Beta

Slashdot: News for Nerds

×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 Re:The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

and there's absolutely no evidence against it.

Well, except for the math being used. You are implying that overlapping states are actually that, instead of just discrete possibilities for one state or another. Schrödingers cat is said to be neither dead or alive. Why? Simply because of the unknown state. It doesnt even have anything to do with atomic decay or whatever, just with the uncertainty provided by a random event generator.
Its even more hillarious when you look at Schrödingers millionaire. Schrödingers millionare is known to play the lottery every week. The chance of winning the lottery is well known, but you dont which numbers he is betting on. The only other thing that you know about Schrödingers millionare is that he will be in the pub every evening. If he wins the lottery he will be in the fancy "Le Pub", otherwise in the "Ye old pub". It is know impossible to know the location of Schrödingers millionaire, its an overlap of probalistic states of either being in "LePub" or being in "Ye old pub". You can however "collapse this function" by "experimental measurement", that is just going to either pub and looking for him. If you find him in "Ye old pub" you will know Schrödingers millionare is, in fact, not a millionare. If you dont find him there you know he is actually a millionaire. Vice versa if you go to "Le Pub" instead.
Assuming Schrödingers millionare is in fact a millionare you will even be able to access unreachable obverserver by collapsing the function, that is by asking the people when Schrödingers was last or first seen in the pub respectivly. You would even know his winning number in that case (assuming the lottery keeps a list of previous winning numbers). This would be equivalent to changing the experiment with Schrödingers cat to have the apperatus releasing the poison include a watch that stops at excactly the moment the poison is released.
From an outside view there is no difference in having an unreachable observer or no oberserver at all. If you actually believe that visiting the pub or opening a box collapses a wave function you also have to believe the other guests or the watch didnt know the real state before you collapsed the wave function.
Obviously you are free to believe your interpretation of the mathematical model used, that electrons actually move through both slits, that the cat is neither dead or alive and that Schrödinger millionaire existed in both pubs but that is obviously not the case since i have unmeasurable drunkions which are experimentaly undetectable reporting directly to me telling me the truth.

about 6 months ago
top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 Re:The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

Simply put, if you extend the slit length, like in an interferometer, you will never detect "half an electron" in either side. So yes, all measurements indicate that every single electron only goes through exactly one slit.
Do an experiment that can somehow detect the presense of a partial electron and i will gladly change my opinion.

about 6 months ago
top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 Re:The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

Thank you for invalditating the article which implies measuring different properties of the same "cat".

about 6 months ago
top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 Re:The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

If the detectors aren't 100% efficient (or not present) any undetected photons will go on to produce the interference pattern - meaning they must have gone through both slits

No. Sorry to be pendantic, but its kinda necessary with stuff like this.
They merely behave like a classic wave. This does not mean the photon (or better a particle like an electron which actually has non-relativistic mass) actually goes through both slits. And barring some duplication or splitting and instant mass teleportation the "moment the universe needs to decide" (the measurement) it doesnt go through both slits at the same time. But paradoxly still behaves like classic wave.

It still is interesting, because (as I understand it) they detected the presence of neutrons only in one arm and their spins only in the other.

Well, they theoretice that. The measurements can only say for certain that a lot more neutrons entered one arm. I mean, if no neutrons entered that arm they might as well have sealed it off completely, after all the only "thing" that went through there are "abstract" properties and those shouldnt be effected by simple matter. Intereference requires that at least a small amount of the wave went through there as well, or in other words, particles at least now and then.

about 6 months ago
top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 Re:The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

If it's like the standard double-slit experiment, each neutron travels through both arms of the interferometer.

Incorrect, quoting wikipedia:

Furthermore, versions of the experiment that include particle detectors at the slits find that each photon of light passes through one slit (as would a classical particle), but not through both slits (as would a wave).

The experiment might have been interesting if the scientists had shot single neutrons instead of stream of multiple neutrons.

about 6 months ago
top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 Re:The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

Because they're scientists with more knowledge of physics than you or me?

I don't understand why you'd automatically assume they haven't measured the same neutron.

