×

Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

Double Take: Condoleezza Rice As Dropbox's Newest Board Member

quax Re:Force her out! (313 comments)

Not only is it morally reprehensible, it is not even effective.

And yes, it is torture.

The Senate report's findings are not some surprisingly new or unforeseeable result. This was well established and repeatedly pointed out to the Bush administration.

And No, the greatest US generation did not do this.

Only in a deeply warped society would some weasel lawyers construct the kind of twisted logic that you are espousing. Your definition is so far outside the mainstream, it doesn't even qualify as a joke. So yes, it is irrelevant.

And while I am happy that you are not happy about this state of affairs, it doesn't make a yota of difference. Your rational is irrational and the method profoundly wrong.

As to being able to catch terrorists without torture, you didn't pay attention to what I earlier wrote. We got all the RAF bad guys and one of the worst terrorists before Bin Laden was caught the old fashioned way, with solid intelligence and diplomacy.

Terrorism was always a reality in most Western countries (but North America) and we dealt with it without misplacing our values.

If you never even heard of Hitchens it's a pretty save bet that you never heard about any of this foreign history, and live on a Faux News diet.

Maybe you should try to travel the world a bit.

 

3 days ago
top

Double Take: Condoleezza Rice As Dropbox's Newest Board Member

quax Re:Force her out! (313 comments)

Please stop misquoting Orwel, he was talking about war not about abusing prisoners.

"foreign democracies aren't as open as ours"

Of course how could any foreign democracy ever be as open as the US. Nothing in Europe or the rest of the world could *ever* touch the US in openness.

Hope you're feeling all snug and cozy under your blanket of US exceptionalism.

And of course you are completely missing the point, no surprise there. None of these foreign democracies ever legalized torture. In cases where the truth is revealed the foreign public reacts with well deserved disgust and outrage. The fact that so many in the US seem to be numbed to the violence conducted in its name is what's most disturbing.

"waterboarding is not torture"

The only Iraq war cheerleader with an ounce of honor actually checked this for himself. Christopher Hitchens changed his tune afterwards.

Your opinion in the matter is completely irrelevant, the procedure just like mock executions is of course well outside any civilized standard.

That you happily put yourself there speaks for itself, and makes my point in highlighting how far the US has fallen.

Fortunately some of this moral cravenness is offset by exceptional Americans like Snowden and Greenwald. Over the long run I am optimistic that the US will regain its misplaced moral compass.

3 days ago
top

Double Take: Condoleezza Rice As Dropbox's Newest Board Member

quax Re:Force her out! (313 comments)

Oh please. As if there has never been terrorism before 9/11. The UK was in a genuine war with the IRA, Germany had the RAF, Italy the Red Brigades and France fought several nasty wars in North Africa after WW2.

Some of the nastier conflicts saw their share of atrocities, but there was never an attempt to redefine and legalize torture. Stooping low is bad, but losing all perspective is far worse.

4 days ago
top

Double Take: Condoleezza Rice As Dropbox's Newest Board Member

quax Re:Low even for Slashdot (313 comments)

As a German living in Canada I couldn't care less what party she belongs to.

Given her track record of lies and obfuscation, this is such bad PR that I can only conclude dropbox either completely does not understand its international customers, or doesn't care to lose them.

about a week ago
top

Double Take: Condoleezza Rice As Dropbox's Newest Board Member

quax Re:Force her out! (313 comments)

Waterboarding is regarded as torture by any other civilized country of the world.

Doesn't matter if you type you fingers bloody or stomp your feet to pretend otherwise. Just shows what America is made of these days ... not the right stuff.

about a week ago
top

Double Take: Condoleezza Rice As Dropbox's Newest Board Member

quax Re:The important stuff (313 comments)

You probably also don't die as a result.

about a week ago
top

P vs. NP Problem Linked To the Quantum Nature of the Universe

quax Cringeworthy (199 comments)

From the summary:

Physicists have always thought [Schrodinger's equation] can be used to describe everything in the universe

What physicists would that be?

The Schrodinger's equation is none-relativistic and doesn't ever capture QED.

Only quantum information dilettantes who never graduated beyond the unitary world of simple quantum systems could believe such a nonsense.

about two weeks ago
top

Stack Overflow Could Explain Toyota Vehicles' Unintended Acceleration

quax News like that make me miss my old cars (664 comments)

Drove a Mercedes 190D once. Alternator quit on a long distance drive. I only noticed because the radio stopped working.

