Beta

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Seat Detects When You're Drowsy, Can Control Your Car

mellon Re:**waves arms wildly** (106 comments)

Essentially you are saying that you would rather risk crashing your car than have the health insurance companies know your health status. I think there's a teaching moment in here somewhere. If we can't admit to the system that pays for our health care that we have health problems, something is badly broken. If this is the model for why a car being able to tell you are impaired is "spooky," I think the problem is not with the car.

about two weeks ago
top

Unintended Consequences For Traffic Safety Feature

mellon Re:Not for deaf/hard of hearing... (579 comments)

Actually, you do hear its beeping from inside of nearby buildings. Possibly we just need sound lasers.

about a month ago
top

Microsoft Opens 'Transparency Center' For Governments To Review Source Code

mellon Re:Somebody has to do it (178 comments)

You don't even have to do the Ken Thompson trick. They're showing you source, sure, but is it the actual source from which your binary distro was compiled? Get real. Even if they have good intentions, chances are they don't have a reproducible build process.

about a month ago
top

White House May Name Patent Reform Opponent As New Head of Patent Office

mellon Re:Classic Obama (211 comments)

Obama actually wasn't in favor of passing "Obamacare." That was Pelosi. Obama very nearly decided not to bother. Get your history straight. Obamacare is one of the most recent examples I can think of of Congress doing its job. And if you think I'm an Obama shill, you are just looking for a fight, because I agree with Obama about half the time at best. I'm sure you can find a better Obama shill without looking too far.

about 1 month ago
top

White House May Name Patent Reform Opponent As New Head of Patent Office

mellon Re:Classic Obama (211 comments)

No, you're not getting me. I am not saying Obama is good or Obama is bad because of his good or bad qualities as an autocrat. I am saying he is good because of his good qualities as an executive. The stuff he's doing as an autocrat I sometimes agree with and sometimes disagree with, but it shouldn't be something he has to do as an autocrat. Congress should be doing the right thing, and it's not. We could debate the merits of the various executive orders he's given since he came into office; I certainly understand why he's been acting as an autocrat. Congress wants him to be an autocrat: they've made that crystal clear. But that's the problem. Congress is supposed to be making these policies, but they have abdicated them to the executive. First with Bush, by letting him do things they shouldn't have let him do. Now with Obama by forcing him to set policies they should have set, because they will not govern.

We clearly don't agree in general, but if you think it's okay for Bush to be an autocrat, you can't turn around and say it's not okay for Obama. And if you think it's not okay for Bush to be an autocrat, then we agree; the question is what to do about it.

about 1 month ago
top

White House May Name Patent Reform Opponent As New Head of Patent Office

mellon Re:Classic Obama (211 comments)

It's really simple. I do not think Obama is perfect and wonderful. But I think he is less harmful than Bush Junior was, because he's competent. He gets things done. I don't like everything he gets done, but he is the head of the executive branch, not the legislative branch. It's his job to get things done.

Expecting the president to change laws is treating him or her like an autocrat: a king. The president is not supposed to make policy; he or she is supposed to implement policies made by congress and the courts. What sucked about Bush was that he thought it was his job to "lead the nation" and he did a piss-poor job of it, with Congress' help.

We really need to get over our collective feudal attitude toward the presidency. The founding fathers understood that the president was not a king; George Washington famously refused to be named king. Why have we forgotten this principle?

about a month ago
top

MP Says 'Failed' Piracy Warnings Should Escalate To Fines & Jail

mellon Re:Piracy Warnings (135 comments)

Decreasing government revenues is a choice, not an inevitable outcome of some fundamental change in society. Part of the nature of the decreasing revenue is that we keep moving more and more discretionary spending into corporate welfare, like private prisons. The best part about this is that the worse you treat people in need, the more likely they are to wind up in prison. $$$.

about a month ago
top

Wikipedia Editors Hit With $10 Million Defamation Suit

mellon Re:Well, this won't backfire! (268 comments)

Nono, that's common practice. The problem is that even if the positive stuff is well-sourced, there's almost always less of it than there is of the scurrilous stuff, so WP:DUE doesn't help. (As you can see, I am a veteran of the BLP wars... :)

about a month ago
top

Wikipedia Editors Hit With $10 Million Defamation Suit

mellon Re:Well, this won't backfire! (268 comments)

Required for what? Fairness, or not getting sued? For not getting sued, you are right, but my point is that Wikipedia actually has a serious problem with the way it does BLP articles, one that I don't think can be readily addressed by the current BLP policies. By "problem" I mean that it's producing articles that aren't accurate or useful, not that it's going to get sued. I really don't think that suing them will work to correct this problem, for the precise reason you state. Unfortunately, it may not be possible to fix this, because as far as I can tell Wikipedia isn't taking the problem seriously. I don't expect this lawsuit will change that, because I don't expect it to succeed.

about a month ago
top

Wikipedia Editors Hit With $10 Million Defamation Suit

mellon Re:Well, this won't backfire! (268 comments)

