments)

Call me when you invent a car that the wheels spin at 60,000 rpm, I want to watch you drive it.

I just invented one. It needs very smooth road though, for its tiny wheels.

about 5 months ago
top

Bitcoin's Software Gets Security Fixes, New Features

indeterminator Re:LOL .. 0.9.0? (173 comments)

The nature of capital investment: getting in early gives you high profit expectation, with high risk of spectacular failure. Getting in late when things have stabilized, gives lower risk with low expected return.

about 5 months ago
top

Snowden Says No One Listened To 10 Attempts To Raise Concerns At NSA

indeterminator Re:The tighter you clench your fist, Lord Vader... (273 comments)

"Seriously, if this is true..."

It's extremely unlikely this is true. Think about it...

He's a sysadmin at the NSA, which means he's supposed to be maintaining their servers -- not looking through classified materials. So if he were to report to his superiors about his concerns with any of these highly classified programs, he'd be admitting to looking at information he should never touch. If he did anyway, he would have been shit-canned immediately and investigated. So, it sounds like a complete pile of horseshit to me.

Either way, this kind of issues should roll uphill, not downhill. If the people in charge can let a Snowden slip, how many more have they let? How many more will they? Someone is trying to avoid their responsibility.

The fact that Snowden was able to get out with the info, suggests the thing is mismanaged. Why was he given access to all this super-classified information, and who's responsible? What was a contractor doing in a super-classified government organization anyway? What Snowden managed to prove, either from the leaked content, or from the fact that there was a leak, is that no one is watching the watchers.

It doesn't matter how you look at it, in the end, it's a complete management screw-up.

about 6 months ago
top

Snowden Says No One Listened To 10 Attempts To Raise Concerns At NSA

indeterminator Re:Blaming the victims ?? (273 comments)

Here we go again, can't vote for them because they have no chance of winning.

You need to start voting for the third guy anyway, it's the only way to break the cycle. if no one votes the thirds guy, then no one thinks he has a chance. Enough people have to go first, and make it look possible.

The part where you're being played, is the part where they make you think that every election you fail to vote an established party, your country is DOOMED, forever. The best part is you keep falling for it every time.

The trick is not to have the new party to win (having a new party to assume total control is a bad idea), but to get them enough votes to scare the established parties to change how your voting works, so they get to keep a share of power relative to their share of votes, even if they would become the third party at the next election.

about 6 months ago
top

Google Funds San Francisco Bus Rides For Poor

indeterminator Re:"Unfair"? (362 comments)

The Google workers who live in SF still pay their taxes in SF, right? I bet they also use local services quite a bit. Property price increase should be welcome to those currently living there, it's much better for them, and the economy as a whole, than prices going down. I admit that I don't fully understand the dynamics of the situation (I don't live in the U.S.), but most places would welcome wealthy neighbors.

If a point-to-point service makes an area so much more desirable, then maybe it was under-valued in the first place. I can't imagine the place being a slum, and then suddenly all googlers want to move there, because free commute.

There is a bigger problem behind all this: unequal wealth and/or income distribution. Fighting a point-to-point private commuting service is not going to fix that.

about 6 months ago
top

Google Funds San Francisco Bus Rides For Poor

indeterminator Re:"Unfair"? (362 comments)

can get away with the continuing destruction of the neighborhoods where there is affordable housing

If a bus line "destroys the neighborhood", you have bigger problems than the bus line.

about 6 months ago

Submissions

indeterminator hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

indeterminator has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>