×

Announcing: Slashdot Deals - Explore geek apps, games, gadgets and more. (what is this?)

Thank you!

We are sorry to see you leave - Beta is different and we value the time you took to try it out. Before you decide to go, please take a look at some value-adds for Beta and learn more about it. Thank you for reading Slashdot, and for making the site better!

Comments

top

MIT Removes Online Physics Lectures and Courses By Walter Lewin

slinches Re:Sexual Harassment shouldn't cost us knowledge (416 comments)

Deleting all of Cosby's TV shows and movies would still be wrong as they are a part of our cultural history.

No one is doing that though, there is a difference between no longer promoting something and erasing it from history.

Actually, there isn't in the case of copyrighted works. If the rights holder stops selling and promoting something without re-licensing it for public use, then it is dead and nobody else can legally acquire a copy. This is one of the reasons there should be a requirement in copyright law that the work must be made available or the holder loses their exclusive rights to it.

To stretch the Cosby link further, you might (quite reasonably) think things Cosby did in the past are funny and even have value beyond pure humour, as social commentary etc. If that were the case and you know someone who had been abused by Cosby, would you choose to put a Cosby video on for them and expect them to find it an enjoyable experience?

That is the situation MIT is in. They aren't just dealing with 'theoretical' students who might somehow be deprived of some value that only those videos can impart. They are dealing with real students actually effected by the situation at hand.

If you wouldn't knowingly ask someone you care about to be entertained by someone who had abused them, why would you expect MIT to ask someone to be educated by someone who harassed them?

I wouldn't ask them to watch something from their abuser, but that isn't what's happening here. No one is being forced to watch anything. They're not even being asked to. Worst case is if one of Cosby's victims happened across a rerun of his, they quickly change the channel. The MIT lectures are even less likely to be seen accidentally and the professor's name is clearly listed on it. Are you suggesting that the right thing to do is to eliminate every reference to a person just so that a few people who were hurt won't occasionally stumble across a reminder that their abuser exists? If so, where do you draw the line there? The MIT professor only violated sexual harassment rules and as far as I have seen isn't even charged with a crime. Is that really enough to warrant erasure of his work? What about a high school bully? Are they so tainted that they should never be allowed to participate in our culture again?

about a week ago
top

MIT Removes Online Physics Lectures and Courses By Walter Lewin

slinches Re:Just wondering... (416 comments)

The best thing MIT could do is release the lectures for free (i.e. remove a profit motive from themselves), eliminate their name being used in association with it, and step back. That's reasonable. Trashing the whole thing is silly.

Maybe there needs to be a creative commons license that expressly forbids attribution, just for this circumstance. I suggest calling it CC-CYA

about two weeks ago
top

MIT Removes Online Physics Lectures and Courses By Walter Lewin

slinches Re:Sexual Harassment shouldn't cost us knowledge (416 comments)

Nope, still no challenge there. Deleting all of Cosby's TV shows and movies would still be wrong as they are a part of our cultural history. If the content owners want to distance themselves from Cosby's now severely tarnished image, then they should make a public statement that they do not want any further association and then sell the rights to his work or release it to the public domain.

If the norm throughout time was to erase someone from history because they did something terrible once, we would never have been able to progress to the level where we could even have this discussion. Everything we do is built upon a foundation of knowledge provided by those that came before us and if we start pulling out the bricks which were laid by those we see as evil, the whole thing will come crashing down. We have a responsibility to keep growing and strengthening that foundation for future generations to build upon, which is far more important than a vain effort to erase the mistake of associating yourself with that evil person.

about two weeks ago
top

Website Peeps Into 73,000 Unsecured Security Cameras Via Default Passwords

slinches Re:People buy stuff without understanding is... (321 comments)

That's a valid option as well as long as you're aware of the consequences and that you're choosing it. Life is full of trade-offs. The real mistake is not understanding the choices you're making.

about a month and a half ago
top

Website Peeps Into 73,000 Unsecured Security Cameras Via Default Passwords

slinches Re:People buy stuff without understanding is... (321 comments)

There's an easy solution to that problem. Don't fix it and tell her why.

Seriously, if someone isn't willing to learn and use the most basic of computer hygiene practices, they will eventually fall prey to malware and will almost certainly lose data to hardware failure at some point. And if you're the administrator of the computer when that happens, it'll be your fault for not protecting them (at least in their eyes).

You could also try explaining it as a car analogy: e.g. "You wouldn't just hop in your car and start driving without learning the rules of the road, would you?"

about a month and a half ago
top

Ebola Nose Spray Vaccine Protects Monkeys

slinches Re:Technicalities (198 comments)

Wow, it's up to 200% effective!?!?!?!?!

about a month and a half ago
top

Verizon Injects Unique IDs Into HTTP Traffic

slinches Re:Is there a way to prevent this? (206 comments)

That's the problem with monopolies (natural or otherwise). Still, there is an option to sign up for just the phone plans without wireless data and use wired or satellite ISPs for internet access.

You could also go the route of circumventing the problem (using the methods others have already suggested) with a bit of added effort/cost, but in that case there's no disincentive to help persuade Verizon to stop the program.

about 2 months ago
top

Bill Gates: Piketty's Attack on Income Inequality Is Right

slinches Re:Let me get this right (839 comments)

How does inflation fund government services to the general populace?