(Car had a great mileage, too.)

about 2 months ago
top

German Chancellor Proposes European Communications Network

quax Better not let the UK participate then (197 comments)

As much as it pains me to observe this, but due to the 'special relationship' having the UK on board will mean that everything is tapped by the US anyhow.

about 2 months ago
top

How Blogs Are Changing the Scientific Discourse

quax Re:Blogs != scientific discussion (136 comments)

But isn't the fact that blogs open the dialog up, to include individuals outside the realm of academia, a decidedly new quality?

about 2 months ago
top

How Blogs Are Changing the Scientific Discourse

quax Re:it's always been that way (136 comments)

Very insightful comment. May I asked what field of science you're in?

about 2 months ago
top

Watch Bill Nye and Ken Ham Clash Over Creationism Live

quax It's a dirty job and somebody has to do it ... (593 comments)

... but I'd rather stick a needle in my eye than listen to that debate.

Anyhow, I am not done yet with reviewing the medieval debates about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

about 2 months ago
top

First Evidence That Google's Quantum Computer May Not Be Quantum After All

quax Re:Quantum Cash! (224 comments)

Other than the fact that paper's like this would have been peer reviewed, I am not aware of any review of their architecture. But this paper is certainly key, because it all comes down to the spin coupling in order to decide if true quantum annealing happens on the chip.

about 2 months ago
top

First Evidence That Google's Quantum Computer May Not Be Quantum After All

quax Re:It makes me feel better (224 comments)

Ups .. thanks for clearing that up ...

about 2 months ago
top

First Evidence That Google's Quantum Computer May Not Be Quantum After All

quax Re:Quantum Cash! (224 comments)

Only to a theoretical computer scientist would the difference between a modern Laptop and a marble-run *not* matter :-)

As mentioned in the other thread. Moore's law comes to an end for semiconductors. This machine doesn't use them and the integration density is still low.

Such implementation details may not matter to you, but I think it shouldn't be hard to see why they matter to the industry.

about 2 months ago

Submissions

top

How Blogs are Changing the Scientific Discourse

quax quax writes  |  about 2 months ago

quax (19371) writes "Mainstream media always follows the same kind of 'He said she said" template, that is why even climate change deniers get their say, although they are a tiny minority. The leading science journals on the other hand are expensive and behind pay-walls. But it turns out there are places on the web where you can follow science up close and personal: The many personal blogs written by scientists — and the conversation there is changing the very nature of scientific debate."
Link to Original Source
top

Google's Quantum Computer Cannot be Explained Classically

quax quax writes  |  about 2 months ago

quax (19371) writes "So writes the company that developed the machine on their blog. Admittedly, you would expect them to defend their architecture, but the founder of D-Wave, Geordie Rose, puts forward a compelling argument, that comes down to Occam's razor. The scientists who claim that the machine can be explained classically, as recently reported on slashdot, only base their model on the sub-set of data that they looked at in their research. But if you look at all the data amassed by D-Wave over time, only quantum annealing makes for a perfect fit.

They are not the only ones who argue that D-Wave's claims in this regard hold up. Independent research performed by Matthias Troyer et al. confirms that quantum annealing is the best model to describe the machines performance, but they don't see evidence for quantum speed-up yet. A recent video nicely summarizes their research findings."
top

Inside General Fusion

quax quax writes  |  about 4 months ago

quax (19371) writes "Slashdot first reported on the Canadian start-up company that attempts piston powered nuclear fusion back in 2009. This new blog post takes a look at where they are now, and give some additional behind the scene info. For instance, a massive experimental rig for magnetized target fusion in the US is currently underutilized, because ITER's increasing cost absorbs all the public fusion research funding. Yet, because this Shiva Star device is located in an Air Force base, security restrictions prevent any meaningful cooperation with a none US company. Even if US researchers would love to rent this out in order to advance the science of magnetized target fusion, this is a no go.

Is this just security paranoia, or should the US preferably not use experimental facilities rather than allowing foreign companies to conduct experiments with them?"
top

Is Science Destined to Follow a Hype Cycle?

quax quax writes  |  about 8 months ago

quax (19371) writes "The controversy to what extend Quantum Computing is over-hyped, has been supercharged with the recent success of D-Wave selling their version of a quantum computer. This caused a significant backlash from some researchers, who argue that the machine is not 'quantum' enough and doesn't conclusively demonstrate a speed-up over classical computing.

This kind of heated argument is part and parcel of the scientific discourse, yet often leads to abandonment cycles that see promising research avenues neglected, only to be rediscovered decades later. Is this inevitable? Simple human nature reasserting itself? Or is there a more rational way to determine where to focus research?"

