Beta
×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

The Physics of Why Cold Fusion Isn't Real

osu-neko Re:The science is settled, stop doing science! (347 comments)

Not at all. His message is, if you think it's real, then start doing science! He doubts it's real because the people who claim it is refuse to even try actual science -- you know, that thing where you document experiments and publish with sufficient levels of detail that allow the results to be independently verified.

Even if you think it's real, you have to admit that what they're doing is not science. Or at least, you have to admit that if you're honest and know what "science" is. It might be invention, but it absolutely isn't science.

about a week ago
top

The Physics of Why Cold Fusion Isn't Real

osu-neko Re:Wrong (347 comments)

A hydrogen bomb yields more energy than was put it, by a large margin.

Sort of, but most of it's waste energy. Show me a process where the amount of power you receive back into the power-grid from setting off an H-bomb is greater than the energy you used constructing it...

about a week ago
top

The Physics of Why Cold Fusion Isn't Real

osu-neko Re:"repeatable independently verifiable reproducti (347 comments)

A patent will just be violated, and completely ignored. Keeping it secret is the way to go, similar to Heinlein's Shipstones. Place a tamper-resistant box at the client's location, set a meter to charge by the watt-hour, and be done with it. Someone tries breaking into the box, it completely obliterates anything inside showing how it works, or just does a big kaboom, Outer Limits, "Final Exam" style.

Ah, yes. One of Heinlein's most unrealistic, least believable premises ever, and that's saying a lot.

Meanwhile, in the real world, your invention will be reverse-engineered in a matter of months if not sooner.

about a week ago
top

Debian Talks About Systemd Once Again

osu-neko Re:Remove It (519 comments)

What if I want a straight text log file that requires no other tools?

Then you write your systemd log in text format. If you can't figure out how to do that, you're not qualified to be reading the log file output.

Why would anyone even have a binary log on a *nix system?

It takes less space, especially if you're archiving them for long periods, causes less I/O in general and less disk fragmentation over time as you compress and delete them every day/week. Note that indeed, you do the same on most classic BSD or SysV init systems by compressing the old logs, requiring you to use a tool to dump them to text if you want to read them later... but that's not as efficient.

If you want binary log files that require tools to dump them to text, use Windows.

Do you turn off the compression of logs on your boxes, or do you admit that having to use a tool to read them isn't so big a deal when you aren't grasping at straws to justify why you hate a particular piece of software?

about a week ago
top

Earth Gets Another Quasi-Moon

osu-neko Re:That's no Moon (54 comments)

There's no dark side of the moon. It's all dark, really...

Well, there is a darker side. It's just not always the same side.

about three weeks ago
top

Physicists Find Clue as To Why the DNA Double Helix Twists To the Right

osu-neko Re:So evolution possibly already happened ... (120 comments)

Depending on how you define "life", yes. In fact, almost certainly, regardless of which definition of "life" you choose. Selection can occur in any kind of chemical or physical process in which produces similar but not always identical results. There's nothing special about the particular chemical processes we call "life", nor some magic line in the sand you can draw and say "this is life, and this isn't" -- it gets rather fuzzy on the edges, and the distinction between life and other chemical processes is as arbitrary as the distinction between which celestial bodies we decide to call "planets" and which we decide don't qualify. Nature doesn't care much for our arbitrary distinctions.

about a month ago
top

Google Quietly Nixes Mandatory G+ Integration With Gmail

osu-neko Re:Does it matter? (139 comments)

Not sure if I follow the real name policy argument. Personally, I understand that people want privacy and there was a huge outcry when Blizzard also required real names as part of their RealID row out. But at the same time I think the issue that both Blizzard and Google wanted to address was cyber-bullying by hiding behind the anonymity of the internet.

You can tell people at a company are speaking from a place of privilege when they assert that using real names will reduce bullying/make people safer/etc. For many of us, using real names pretty much guarantees bullying and danger, and quite possibly even threatens our lives. From Blizzard, it really takes the cake. Like I'm going to put my life in jeopardy for the sake of a video game. And even if the threats aren't serious, many people would just rather avoid the hate and abuse to begin with, even if it's "only" verbal/emotional abuse. Some people use anonymity as a weapon, but most of us use it as a shield. Congrats for those lucky enough to not need it, but understand we're not all so lucky. Removing it just further marginalizes those who aren't privileged enough to be safe without it.

about 1 month ago
top

Scotland Votes No To Independence

osu-neko Re:Everyone loses (474 comments)

People always think the world is currently going to Hell around them, even while living in a golden age.

about a month ago
top

Dealership Commentator: Tesla's Going To Win In Every State

osu-neko Re:Spot on (156 comments)

s/server/service/

about a month ago
top

Dealership Commentator: Tesla's Going To Win In Every State

osu-neko Re:Spot on (156 comments)

I buy damn near everything over the internet. I get exactly what I want from a competitive marketplace. Why can't I buy a car to my exact specifications direct from the manufacturer? If Amazon can deliver almost anything to my front door, why can't GM, Ford and Toyota deliver a car to my door?

In your scenario your going to hate it when you need warranty work and the dealers tell you that you need to take it to an authorized warranty repair center for directly purchased cars. BTW that service center is three states over.

