Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!



Choose Your Side On the Linux Divide

jschrod Re:My opinion on the matter. (826 comments)

Here's to you if that happens to work in your environment. The demands of our costumers are different.

We prefer monitoring checks that are on a business-relevant level. If a process runs or not -- that's what systemd is telling us -- is irrelevant for our level of monitring. It might be a first stage, but that should be obsoleted by proper monitoring conditions. We need monitoring checks that tell us if an account can be opened, if an order can be plaed. Monitoring needs to tell if the business is running. Technical terms like daemons have a rather minor place in this. The real test: can the customer do the things we want him to do.

No customer of us wants to know if our JBoss cluster is running. What they want to know if orders could be placed via the application that's running on our JBoss cluster. And it's our damned professional obligation to provide that information, and not hide behind the excuse "JBoss was not running".

Proper monitoring, as I think about it and as we practice it, is about business-relevant data. It's not about a daemon runnning on one system. It's about "how long does a customer wait to get a dialog served to order a system. Or, "how long does it take to deliver the promised system to the customer." So we create and change new systems, to see how long it takes. If it takes too long, we establish new instances to make that workflow go faster. That's, IMNSHO, is what cloud computing is about: atomatic attaching *and* detaching instances of standardized instances, that are never touched manually, to realize the perfornamce demand of our customer.

I don't demand cloud-like infrastructure recoginition in this discussion (though I'm most familiar with it). But standard virtualized data center environments already show the problems I'm talking about.

Don't get me wrong: I actually like systemd. My probem is that some of its proponents try to sell it for tasks that it has never been made for and will not deliver it. E.g., proper monitoring, a.k.a. business-relevant delivery of information about services

Thinking about it, your might have found a hole in the setup that I deliver to our clients. Folks might have setup daemon-process-based monitoring and left it at this. Grmmbl. Seems we have to detect this low-level monitoring, to escalate it to a proper monitoring in our infrastructure. Thanks for this insight.

about three weeks ago

Choose Your Side On the Linux Divide

jschrod Re:My opinion on the matter. (826 comments)

You and I have very different opinions what "monitoring" is. In my book, systemd does no monitoring at all. It supervizes the daemon it has started, can most often tell if this service processes are running or not (sadly, not reliably enough) and can restart them if necessary. But that's not monitoring.

Get the current login; from Usenix; there's a good article what monitoring is about. It's not about tools. It's about data that is collected by Nagios and its like, collected in systems like Ganglia, and used to manage and to plan services in an overall environment, not per system.

Specific tools are not relevant; that you *do* monitoring for your whole data center on a service level, not on a system's daemon/process level, is relevant.

about three weeks ago

Choose Your Side On the Linux Divide

jschrod Re:My opinion on the matter. (826 comments)

Alternatively, somebody has to take the time to set-up exhaustive monitoring, including ALL the trivial services running on the servers, and some dummy has to watch it around the clock, and manually perform this extremely simple and menial task. Or else maybe you're the dummy who gets paged at 3AM to do a trivial service restart, due to some simple and transitory event.

That, from a 6-digit /. id, lower than mine, makes me almost speachless.

If you don't have a setup system that establishs monitoring automatically and without manual intervention on all new systems; if you have manual supervision of basic monitoring events; if you don't have built-in fail-over strategies -- well, good luck in doing your job. FWIW, what you're doing is not state of the art. If you're responsible for it or if you can influence its architecture, you should work hard to improve the state of your affairs.

The 80s have gone, where we could hand-held every single system we had to manage. These lucky times are over. Thinking about it, they weren't so lucky at all. Porting X10 just to have a graphical desktop was no fun, even though I thought so at that time. Young and foolish and so... ;-)

The assignment today for most people in admin area is to handle 100s to 1.000s of systems. One needs to establish proper means to do so; and manual work ain't it. (You won't be in the situation to handle 10,000s to 100,000s or even millions of systems; otherwise you wouldn't have posted the comment cited above.)

about three weeks ago

EU Court Backs 'Right To Be Forgotten'

jschrod Re:This is bullshit (153 comments)

The information does not belong to the aggregator OR to the person the information is about. The information belongs to the content creator (who sometimes has a copyright on that information as well).

