Welcome to the Slashdot Beta site -- learn more here. Use the link in the footer or click here to return to the Classic version of Slashdot.

Thank you!

Before you choose to head back to the Classic look of the site, we'd appreciate it if you share your thoughts on the Beta; your feedback is what drives our ongoing development.

Beta is different and we value you taking the time to try it out. Please take a look at the changes we've made in Beta and  learn more about it. Thanks for reading, and for making the site better!



Lectures Aren't Just Boring, They're Ineffective, Too, Study Finds

tamyrlin Far from junk science... (166 comments)

If you read the article in PNAS ( ) you can see that they consider the question of examination equivalence by only looking at previous studies that "were largely or solely limited to changes in the conduct of the regularly scheduled class or recitation sessions;" So based on what I have read in the paper I would classify this as very far from junk science.

about 4 months ago

Lectures Aren't Just Boring, They're Ineffective, Too, Study Finds

tamyrlin Re:I've heard slashdot is behind the times... (166 comments)

The article (available at ) is a meta-analysis of earlier studies. So this study can be seen as a validation of the earlier research rather than presenting something completely novel.

(One possible reason why lectures are still so common: It is a cheap teaching method that scales well with class size.)

about 4 months ago

Lectures Aren't Just Boring, They're Ineffective, Too, Study Finds

tamyrlin Anecdotal evidence suggests... (166 comments)

... that it is easier to take cheap shots at research if you only read the slashdot summary rather than the actual publication.

So to answer your concerns I tracked down the publication in PNAS:

To quote from the article:

The data we analyzed came from two types of studies: (i) randomized trials, where each student was randomly placed in a treatment; and (ii) quasirandom designs where students self-sorted into classes, blind to the treatment at the time of registering for the class

In other words, if I understand the article correctly, the authors only considered studies where active learning was contrasted with traditional lectures in the same course! Therefore it seems likely that active learning is a good idea, regardless of whether the topic is hard or easy. (By the way, active learning doesn't necessarily have to involve fun and games, although if a student, in general, doesn't think that learning is fun, perhaps he or she should consider doing something else...)

about 4 months ago

Come Try Out Slashdot's New Design (In Beta)

tamyrlin Re:Fluid Design... (1191 comments)

It is late here and I'm in a negative mood. However, the fact that at least one staff member seems to actually listen to the comments written here is a hopeful indication. (Also, the mock-ups on dropbox in the grandparent looks promising. I'll have to look into the Stylish plugin which I didn't know about before.)

about a year ago

Come Try Out Slashdot's New Design (In Beta)

tamyrlin Re:The decay of Slashdot (1191 comments)

Personally I'm very interested in the Discourse platform which is being created by some of the stackexchange people. I suspect that a website based on Discourse might become the new "slashdot" in the future.

Although I'm not volunteering to knock up a new slashdot based on discourse :)

about a year ago

Come Try Out Slashdot's New Design (In Beta)

tamyrlin Re:Oh F*CK That! (1191 comments)

I think the most damning thing about the new comment system is that I had to go back to the old version of the site to read through the comments in an efficient manner. (And I'm not talking about the fact that the "reply" button is not implemented yet...)

Also, the exact user id is mostly for bragging rights anyway, but it does give an indication as to whether the user is a long time user of slashdot or not. Although other indications such as the karma of the user might be more useful in most situations...

about a year ago

Come Try Out Slashdot's New Design (In Beta)

tamyrlin Re:When you buy a bigger desk (1191 comments)

I'm using A3 paper when appropriate and A4 paper when appropriate. However, if my printer suddenly starts to print A4 sized content (or even A5 sized content) on the A3 paper I actually wanted to print it to I'm getting mighty irritated.

about a year ago

Come Try Out Slashdot's New Design (In Beta)

tamyrlin Ouch. (1191 comments)

I don't want to sound too negative, so I'll limit myself to my major concerns:

* The current version has very clear boundaries between stories in the form of the green bar. (Same for (expanded) comments.) With the new design it is simply harder to find these boundaries.
* Why all the wasted space in this new design? If I want a narrow column I'll just resize my web browser. The old layout was good because it allowed me to quickly scan through a lot of stories to select the ones that interested me. Same with comments. With the new design I need to scroll quite a bit more before having seen all the content.
* Speaking of comments, what is going on with the comment system? I hope the limited comment functionality (for example, lack of folding, etc) is just due to the fact that this is a beta.