Because, quoting the article:

In this experiment, the neutrons pass through a magnetic field to ensure that the spins are aligned in the same direction.

Nice, get a couple of them, guaranteed to have the same magnetic properties. Sounds fine. Lets go on.

They then enter the interferometer where the beam is split so that the neutrons pass down both arms of the device before recombining to produce an interference pattern picked up by a pair of detectors.

Fine. Split them up like a normal double slit experiment. As stated, neutrons in both arms.
But now we have a paradox?

The paradox arises when the team carried out two weak measurements. The first found the presence of neutrons in one arm while the second noted their magnetic properties in the other arm.

As stated above, there are neutrons in both arms. They find evidence of presence of neutrons in one arm (obviously, since they are in both arms) and measure magnetic properties in the other arm (obviously, since there neutrons there as well).
The result is so blatantly obvious. And there is no reason given in the article to assume both measurements apply to the same neutron. Its not like there is an explanation i dont understand, i could live with that, there is no explanation given at all.

Perhaps they have got it wrong; time will tell. I think it's safe to assume that at the very least they remembered to rule out the obvious alternative explanations before publishing.

Perhaps they have ruled out the obvious explanation. In that case the article is utter crap for not mentioning it.

about 6 months ago
top

Physicists Claim First Observation of a Quantum Cheshire Cat

mrwolf007 The most insightfull part of TFA (148 comments)

At issue is whether the result is really paradoxical or simply an ordinary consequence of the way the experiment is set up. For example, perhaps the experiment measures the properties of different neutrons in each of these places.

Personally i dont even understand why those guys are thinking they are measuring the properties of the same neutron.

about 6 months ago
top

BP Hired Company To Troll Users Who Left Critical Comments

mrwolf007 Re: Dream job (263 comments)

This, Samsung, BP, et al. have to pay someone to troll their competitors... Apple gets chumps to do it for free.

What makes you so sure about this?

I have yet to meet a real life apple fan (and yes, i know some people who have pretty much all available kit) that behaves anywhere near as stupid as the common internet troll. Sure, anonymity might have something to do about it, but i really doubt there are that many people who actually care about Apple like a religion.

about 8 months ago
top

Sweden Is Closing Many Prisons Due to Lack of Prisoners

mrwolf007 Sure (752 comments)

But they just dont have enough space for all the NSA employees.

about 8 months ago
top

How Your Compiler Can Compromise Application Security

mrwolf007 Re:News flash (470 comments)

Obviously there is an example in the first page of the paper. What follows is mostly a direct quote from there.

char *buf = ...;
char *buf_end = ...;
unsigned int len = ...;
if (buf + len >= buf_end)
return; /* len too large */
if (buf + len < buf)
return; /* underflow, buf+len wrapped around */ /* write to buf[0..len-1] */


char *buf = ...;
char *buf_end = ...;
unsigned int len = ...;
unsigned int buf_len= buf_end-buf;
if (len>buf_len) return; /* write to buf[0..len-1] */

There fixed it for ya.

They say they found this code in Chromium, Linux and Python.

If this had been some newb project i would have just frowned. But hearing those levels of incompetence reach so far hurts my head.

about 9 months ago
top

How Your Compiler Can Compromise Application Security

mrwolf007 Re:News flash (470 comments)

Maybe a developer has added logic like this - "if (someBadCondition) int x = 1 / 0;" to force an exception or fault to be thrown.

As opposed to "if (someBadCondition) exit(E_MYBADCONDITION);"? Actually might as well write to a log fire before exiting as well.