If that's the case in the US, that's an important distinction between the USA and Europe: Personal information belongs to a person, not to any content creator. So-called content creators are not allowed to publish information about me that I haven't approved. Content aggregators like search engines are not allowed to spread the work further.

An exception is made for "persons of public interest". This usually means politicians or movie stars who earn their money with public engagements. It does not mean publication of any minor breach of the law, or similar information.

And yes, this applies to the physical publication world as well. 100,000s of books have been called back, causing much more lost money than in Internet parlance, because this law hasn't been respected in the first place.

Btw, and it ain't so that Google has problems or outrageous costs associated with fulfilling this court's request. They have the infrastructure already in place, to cope with the link takedown demands of RIAA

about 4 months ago

EU Court Backs 'Right To Be Forgotten'

jschrod Re:Those that forget history are doomed to repeat (153 comments)

Exept that the EU court explicitely excepted persons or actions of public interest of that ruling.

And no, there is no formal definition what is a person or action of public interest. This will be decided by courts on a case-by-case decision. As it should be, humans should judge, not algorithms.

about 4 months ago

DarkMarket, the Decentralized Answer To Silk Road, Is About More Than Just Drugs

jschrod Re:Eeeehhhhhh (251 comments)

> Protip - "Uncle Sam has no business in my business" is pretty damn asinine. Because it's pretty clear that he DOES,

In my world, Uncle Sam has no business, but resumes to collect all meta-data of any communication that I do, and for some states even all communication, just because he can. He's called upon it, but the answer is clear: I'll continue to do it because I can. I'm the dominant military power on Earth, I don't have to care for international rights, for human dignity, for justice. Uncle Sam tells me that he's the imperial power left on Earth that can decide who's allowed to live and to die without any court that may intervene.

> especially if your business is selling illegal weapons, murder, kidnapping, etc.

Sorry, but that's not my business. I'm just a normal non-US person supervised by the NSA, as all of us non-US folks are.

Wait, you mean that your civil rights are only for US citizens? They don't belong to us?

There was a time when the U.S.A was looked upon as the guiding light. I'm old enough to remember it. Guys, you destroyed that. You turtore, you kill hundreds of thousands of innocents -- much more than al-quaida ever did, you're the 800 pounds bully on the international political circuit, you won't coorperate, you are the scam on Earth.

> [Uncle Sam] is pretty clear that he DOES have business

You might think so. But I sincerly hope that your Tea Party will take over policital power in the US. It will be a few harsh years for us, world-wide, but they will destroy you better than any foe could do. Then we will be able to continue to build the world society that you don't want to be part of. Sigh, your ancestors lend us the ideas, but you abandoned them.

about 5 months ago

Linus Torvalds: Any CLA Is Fundamentally Broken

jschrod Re:As can ANY of the major CLAs... (279 comments)

You should have looked into the kernel tar files.

The 2nd paragraph of COPYING reads:

Also note that the only valid version of the GPL as far as the kernel is concerned is _this_ particular version of the license (ie v2, not v2.2 or v3.x or whatever), unless explicitly otherwise stated.

Since it is well known fact that Linux is GPLv2 only, what's your intent in denying that? Trolling?

about 8 months ago

Pirate Bay Founder Warg Being Held in Solitary Confinement

jschrod Re:Business as usual (192 comments)

To whomever modded you informative: That Mitnick is not capable is the WHOLE POINT OF IT.

You don't seem to get it. Having rights in the legal system is not reserved for über hackers. It's there for everyone, not even for, but especially for douchebags like Mitnick. That they put him in solitary confinement, him being not a good hacker at all, is the prime example of un-ethical behavior of authorities in the US judical system. (But then, this is a barbaric system with death sentences. So it's part of the system, FWIW.)