about a year ago

The Greatest Keyboard Shortcut Ever

tamyrlin In case of emergency: Grab the data from /dev/mem (506 comments)

What is even more annoying is when the webserver serves up an error page after you have just written a very long comment (or similar) hit "post". My solution (in Linux) is to simply dump /dev/mem to /tmp/memorydump and then search this file for keywords present in the recently written form. While this is not a perfect solution, it has certainly saved me a lot of extra work in a few situations. (Nowadays I mostly write longer entries in emacs and cut&paste everything into the form to avoid this kind of issues.)

If you are going to try this out, note that you'll need to do this immediately, before the memory has been overwritten by another process. (And you obviously need to be root to be able to access /dev/mem in most situations.)

1 year,28 days

Hackers Reveal Nasty New Car Attacks

tamyrlin This has already been done. (On another(?) car.) (390 comments)

There is at least one car model where researchers has been able to get access to the CAN bus and do all sorts of shenanigans through the following means:

  • * Specially crafted file on a CD inserted into the CD player
  • * Exploit weakness in the car bluetooth interface
  • * Exploit weakness in built in GSM modem

For the details, see (Pretty scary reading. In this case they are also able to disable the brakes and they are also able to engage the brakes on only one of the front wheels for all sorts of "fun"...)

about a year ago

Hijacking Airplanes With an Android Phone

tamyrlin Re:I call BS (131 comments)

The problem seems to be (if I understand the article correctly) that for example the FMS can be hacked (presumably by buffer overflows or similar exploits) and then used to take over other functionality.

This seems similar to how a malformed RDS packet sent via FM radio can disable the brakes on a certain car: (among other things).

Exactly how similar these attacks are are difficult to ascertain as the presentation leaves a lot to be guessed, although the net-security report on his talk gives some more details.

about a year and a half ago

Hijacking Airplanes With an Android Phone

tamyrlin This is even worse than car security (131 comments)

It seems that the aircraft industry is about as security conscious as the car industry. The following page at discusses how researchers were able to take almost complete control, including the breaks, but excluding the steering IIRC by for example the following attack vectors: Malware infested CD inserted into car stereo, malformed RDS package sent via FM radio, some sort of bluetooth hacking, etc. (Also the ODBC-II port of course, although that is cheating....)

At the time I read the lwn article and the associated papers I thought to myself that the car industry should learn security and stability from the aerospace industry. Unfortunately it now turns out that they seem to have done so :(

about a year and a half ago

Enlightenment Terminal Allows Video Playback, PDF Viewing

tamyrlin Re:Security implications do not look good (114 comments)

In theory, yes. In practice no, if you consider the fact that ls might very well be exploitable through malware infested files in this scenario. (I think all sysadmins shudder at the thought that merely listing the contents of a directory with malware in it could be dangerous...)

However, there are ways around this. IIRC chrome decodes images inside a seccomp jail, causing an exploit in the image decoder to be very hard to use for anything except showing a a naughty image and eating CPU time. (I don't know if the enlightenment guys are doing this or not, but I hope they are considering it at least.)

about a year and a half ago

Enlightenment Terminal Allows Video Playback, PDF Viewing

tamyrlin Security implications do not look good (114 comments)

The demo video they have look really cool and I like any idea that improves the usability of the terminal. I just hope that they have some strategies in place to minimize the security impact of adding a large amount of potentially vulnerable code to a critical service such as the terminal (e.g., using securecomp or other mechanisms to sandbox the potentially vulnerable code).

about a year and a half ago

Why Can't Intel Kill x86?

tamyrlin Re:It will (605 comments)

At least one x86 processor design has a special non-x86 programming mode. In the Datasheet for the VIA C3 you can find the following tidbit:

"When set to 1, the ALTINST bit in the FCR enables ex ecution of an alternate (not x86) instruction set. While setting this FCR bit is a privileged operation, ex ecuting the alternate instructions can be done from any protection level.