It's not that simple. The problem is that dirt sells, so for any given interesting person, there is always dirt. Getting reliable sources to say anything else about the subject of the BLP is harder, because good news doesn't sell. So if you are a person who is prominent in a small community, and you get famous because of an exciting news story, you wind up with a BLP page that makes you look like a scumbag, and says absolutely nothing about whatever it was that got you prominent enough that a gossip story about you was able to make the news. I've seen this happen to a couple of prominent figures. It's unfixable, because a gossip column is more reliable than an organizational web page. Personally, I count myself lucky that I don't have a wikipedia biography.

about a month ago
top

Otherlab Working on a 'Fundamental Jump' in Technology for Exoskeletons (Video)

mellon Re:lololol (36 comments)

Are you nuts? This is going to help my mom to walk. Screw military applications—if they can make this work, it will change the lives of a lot of people who have physical disabilities.

about a month ago
top

Robert McMillen: What Everyone Gets Wrong In the Debate Over Net Neutrality

mellon Re:Everybody is wrong... (270 comments)

More importantly, it's the only restaurant in town, and there are no grocery stores. So if you want a cheeseburger, you go there. And because of that, they can charge you extra for better service, because nobody else is able to offer you service at all. Honestly, the restaurant analogy doesn't work very well.

about a month ago
top

Robert McMillen: What Everyone Gets Wrong In the Debate Over Net Neutrality

mellon Re:Everybody is wrong... (270 comments)

If you want to use your restaurant analogy, what he's saying is that if the restaurant charges _me_ $5 for a hot dog, they also have to charge _you_ $5 for a hot dog. But no, that analogy still doesn't work, because what's going on here is that the ISP has the only path between you and the greater internet. And they are saying to online services, "look, guys, if you want to get a clean connection to our customers, you have to pay the vig. otherwise, we put you on the congested router, and your customers switch to someone who paid the vig." This is a problem because it disadvantages new entrants to the market: it is anti-competitive. So yes, us pro-competition "commies" want that stopped. I'm not clear on how that makes us commies, but whatever...

about a month ago
top

Robert McMillen: What Everyone Gets Wrong In the Debate Over Net Neutrality

mellon Re:Everybody is wrong... (270 comments)

No, that would be a good analogy if the FCC were going to require Amazon and Newegg to sell their stuff at the same prices. Which they are not going to do, as far as I know.

about a month ago
top

Robert McMillen: What Everyone Gets Wrong In the Debate Over Net Neutrality

mellon Re:Everybody is wrong... (270 comments)

Well, his chart is a good clarifying bit. But aside from that, he seems to be in complete agreement with John Oliver and all the other stories I've read on the topic: the problem is, truly, not with fast lanes, but with slow lanes. If they were not dicking with Level 3 by giving them a more congested link than they give Google, we would have nothing to complain about. The point about the last mile is also true, and going back to Common Carrier-based regulation would address that point, because it would re-open the ability of the FCC to require carriers to sell last-mile bandwidth to their own internal business units for the same price that they sell it to competitors. This is not something new to the discussion, although I will admit that not every article about Net Neutrality covers it.

So I guess this article is worth reading, because I think it does hit on all the major points, but the characterization that it's the first to do so, and that everybody else has gotten it wrong, is essentially clickbait. Forgivable, since in this case the article is worth reading.

about a month ago
top

UK Man Sentenced To 16 Months For Exporting 'E-Waste' Despite 91% Reuse

mellon Re:The headline is juicy, but hides a real problem (212 comments)

RIght, and we should definitely support this plan of yours by relaxing the laws on emission controls... Because after all your desire not to have to repair the computer totally trumps any desire we have to breathe clean air and not see forests destroyed by acid rain.

about a month ago
top

UK Man Sentenced To 16 Months For Exporting 'E-Waste' Despite 91% Reuse

mellon Re:resell working _used_ equipment? Heresy! (212 comments)

Yes, well, we also do a lot to make sure that they don't actually have the opportunity to have a safe environment, and I suspect that feels worse. Talk about arrogance!

about a month ago
top

UK Man Sentenced To 16 Months For Exporting 'E-Waste' Despite 91% Reuse

mellon Re:The headline is juicy, but hides a real problem (212 comments)

It's not—if they can use the TV, they will want to. The problem is that most likely they can't. Even if it's in working order, it has to be able to display the signals that are available to receive, and you have to be able to get power for it. And CRTs draw a lot of power.

about a month ago
top

UK Man Sentenced To 16 Months For Exporting 'E-Waste' Despite 91% Reuse

mellon Re:resell working _used_ equipment? Heresy! (212 comments)

In principle, reuse is a really good thing. And in some cases it's a good thing in practice too. There are definitely things we can export to Nigeria for which Nigerians will benefit from that export. But there is also a very dirty recycling industry in the third world. For stuff they can't use, we ought to keep it and recycle it expensively, rather than shipping it there and have them die young of heavy metal exposure recycling it cheaply.

about a month ago

Submissions

mellon hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

mellon has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?
or Connect with...

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>