Not that this is really different in other parts of the world, as we can read in TFA.

about 9 months ago

A Review of the "Mental Illness" Definition Might Prevent Crime

jschrod Re:Need more mental health centers not prisons (260 comments)

When my knees or hips eventually wear out, they give me new ones and bam, I magically get to walk for another 20-30 years.

If you will be in for this, especially if it concerns your knees; you will then be haunted by that comment.

Because, you will, most probably, not walk without pain for another 20-30 years.

Sincercely yours, probably being a few decades older than you.

about 10 months ago

Elementary School Bans Students From Touching Each Other

jschrod Re:The Type (336 comments)

The school has placed a temporary ban on play at recess or lunch that involves physical contact between kindergarten students. This is in response to a number of injuries that have happened with this particular class.

And they couldn't handle these incidents in a different manner? For example, without punishing the whole group for the behavior of a few? Without installing the knowledge "bullies win" in the kids' minds?

You should better go, and select a different schools for your kids. These so-called teachers are obviously unprofessional and should be avoided. (I'm a pedagogue, FWIW. This is a textbook example how teachers should *not* handle incidents with students. Especially not at kindergarten age where social interactions are to be learned.)

about 10 months ago

CryptoSeal Shuts Down Consumer VPN Service To Avoid Fighting NSA

jschrod Re:Sad (361 comments)

Did the terrorists actually win this war on terror?

Yes, for sure, in the USA they did. It was a full-fledged, all-around victory, without any substantial opposition. That the terrorist's victory also helped companies like Halliburton to enormous profits was not inconvenient, either. Haven't you left your mother's basement in the last 13 years?

about a year ago

CryptoSeal Shuts Down Consumer VPN Service To Avoid Fighting NSA

jschrod Re:SubjectsInCommentsAreStupid (361 comments)

For European companies, the NSA reading their data equals their competitors reading their data. This has been known here since at least the early 90s, when Echolon data was used for commercial advantage of US companies.

Some European companies really don't care. But some do. That's why there was always a healthy mistrust in competetive European companies concerning their crucial data out of house, and why cloud computing has a slower uptake here than in the US. (Their unimportant data, they could care less about, even if it's personal data and against the EU privacy laws. That's life.)

about a year ago

Forrester Research Shows Steep Decline in Free Office Suite Stats

jschrod Re:Office 365 (337 comments)

When I do so, every start of localc nags me with a modal dialog that it's not functional without an JRE. Owing to that nag dialog, I had to turn it on again.

If somebody could tell me how one can avoid that nag dialog, I'd be happy.

about a year ago

Sick of Your Local Police Force? Crowdfund Your Own

jschrod Re:Changing culture (330 comments)

I looked at all your links, and -- while it seems that some parts of Oakland society are seriously messed up -- I don't get your statement that the reports supports your statement "This is a culture that actively celebrates murder and beats or kills those that cooperate with the police."

None of your links reported about such behavior.

If you live in Oakland, maybe you should start to make an appointment with a shrink. It may help you.

But then, maybe not. You US Americans are seriously mad nowadays, looking from the other side of the pond.

about a year ago

Molecule In Corked Wine Plugs Up Your Nose

jschrod Re:So stop using corks (134 comments)

> > Some burgundies from Rebholz, too.

> Really ? How well do they cellar? 20 years seems a bit long. Most pinot noir just doesn't age well.

Actually, I meant his white burgundy grand cru (Im Sonnenschein). Some years wines from him age extremely well; last year I was at one anniversary tasting where he opened bottles from the last 25 years, and there were astonishing wines among them. 15 year old Sekt, still fresh; I couldn't believe it.

His pinot noir age quite well as well; in some years it must age. E.g., currently his 2005 Im Sonnenschein GG is still too closed to be drinkable in good consciousness. Together with Bernhard Huber, Paul Fürst (where Rebholz son currently is an apprentice), Fritz Becker, and a few others, they show what red burgundy from Germany can be like.

