Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Intuit Beats SSL Patent Troll That Defeated Newegg

nomanisanisland Re:It's not the infringement that's the issue (59 comments)

The ability to create many copies of something for virtually free has nothing to do with whether it is patentable or not. Abstract mathematical formulas and algorithms are not patentable, but their application in something tangible is patentable.

The real issue isn't whether software patents as a class are valid or not in general - they are under current laws, even though some specific cases are not - no, the real issue is whether they should be patentable going forward. People forget that the concept of patents aren't an innate or natural right, but rather something invented for the purpose of incentizing R&D, and disclosing the invention so that others can see how it works instead of it being a trade secret. The question is if those benefits would not happen if there were no patents for software.

about 2 months ago
top

I Want a Kindle Killer

nomanisanisland Re:Nonsense (321 comments)

I agree - it's a damn good book reader, and adding speech input and stylus input and other crap is completely missing the point of a Kindle.

The one thing I'd like to see, in both the physical and app-based Kindle readers, is a way to organize the books in the library. I've got 335 books: 90 downloaded and 245 archived, and it's painful to find one or browse. You can sort by title, author, recently viewed, and "type"; but I rarely remember the author names or titles, and the "type" sorting seems useless.

A lot of the books I have are fiction books in a series, like Honor Harrington or Lost Fleet or whatever, but I have to search the web to find what book title goes next in the series. Since Amazon doesn't appear to know the actual series order, I'd like to be able to edit the titles to reflect it, or somehow add that metadata to it.

I also have tech books on various topic areas. So I'd also like to be able to create folders, and sort by my rating of them, etc.

But perhaps most Kindle users don't read a book a second time ever?

about 3 months ago
top

Snowden to Critics: Questioning Putin Has Opened Conversation About Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Dumbass (168 comments)

It's a nice try, but it's not analogous, and I think you know that.

For one thing, Bletchley Park didn't monitor their citizens wholesale; they didn't have the technical capability to do that.[1] That's the part of Snowden's revelations that infuriates so many people, and should also make you afraid. You don't have to go very far back in US history to be afraid of such a thing: imagine if J. Edgar Hoover had the NSA's assets. Monitoring foreign powers is a different story, and I have a hard time believing that part of Snowden's leaks truly surprised any foreign nation (it's what we pay the CIA to do, ultimately).

For another thing, we're not actually in a war right now, unless you want to claim the "war on terror" is an excuse to do such things. (a type of "war" that conveniently has no possible end date, no possibility of peace treaties, armistice, etc.; and a type of "war" in which everyone is a suspect... the proverbial boogeyman)

[1] Ironically Britain's gone a lot further in monitoring their citizens these days than Bletchley Park could, and further than even the US has gone. But that doesn't really matter. Last time I checked, the US revolted from British rule, and had some documents they claimed they abide by instead.

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Useful Idiot (396 comments)

The moms and dads of America are proud to send their sons and daughters off to war, in return for some college money and the condition that we do our best to return them in one piece. That's the deal. Snowden broke faith with a whole lot of military families.

The commentary on Slashdot is so onesided, its astonishing. A little bit of surveillance is a small price to pay. Some pay everything.

I have the utmost respect for the men and women who put themselves in harm's way to protect my country, my family, and myself. But I like to believe they also do it to protect our way of life, and the ideals our country stands for. "A little bit of surveillance" is an enormous price to pay - it changes what this country is about, to be something less worthy.

And this isn't just about the Constitution or the ideals of liberty... there are some very practical reasons not to allow our government to perform surveillance of its citizens in the manner they've been accused of. It's not hard to imagine such abilities could be abused, and it's not like we haven't had people like J. Edgar Hoover. Imagine what Hoover would have been able to do given the NSA's knowledge.

If our military asked for money to protect our soldiers, with better body armor, better protection for Humvee's, etc., I'm all for it. But ask us to give up our liberty? No. That's not the deal.

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Old proverb (396 comments)

A regexp for your position would be [*] US is wrong.

For the syntax of most regex engines, star "*" in a regex bracket expression is not a special character - it is the literal star character. (sorry for pointing this out, but this is /. after all, so I can't help myself)

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Useful Idiot (396 comments)

rahvin112: if I could mod you up I would. Totally agree. It's a shame really.

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Useful Idiot (396 comments)

He could have gone to Congress.

What does "gone to Congress" mean? You mean like just walking in the front door and demanding speaking time during a joint session of both houses? (not gonna happen) Or do you mean he could have contacted a congressman, which would give him a fairly high chance of being arrested within hours for being a traitor? (or do you think contacting a congressman with information about the NSA's activities would somehow remain quiet for long?)

Maybe you aren't aware of it, but under the US Constitution the Congress has special powers that are quite useful in situations like this.

Maybe you aren't aware of it, but the US Constitution doesn't seem to have much applicability to NSA activities.