You mean like how I can't get warranty repair on my Dell because I'm nowhere near Texas? Oh wait, I can. Hell, I can get the tech to come right out to my office and do it on-site, I don't have to take it anywhere. Funny what happens when there's a competitive marketplace, and the ease or difficulty of getting service and support is something consumers consider. Or were you imagining a scenario where car buyers worry less about server than computer buyers? Cars are so cheap, after all. Oh wait...

about a month ago
top

Welcome To Laniakea, Our New Cosmic Home

osu-neko That's very large... (67 comments)

One wonders how long it will be until it's entirely represented in Elite: Dangerous. :)

about 1 month ago
top

Ask Slashdot: Linux-Friendly Desktop x86 Motherboard Manufacturers?

osu-neko Re:SteamOS compared to OUYA? (294 comments)

I didn't immediately think shill. The previous fourth console (OUYA) appears to have failed to take away any market share from the big three. What makes Steam Machine different?

Valve/Steam? And are we really comparing a kickstarter project to a powerhouse of the gaming industry? This is a bit like noting a number of minor manufacturers people never heard of failed to gain any marketshare in the early MP3-player market, therefore it was folly to expect Apple to succeed. Of course, Apple had the advantage of pairing their new devices with an online distribution service for content, whereas Valve... oh, wait...

about 2 months ago
top

Researchers Hack Gmail With 92 Percent Success Rate

osu-neko Re:the hard way (87 comments)

what they are doing makes little sense

Clue tip: If something appears to make little sense, you probably missed something. Your immediate response to that should be, "what am I missing?", not "okay, these professional scientists must be idiots who don't understand the topic they have Ph.D.s in as well as I do". Appeal to authority is bad, of course, but if you find yourself at odds with an expert, it should at least prompt a bit of self-critical examination to double-check where you might have missed something that, if you hadn't, would have made it all make sense. Like here, where the point of what they're doing is to determine a heck of a lot more than simply what the foreground process is, but rather, what the foreground process is doing.

about 2 months ago
top

3 Congressmen Trying To Tie Up SpaceX

osu-neko Re:What? (393 comments)

In either case, it makes it more difficult for private citizens to do what they want with their money by either increasing the cost of borrowing or directly taking it from them.

For some specific individuals, yes. For "private citizens" in general, no. The citizens as a whole have the exact same amount of money either way. The government doesn't take the money from taxes and bury it in a hole somewhere, it spends it, usually on employees that are predominantly citizens, or companies that are usually located within the same country. Indeed, money spent by the government is more likely to be spent on in-country companies that money spent by non-governmental organizations. The idea that the people have less money when taxes are higher is absurd. They money is redistributed, not eliminated. The people as a whole have the same amount of money regardless of whether taxes go up or down.

about 2 months ago
top

3 Congressmen Trying To Tie Up SpaceX

osu-neko Re:What? (393 comments)

The argument is that the government doesn't create wealth.

Yes. The argument is that if you call a large organization a government, it doesn't create wealth, whereas if you call it a corporation, it magically does... by acquiring money from some parties and redistributing it to further parties. Those first parties will have had their money stimulate other business, instead of having had it been taxed, where the government would have then spent it, usually by giving it to businesses to do whatever job that needs to be done. In the end, the same amount of money is in the economy, and the same amount is in the hands of other businesses, all that's changed is which specific businesses have it, what work is actually done, and who benefits from the work done.

about 2 months ago
top

3 Congressmen Trying To Tie Up SpaceX

osu-neko Re:What? (393 comments)

Well, if you're going to go that route, the contractors don't build anything either, they just arrange/rearrange the materials they're given. By that standard, nothing's ever been built on Earth, we're just assembling stuff left over from the last local supernova.

By any reasonable definition, NASA builds a lot of stuff.

about 2 months ago
top

Elementary OS "Freya" Beta Released

osu-neko Re:Unless there is some killer feature (209 comments)

Unless there is some killer feature, or the distribution is tailored well to a specific niche, I am quite bored with the "yet another Linux distro" articles

If you weren't interested in the article, why did you click on it? You know you're not required to read the ones that don't interest you?

Even better, you commented on it. Comments count even more than clicks to the bean-counters who determine which articles are generating the most interest and thus should be focused on more by the site. Comments are more content for the site, creating even more for people to read, and ultimately, more ad-revenue for the bean-counters. Even if your comment is negative, it's presence and the debate that it engenders encourages sites to post more of exactly what you commented on.

If you want to see less of something, actually prove it by not looking at it in the first place. That is what sends the site a loud and clear message about what you'd like to see more or less of.

about 2 months ago
top

Babylon 5 May Finally Get a Big-Screen Debut

osu-neko Re: And so it begins... (252 comments)

What really irked me was the human characters betraying their oath to Earth and going native after they had kicked Clark out of office.

They didn't betray their oath. Arguably they upheld their oath better than others. They did what was in Earth's best interest, even when Earth's government (and probably most of its people) would consider them traitors for it. Their oath was to Earth, not its government, and they chose the path of true loyalty rather than blind obedience. You seem to be confusing loyalty to your country with loyalty to your government. Sometimes the former requires defying the latter.

about 2 months ago
top

Oracle Hasn't Killed Java -- But There's Still Time

osu-neko Re:Nobody kills Java (371 comments)

Old languages never die, they just stop being hyped.

about 2 months ago

Submissions

Journals

osu-neko has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?