Link to Original Source
top

VC Funded Fusion Start-Up Set to Demonstrate Break-Even Net Gain This Year

quax quax writes  |  about 10 months ago

quax (19371) writes "If the company General Fusion succeeds in demonstrating the viability of their approach, the international ITER project will be pretty late to the party. Surprisingly this company managed to stick tightly to their development schedule in developing their reactor for Magnetized Target Fusion. This approach has never been tried at this scale, and it will be the first time to demonstrate net energy gain equivalent in this manner (the equivalent meaning, that if the pure deuterium mix in the test was replaced with one containing tritium you would get more power out than you put in).

The next big question will be if this can become commercially viable. The mechanical stresses the reactor will have to withstand are huge, so demonstrating that this can actually run continuously will be no small feat.
   "

Link to Original Source
top

Major Quantum Information Technology Breakthroughs

quax quax writes  |  about a year ago

quax (19371) writes "Within the same week two major Quantum Information Technology milestones where announced: The Los Alamos National Labs unveiled that they've been operating a scalable quantum encrypted network for the last two years (link to original paper).

There have been commercial quantum encryption devices on the market for quite some time now, but these have been limited to point to point connections. Having a protocol that allows the seamless integration of quantum cryptography into the existing network stack raises this to an entirely different level.

Just days after this news came the announcement that the company D-Wave, that claims to ship the first quantum computing device, aced a test when their machine was put into direct comparison with conventional hardware. It wasn't even close. For the class of problems that the D-Wave machine is designed for, the next best algorithm on a regular CPU performed several thousand times worse."
top

A New, Untapped Physical Resource for Information Processing?

quax quax writes  |  1 year,8 days

quax (19371) writes "In the most influential textbook on the matter Michael Nielsen and Isaac Chuang wrote:
"Quantum Computing and Quantum Information Science has taught us to think physically about computation. (...) Indeed in the broadest terms we have learned that any physical theory, not just quantum mechanics, may be used as the basis for a theory of information processing and communication."
This is exactly what the Kish Cypher Encryption protocol is doing by exploiting thermodynamics in an unexpected fashion. Could this become an easier to implement alternative to Quantum Cryptography, providing unhackable networks?"

Link to Original Source
top

Physicists still confused over how to interpret Quantum Mechanics

quax quax writes  |  about a year ago

quax (19371) writes "Feynman famously quipped that "nobody understands" quantum mechanics. But after almost a century shouldn't there be at least some consensus on how to interpret this theory? Ever since the famous argument between Bohr and Einstein over the EPR paradox, conventional wisdom was that Bohr's Copenhagen Interpretation will carry the day, but when surveying 33 leading experts at a quantum foundation conference, less than half voted that way.

Is it time for yet another paradigm change?"

Link to Original Source
top

Is Quantum Computing a Pathological Science?

quax quax writes  |  about a year ago

quax (19371) writes "Science and engineering is not free of fads. Sometimes they start with a bang and end up vilified as pathological science just like cold fusion did. But could something seemingly as established as Quantum Computing fall into the same category?

Some physicists are seriously proposing exactly that. The author argues that the amount of publications on Quantum Computing has reached an unsustainable plateau and that the ratio of one experimental to thirty theoretical papers demonstrates how little this field is actually grounded in reality.

But what if the shoe is on the other foot? Could it be that these animosities are actually more a reflection on the state of modern physics?"

Link to Original Source
top

Who is afraid of the big bad Quantum Computer?

quax quax writes  |  about a year ago

quax (19371) writes "Whenever Quantum Computing is dragged out to get some mainstream exposure it is the same old story: If we finally get these powerful machines then the end of all encryption is here and the sky is falling.

This article makes the case that there is much more to Quantum Computing than that, and that all the hand-wringing is not only pre-mature but also rather silly. Current quantum computing devices cannot defeat our standard encryption yet, but are at a point where they can already be a valuable new computing resource. On the other hand when considering how modern cryptography works, and when taking into account the progress made on Quantum Cryptography, the often repeated threat from Quantum Computers to the privacy of a encrypted data appears to be completely overblown.

 "

Link to Original Source
top

Are Quantum Computers here to stay?

quax quax writes  |  about a year ago

quax (19371) writes "The first quantum computing devices have hit the market, while the juggernauts of the IT industry are still in research mode. So what is the difference between what you can buy now, and what IBM and Microsoft are researching? Turns out, unlike modern digital computers, the quantum computing field is far more diverse in terms of design and hardware approaches. This article attempts to sort this out and predicts a timeline for this nascent IT sector."
Link to Original Source
top

A New Methode to Solve Linear Equations

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "Solving linear equations is one of the most common mathematical problems, and it is a fairly easy one that everybody learns to work in school. Surprisingly, a new algorithm has been found that improves over established methods within the domain of finite fields.