But sorry, if a dev actually uses something like in your example he should consider switching to a different job.

about 9 months ago
top

German Report: Obama Aware of Merkel Spying Since 2010

mrwolf007 Re:Wutend (280 comments)

Actually there are better examples from german history.
Under chancellor Bismark Germany had good relations and treaties with most european nations. After he was fired by the young Kaiser Willhelm those ties dissolved and soon after WW1 broke out.
Lesson to be learned, no matter how big you are (and Germany was a lot bigger back then), pissing off everyone isnt a good idea.

about 9 months ago
top

1.8 Million-Year-Old Skull Suggests Three Early Human Species Were One

mrwolf007 Re:1.8 Million-Year-Old Skull Suggests ... (168 comments)

Actually i was just poking fun at the title, for claiming "1.8 Million-Year-Old skull Suggests ..." instead of reading "Scientists studying 1.8 million year old skull suggest ...".

about 9 months ago
top

1.8 Million-Year-Old Skull Suggests Three Early Human Species Were One

mrwolf007 1.8 Million-Year-Old Skull Suggests ... (168 comments)

Man, the real story here is the skull.

It dont really care what it suggests, the mere fact it was talking is creepy...

about 9 months ago
top

Nokia's Elop Set To Receive $25 Million Bonus After Acquisition

mrwolf007 Fail (196 comments)

First of all. Android isnt an instant success guarantee that some people seem to postulate.
Obviously you need to distinguish yourself. I mean, rock solid hardware, bloody good cameras, you know things like that.
But the big, bloody obious point to be made. Do you know a single phone manufacturer that sells more Windows phones than Android phones? I mean, quite a few have both in stock. There are enough models around that are available with either Android or Windows. Please enlighten me if there are any of those that actually sell better with Windows.

about 10 months ago
top

Crowdfunded Bounty For Hacking iPhone 5S Fingerprint Authentication

mrwolf007 Re:Broken on first day (148 comments)

Hmm, so how many things did Apple patent that they didnt bother to implement?
And givent he fact that most testers probably wont find a test candidate to chop a finger off ill guess i just ... have to take your word for it?

about 10 months ago
top

Apple Has a Lot In Common With The Rolling Stones (Video)

mrwolf007 Re:Ho-hum, another really amazing device (147 comments)

The phones these days are so bloody wonderful that apart from adding a Fleshlight and 3D holograms, what the heck else do you want.

There have already been several phones with 3D displays, didnt seem to be something people were really interested in.

And, uhm, i heard fanbois of the various smartphone vendors love their phones, but seriously, you know a marketing slogan like "Life Companion" probably wasnt meant you should actually, well, do that bees and flowers stuff with a phone.

about 10 months ago
top

Mechwarrior Online Developer Redefines Community Warfare

mrwolf007 Re:Not P2W (189 comments)

So, what you're saying is that there is a game mechanic (the XP system) whose effects are to make the game less fun by turning it into work, but which you can pay real money to lessen, and you don't see that as a problem?

Yeah, having an "XP system" is obviously a pretty stupid idea. I doubt it will catch on in any MMO or MMORPG.

about a year ago

Submissions

top

Apple faking evidence?

mrwolf007 mrwolf007 writes  |  more than 2 years ago

mrwolf007 (1116997) writes "The legal battle between Apple and Samsung over the import ban on the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in the EU is getting increasingly redicilous. First Apple won an injunction against Samsung. Later in turned out that Apple filed the case in the wrong court (google translation). Thought you heard it all by now?
Now reports show that Apple even faked evidence (google translation) to aquire the injunction."
top

Germany planning 400 billion euro solar center

mrwolf007 mrwolf007 writes  |  more than 5 years ago

mrwolf007 (1116997) writes "Several large german companies are planning the worlds largest solar center. At an estimated cost of 400 billion euros the center is supposed to provide 15% of the electricity for Europe. The center will be built in Africa and use parabolic mirrors to heat a special oil which in turn powers large turbines. The center is planned to be operational in 10 years. Original article (in german)."
Link to Original Source
top

Happy birthday Nmap

mrwolf007 mrwolf007 writes  |  more than 6 years ago

mrwolf007 (1116997) writes "For those of you who havent heard it yet, Nmap is now ten years old. The network scanner is now available in version 4.5, which is the first mayor release since 4.0 two years ago. Looking past, Nmap has been featured in at least 5 films, inclunding the second part of Matrix and The Bourne Ultimatum, and is probably in the toolbox of almost every person interested in network security, be it jobwise or otherwise. Further information can be found on the official release notes."

Journals

mrwolf007 has no journal entries.

Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...