He stole ~ 1.7 million highly classified intelligence documents, fled the country, and started leaking them to whomever wanted a copy - at least as far as we have direct proof. He could have covertly done far worse. The description doesn't seem unreasonable.

Actually, according to the Guardian journalist, Snowden wouldn't give them a copy of everything. You can disbelieve him, but at least on the surface it appears Snowden was being more careful than Chelsea Manning. (and yes, I consider Chelsea Manning a traitor)

There's no debate Snowden stole highly classified intelligence documents and leaked them to the press. But that doesn't mean he's automatically a traitor. He might be, but we don't know. For example, suppose you had highly classified intelligence documents that implicated the NSA in a coup attempt to overthrow our elected leaders or coerce them in some way. Revealing those documents would not make you a traitor; quite the opposite. And for some people, what Snowden revealed shows an unconstitutional and potentially dangerous action by a portion of our government. If they're right, he's no traitor; quite the opposite.

And I'm only talking about the part that reveals blanket monitoring of US citizens, without cause nor due process. Monitoring foreign nationals isn't unconstitutional, and is what we should want our government to do: it's why have the CIA and NSA and so on to begin with. (Sorry Merkel, but monitoring Europeans is fine too, including their elected officials. We're friends now, but haven't always been, and might not forever be.)

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Useful Idiot (396 comments)

He chose to flee to the two countries with the BIGGEST free speech / surveillance issues in the world-- China and Russia-- after publicly blowing the whistle on much lesser instances in the US.

I mean we're throwing a fit about the NSA's capturing of "metadata". China just snorts up every bit of cell and internet data that goes in or out of any ISP or carrier, and they barely attempt to hide it. Im sure Russia is pretty close.

I don't know about you, but I don't want my country to only have to be slightly better than China or Russia. I don't give a crap how bad or good Russia or China are; I only care that my country abide by the values it claims to uphold. Being China++ doesn't mean much.

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Useful Idiot (396 comments)

I asked my senator if he had ever called her about his concerns. She said "no." I'm going to go out on a limb and say that he never called Ron/Rand Paul, or any other congressman that one would assume would be receptive to the sort of grievances Snowden supposedly has.

For a few seconds I thought you were being serious, and I was going to respond with something like "You think going to a politician, any politician, with material the government considers treasonous to reveal, is a good idea?!?" But then I realized you must be joking, because no one is that insane. So I applaud you sir/madame, well done! You had me a for a bit.

about 4 months ago
top

Snowden Queries Putin On Live TV Regarding Russian Internet Surveillance

nomanisanisland Re:Useful Idiot (396 comments)

He probably could have tried legal measures to implement reform if it was actually more important to him than being famous

Really? What legal measures could he have tried while remaining in the US? He would have been arrested faster than SSD read times, and never heard from again for "national security" reasons. The government's first response was to label him a traitor - they don't let you have much freedom as a traitor, in case you didn't know. I doubt any legal measures he could have tried before being arrested as a traitor would even have been reported on by the press, again for national security reasons.

Whether you think his revelations were right or wrong, I think you'd have to agree he couldn't have truly revealed anything successfully by staying in the US.

about 4 months ago
top

SSD-HDD Price Gap Won't Go Away Anytime Soon

nomanisanisland Re:HDD is fine for .. 98%? (256 comments)

Lets be honest here - outside of a small percentage of users doing raw uncompressed video operations HDD are more than fast enough.

Let's be honest here - you've never used a system with an SSD, have you? The difference is surprisingly noticeable. Many people say that when they upgraded their HDD to an SSD, it was like getting a new computer. They're right. I recently did it, and it's an amazing difference. And no, I don't do anything with uncompressed video, or any video.

What I do is programming. So I do things like 'make' a lot, and 'git checkout', and even 'grep', and so on. All of those types of things improve with an SSD, because they all involve file access, for a lot of files.

So I guess in a way yes, you're right: outside of the small percentage of users who do things with files of any type, or that would get an improvement with faster memory paging (because that too is faster), or that open and close apps a lot, HDD are more than fast enough. Of course the "small percentage" might be quite large, at least for /. readers.

about 4 months ago
top

Student Records Kids Who Bully Him, Then Gets Threatened With Wiretapping Charge

nomanisanisland Re:To the crazy people (798 comments)

Pennsylvania is a two-party consent state, so by my understanding of wiretapping laws there, what this kid did was illegal.

Then the school administrators should be charged with tampering with evidence. And the judge should have thrown it out for lack of evidence. And the police officer should be reprimanded for failing to Mirandize the kid, and the kid was actually a minor (15 years old) so not bringing in the parent before interrogating him is another reprimand.

about 4 months ago
top

Student Records Kids Who Bully Him, Then Gets Threatened With Wiretapping Charge

nomanisanisland Re:Rewarding the bullies... (798 comments)

School administrators do not charge anyone with anything. They are not the law and do not file charges or determine what charges should be filed. It sounds to me it is a lot more likely that the police determined that a crime had been committed BECAUSE IT HAD. Pennsylvania is one of the few all-party consent states and it is illegal to record somebody without notifying them that you are recording. The kid DID break the law.