This algorithm is poised to find widespread use in applications as diverse as cryptography and quantum error correction.

The article provides links to the original paper and illustrates the concept of finite fields."

Link to Original Source
top

How to get media attention for a start-up set to revolutionize IT?

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "The recent physics Noble price awards highlighted the prospect of quantum computing. Yet, in the media reports there was no mentioning of the only company that claims to ship the first quantum computing device. This is despite some recent impressive computational feats that were accomplished on its hardware and published in Nature. The company seems to do all the right things, so why do they get so little mainstream coverage?"
Link to Original Source
top

Accelerator Driven Treatment of Nuclear Waste

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "In the wake of the Fukushima disaster the nuclear industry again faces massive opposition. Germany even decided to abandon nuclear energy altogether and the future of the industry is under a cloud of uncertainty in Japan. But one thing seems to be here to stay for a very, very long time: The radioactive waste that has half-lives measured in thousands of years.

But there is a technology under development in Belgium that could change all this: A sub-critical reactor design, driven by a particle accelerator that can transmute the nuclear waste into something that goes away within about two hundred years.

Could this lead to a revival of the nuclear industry and the reprocessing of spend reactor fuel?"

Link to Original Source
top

Strong Words on Weak Quantum Measurement

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "Recently news made the round that the Heisenberg Uncertainty principle was supposedly violated. (Slashdot reported on it here).

The underlying papers are quite mundane. But all caveats get stripped out in the reporting until only the wrong sensational twist remains.

Heisenberg did at some point speculate that the uncertainty relationship may be due to the measurements disturbing the system that is probed, but this idea has long been relegated to the dust bin of science history. So Robert R. Tucci deservedly demolishes this class of weak measurement experiments."
top

Beyond Entanglement - Quantum Discord

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "Entanglement lies at the heart of quantum mechanics and irritated Einstein to no end who called it "spooky action at a distance".

More recently science learned how to use entanglement as an information processing and computing resource. For instance it was thought to be the foundational ingredient for inherently wiretap safe quantum cryptography.

Now a recent paper in Nature Physics showed that the underlying phenomenon of quantum teleportation can be achieved by using none-entangled separable states that only display a low degree of non-classical correlations.

These states are characterized by their Quantum Discord property. The latter may turn-out to be more important than entanglement for the young field of quantum computing.

Time to add a new term to your science vocabulary."

Link to Original Source
top

Germany's former first lady sues Google

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "Bettina Wulff faces an uphill battle for her reputation. Her husband had to resign as Germany's president due to corruption allegations and has many detractors. Apparently some of them started a character assassination campaign against his wife. At least that is, if you trust serious journalists who looked into the matter and stated that it is made up. Unfortunately though for Bettina Wulff, the rumors took off on the Internet. Now whenever you enter her name Google suggest the additional search terms "prostitute" and "escort". Google refuses to alter its search index.

What do you think, should Google be allowed to destroy somebody's reputation like this?"

Link to Original Source
top

Radioactive Decay Influenced by the Sun

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "In school you probably learned that the decay rate of radioactive matter is solely determined by the halftime specific to the element. There is no environmental factor that can somehow tweak this process. At least there shouldn’t be. Now a second study confirmed previous findings that the decay rate of some elements seems to be under the subtle and mysterious influence of the sun. As of now there is no theoretical explanation for this strange effect buried in the decay rate data."
Link to Original Source
top

The Unbearable Lightness of Quantum Mechanics

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "For almost a century, ever since Einstein published his theory of General Relativity, a truly unified theory has been evading physicists . After decades of efforts, String theory and other mainstream approaches (so far) failed to deliver. This article takes a look at why it is so hard to reconcile Einstein's masterpiece with Quantum Mechanics and why there's hope that newly proposed experiments may eventually rectify the situation."
Link to Original Source
top

Diamonds are a Qubit's Best Friend

quax quax writes  |  about a year and a half ago

quax (19371) writes "Diamonds are an incredibly versatile material. A recent slashdot stories report its use in medicine, another shows that exploiting is hardness can help to produce better phase change memory. Some synthetic diamonds are semi-conductors and could be made into chips that don’t require cooling. Nevertheless, diamonds never played an important role for computer technology. This may be about to change. Ironically it is this precious gem that could result in Quantum Computers cheap enough for the rest of us."
Link to Original Source

Journals

quax has no journal entries.

Slashdot Account

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Don't worry, we never post anything without your permission.

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>
Sign up for Slashdot Newsletters
Create a Slashdot Account

Loading...