> I've got some Kreydenweiss too but it's a bit overpriced.

Full agreement. And you can't rely that every year ages as well as the 89. E.g., 2002 oxidated very early. And there are the years in 2004+ where Antoine (Marc's son) took over, and was still learning the trade. I haven't been in Andlau for the last 5 years or so; but have heard reports that Antoine starts to be better again. A wine from him that's not-as-long-aging but good and not so expensive is the Clos Val d'Eleon.

Marc and Emmanuelle moved from Andlau to Nimes, btw, and make quite good red wines, for early drinking, just 3-5 years in the cellar. If you're in that area, be sure to visit them; Marc is an enthusiastic guy who can and will talk for hours about his wines, the grapes, and process he uses.

> Many good dry Rieslings will keep 20 years I think.

Yes, they do. (That was the point I was trying to make.) Of course, one has to be careful and check when they are about to oxidate -- and then it's a matter of taste if you let them a bit, or if you rather drink them... :-) I remember some 82 Bordeaux where I had bad luck and noticed it too late. :-(

Here's to you, and a have a good glass,

1 year,2 days

Molecule In Corked Wine Plugs Up Your Nose

jschrod Re:So stop using corks (134 comments)

The 89 rieslings in my cellar that still taste fresh, and are just now starting to have a bit of oxidation, beg to differ. E.g., Kastelberg from Kreidenweis. Some burgundies from Rebholz, too.

My 81 Chateau d'Yquems is still considered young.

You don't need lots of tanin to have well aging wines.

1 year,2 days

FISA Court Will Release More Opinions Because of Snowden

jschrod Re:Obama needs to pardon Snowden (179 comments)

That 95% of the world's population feels as if they are powerless against such a tiny minority speaks more about the pathetic majority than the minority.

Do you really think that? That's saddening. I'm glad that, effectively, I don't belong to this "pathetic majority" -- they are scraping to get enough water and enough food, shelter against warlords (in some countries, against US drones targeting cvilians, effectively the same). I, living in a G8 state, have the luxury that 80% of the world's population doesn't have. I can answer drivel like yours.

You might not understand it; but, life's not a Hollywood movie where the good guys win. No, the NSA wins. Those who take our liberty and won't give it back. Hoover is back, now named Alexander; and he's more intelligent and thus more evil. The USA is spending vast amount of its money for its military, its spionage-intel, and associated companies, making it practically impossible for "the pathetic fawning of the rest of the world's governments" (your words) to do anything against it.

Our only hope is, you'll destroy your own society with it. You gave up already and surrendered to terrorists. You complied with them and made your country a fascist police & surveillance state -- which it wasn't before. You made their lies come true. Your society spends insane amounts of money on things that only very few will profit from. The rest of your society goes downhill, and they're voting to go downhill.

Gibbon's "History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire" is a blueprint what's happening to you. Sadly, it seems to need too long before a sane civil movement appears.

1 year,2 days

Toronto Family Bans All Technology In Their Home Made After 1986

jschrod Re:Marriage? (534 comments)

Contraceptive pills appeared in 1961, but it needed to be 1965 that more than 40% of women started to use it.

"Fuck anything that moves" was ever only the lifestyle of very few people; and those lived more in the late 60s than in the early 60s. (I'm old enough to remember this. Are you, too?) And it's not the point that I wanted to make, when I call out US Americans to be prudish.

1 year,3 days

Toronto Family Bans All Technology In Their Home Made After 1986

jschrod Re:Marriage? (534 comments)

It's not the governments fault that the biggest commitment you've ever made to a "relationship" is deciding to pay by the minute or by the hour.

"You've ever made"? As in, me? I live with my partner since 32 years and will do so for the rest of our live. We don't need a state certification to be sure of that. Whom are you talking of? Get back to your mother's basement, and off my lawn.

1 year,3 days


jschrod hasn't submitted any stories.


jschrod has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>