So, recording in a public place (it was a public school classroom, in front of others) is illegal in PA? Then the school administrators should be charged with tampering with evidence. And the judge should have thrown it out for lack of evidence. And the police officer should be reprimanded for failing to Mirandize the kid, and the kid was actually a minor (15 years old) so not bringing in the parent before interrogating him is another reprimand. So in summary: EPIC FAIL.

about 4 months ago
top

How Apple's CarPlay Could Shore Up the Car Stereo Industry

nomanisanisland Re:Wouldn't trust Apple (194 comments)

Probably because it's geared towards the high-end of the market. The aftermarket stereos and cars this is geared toward are luxury ones, not economy brands. My guess is the demographics of that market are more in Apple's iPhone/iPad sweet-spot than Android's. But I have no data to back that up, just personal observation.

about 4 months ago
top

How Apple's CarPlay Could Shore Up the Car Stereo Industry

nomanisanisland Re:Wouldn't trust Apple (194 comments)

Most of Apple's customers are children, yuppies, and idiots. No one who actually understands technology[hardware and software] and mathematics buys Apple products.

That's interesting, since I meet a lot of software developers at other companies and the most common laptop maker they have (by far) are Apple ones: MBP or Air. Now maybe it's the tech industry I'm in (networking), or the type of developers I meet (highly paid ones who travel), but they can't all be stupid.

I used to tease them about it, until I got one because I was fed up with my employer-supplied laptop... and I have to say they are really, really good. There are some very frustrating things about Apple, no debate, but compared to the competition? Not even close. If I want to boot to linux or run it in a VM I can, but sometimes you just want something that works well without being a sysadmin; and the physical design is really good.

They're way expensive, but it's the thing you use all day, every day. If you can afford it at all, I think it's worth it. If you can't afford it, there's nothing to argue over.

It's like arguing over monitors. If you can afford a 30" or bigger IPS and you would use it all the time, get one. If you can't, don't complain that you don't need the extra inch or two.

about 4 months ago
top

How Does Heartbleed Alter the 'Open Source Is Safer' Discussion?

nomanisanisland Re:"Many eyes" discovered quickly, didn't disclose (582 comments)

Data point: the NSA reportedly discovered this bug within days of its placement, and didn't disclose it.

And a source for that "data point" would be...?

about 4 months ago
top

How Does Heartbleed Alter the 'Open Source Is Safer' Discussion?

nomanisanisland Re:Wat? (582 comments)

What the OpenSSL team seems to have failed to do is to perform a really serious amount of destructive testing on their library which, as you pointed out is essentially what black hats do to find these kinds of vulnerabilities anyway. This is not surprising since quality assurance and testing seems to be a bit of a poor relations many FOSS projects just like it is in the closed source community.

Actually that surprised me quite a bit. A lot of FOSS projects do perform testing, at least automated testing. And some even do fuzz testing. And some even run static code analyzers. So considering how important and widely-used OpenSSL is, I was surprised to hear they didn't. So I went and checked and they do appear to have some test code. Obviously not enough, or at least not for this new hearbeat feature, but they do have some.

Finally, when something is as widely used and fundamental to the workings of the internet and online commerce as OpenSSL is one would expect that perhaps some of the big beneficiaries of the OpenSSL project like Google, Apple, Amazon, Facebook etc. could foot the bill to do some suitably paranoid amount of quality assurance on it and other such FOSS projects.

I'm with you 100% on that. They have no legal obligation of course, but damn they look really cheap and slimy right now. (except for maybe Apple since they don't use OpenSSL, but then again they had their own embarrassing security bug just a few months back)

about 4 months ago
top

How Does Heartbleed Alter the 'Open Source Is Safer' Discussion?

nomanisanisland Re:the heartbleed bug was introduced by a jew (582 comments)

it's not a matter of open source but a matter of having israel partisans working on mission critical code.

You're obviously a troll and an idiot, but just for the record: I don't know if Seggelmann is Jewish - his last name is, but then so are a lot of German last names... and he's German (not Israeli) and there aren't many German Jews left - but the reviewer of the code was Stephen Henson, who is not Jewish. Do you blame him too? RSA (the company that became synonymous with public crypto, and the algorithms they patented) stands for Ron Rivest, Adi Shamir, and Len Adleman. The last two are also Jews, and Adi Shamir is actually an Israeli. Do you blame them too? In fact, according to the Bible, there's this guy named Jesus who was also a Jew. Do you blame him too? As it happens, there are a disproportionate number of Israeli programmers in the tech space, mostly because as far as I can tell they've always had a high ratio of well-educated people in math and comp sci, and lately an influx of of well-educated former-Russians too. Thank god it wasn't an Indian or Chinese programmer who caused this, or /. servers would collapse from the comments.

about 4 months ago

Submissions

nomanisanisland hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

nomanisanisland has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>