Inflation allows the government to borrow at net interest rates near zero or lower. As long as inflation is higher than the interest rate on the loan, the interest costs are offset by paying the loan back in devalued currency.

about 2 months ago
top

Fuel Efficiency Numbers Overstate MPG More For Cars With Small Engines

slinches Re:I don't the big MPG/GPM deal (403 comments)

I haven't driven a car in the past 15 years that didn't have a "distance to empty" option on the dash.

And I haven't driven a vehicle in the last 15 years that has such a feature. But then all I've driven in that time is a basic light pickup and a Jeep. I know range features are available, but they're more common in higher end domestic or import passenger cars.

Anyway, MPG's a useless metric for figuring out whether you need to stop for gas, unless you also know how big your tank is. If you do, then you're doing the math in your head to duplicate the distance to empty calculation on your dash.

Why would someone not know how big their tank is? There should be a clear reminder of the size every time you fill up.

Finally, the portion of the population who routinely take drives with >150 miles between gas stations is tremendously small.

There are quite a lot of people who live in the western US and Canada, where this is true.

Not that my anecdotes best yours, it's just that there would need to be conclusive evidence that a change would be worth the expense incurred and the arguments for gpm style fuel efficiency ratings don't seem (to me) to be compelling enough to justify such an action.

about 2 months ago
top

Fuel Efficiency Numbers Overstate MPG More For Cars With Small Engines

slinches Re:I don't the big MPG/GPM deal (403 comments)

Fundamentally, we're not interested in how far we can go on X gallons of gas, we're interested in how much gas it will take us to drive to our destination. GPM lets us compare that directly, while MPG doesn't.

But that's only true when making a decision between different cars. It's far more common (at least it is where I live) to have to quickly calculate whether I need to stop for gas now or if I can make it to the next town that's ~150 miles away in the car I'm currently driving.

about 2 months ago
top

IBM Solar Concentrator Can Produce12kW/day, Clean Water, and AC

slinches Re:Cubic litres (268 comments)

It must be the higher dimensionality thing since he successfully converts that to 350 cubic gallons (imperial, no less) a bit further along.

Alternatively, the water produced by this process is cubic in shape which would make it difficult to use with traditional plumbing systems.

about 3 months ago
top

Wave Power Fails To Live Up To Promise

slinches Re:Golden opportunity missed... (198 comments)

Oh, darn. We must be on different wavelengths. Last I heard, they were doing swell.

I guess these sorts of things just ebb and flow with the economic tides.

about 3 months ago
top

Sci-Fi Authors and Scientists Predict an Optimistic Future

slinches I believe!! (191 comments)

This is inspiration incarnate. Now we can create any sort of wondrous future we desire and the main project heiroglyph page is all I needed to see for proof. It's marginally functional without javascript!!!!

about 3 months ago
top

Ask Slashdot: What Old Technology Can't You Give Up?

slinches Re:Model M Keyboard (635 comments)

In my limited experience, MX Browns are a good compromise. Still some tactile feedback without being obnoxiously loud.

Buckling springs and blues are enough to make neighbors in a cube farm go postal and aren't that much better.

about 4 months ago
top

Ask Slashdot: What Old Technology Can't You Give Up?

slinches Re:Cable Lacing (635 comments)

If you like cable lacing, you'd probably love lock wiring.

Even if it's horribly labor intensive, the end result sure looks nice.

about 4 months ago
top

Amazon Fire Phone Reviews: Solid But Overly Ambitious

slinches Re:How thrilling... (58 comments)

True, but Understanding of others' Ignorance also Brings Fear

Also, it's a Futurama reference.

about 5 months ago
top

Western US States Using Up Ground Water At an Alarming Rate

slinches Re:Lumping everyone together.... (377 comments)

I responded to a similar comment by an AC earlier, but allowing Arizona's share to go unused would be in addition to the amount agreed to go to Mexico.

about 5 months ago
top

Western US States Using Up Ground Water At an Alarming Rate

slinches Re:Lumping everyone together.... (377 comments)

This is an obvious troll, but to clarify, there's an agreement in place to ensure that a set amount of water will flow into Mexico. You can read more about it HERE. I was implying that if Arizona didn't use or sell its share that it would flow across the border in addition to what is guaranteed by law.

about 5 months ago
top

Western US States Using Up Ground Water At an Alarming Rate

slinches Re:Lumping everyone together.... (377 comments)

We shouldn't have 6 million people living in a desert that can barely naturally support 1/10 that many. And pumping several hundred thousand acre feet of water over a mountain range for Phoenix is a terrible waste of water, not to mention the water lost to evaporation in the process and the power used.

I get it, you don't like the Central Arizona Project, but without it what would Arizona do with it's share of the Colorado? I think it's better to deliver it to where it's needed (i.e. Phoenix) than sell it to southern California or let it flow into Mexico unused. The areas nearest the river are poor areas for development anyway.

about 5 months ago

Submissions

slinches hasn't submitted any stories.

Journals

slinches has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?