This alternate instruction set includes an extended set of integer, MMX, floating-point, and 3DNow! in- structions along with additional registers and so me more powerful instruction forms over the x86 instruction architecture. For example, in the alternat e instruction set, privileged functions can be used from any protection level, memory descriptor checki ng can be bypassed, and many x86 exceptions such as alignment check can be bypassed.

This alternate instruction set is intended for testing, debug, and special application usage. Accordingly, it is not documented for general usage. If you have a ju stified need for access to these instructions, contact your VIA representative. "

I have tried to find some details about this alternate instruction set but haven't been able to find anything unfortunately. (And I'm not so interested in this any longer as my remaining Via C3 machine is now only used for backups and does not require very high performance...) Anyway, I'm guessing that it didn't become very popular due to the fact that they kept the details secret.

about a year and a half ago

After A Year, Emacswiki Alternative Shutting Down

tamyrlin There are many reasons to use M-x shell (127 comments)

Because there is a nice integration between the other buffers and your terminals. For example, say that you want to run a few commands in the same directory that the file you are editing exists. In that case you just type M-x shell to start a shell in that directory. (Note that this also works if you are working with a file on another computer via ssh. Your shell will then automatically start over an ssh session.)

If you are running commands that outputs a lot of text in the terminal the search capability of emacs is really useful as well.

Another use case is the integration between macros, text buffers, and terminals. Consider a use case where you are editing an HTML file and want to ensure that all images referred to in IMG tags are available at a remote location. It is then easy to create a macro in emacs that finds all IMG tags, extract the file name and copy the file name to a suitable scp command that you can paste into the terminal window.

However, I must admit that I still have a few xterms open, but I find myself gravitating towards running shell commands in a shell buffer in emacs, especially when programming. Also, there are of course other ways to solve all of these issues (scripting, file redirection, etc), but for myself I usually find myself preferring to use emacs in most of these cases.

about a year and a half ago

Electrical Grid Hum Used To Time Locate Any Digital Recording

tamyrlin How hard would it be to actually do this yourself? (168 comments)

This is a really cool application. I wonder how hard it would be to write an application to do this yourself as a way of identifying for example when a certain TV broadcast was recorded.

Also, for those of you who are interested in what the phase noise looks like there is a nice article about this over at where the phase noise of the power grid is compared to a GPS clock.

about 2 years ago

Bruce Perens To Answer Your Questions

tamyrlin Re:Best Open Source hardware licenses? (78 comments)

I have been wondering about this myself. This situation is not really that well explored and I'd really like to see a license for HDL-like code with some high quality lawyering behind it.

One problem is that hardware such as ASICs are typically not protected by copyright. Instead it is protected by maskworks laws which are similar to, but not as strong as copyright. The intention is that ASIC-like hardware should be protected by patents. (Although I guess an exception would be made for ROMs where the layout itself would be protected by maskworks whereas the actual metal configuration of the ROM array would be protected by copyright.)

For FPGAs I have heard people claim that their lawyers consider the bitstream to fall under copyright law -> e.g., the GPL would be fully enforcable. Another interesting case in point is that SUN choose the GPLv3 as the license when releasing the source code for the Niagara processor. Personally I've used an MIT-style license when releasing open source hardware because I was more interested in getting the (fairly small) designs out there than to try to enforce the GPL license for something it wasn't really designed to protect.

Also note that the GNU FAQ has the following to say about hardware:

Any material that can be copyrighted can be licensed under the GPL. GPLv3 can also be used to license materials covered by other copyright-like laws, such as semiconductor masks. So, as an example, you can release a drawing of a physical object or circuit under the GPL.

In many situations, copyright does not cover making physical hardware from a drawing. In these situations, your license for the drawing simply can't exert any control over making or selling physical hardware, regardless of the license you use. When copyright does cover making hardware, for instance with IC masks, the GPL handles that case in a useful way.

about 2 years ago

Thanks For Reading: 15 Years of News For Nerds

tamyrlin Re:dayummm (229 comments)

Here is one old timer checking in. Although I'm more of a passive consumer of slashdot these days. Although this is not really slashdot's fault, I'm more of a passive consumer of mailing lists, discussion groups, usenet, etc these days as well. (Having a day job and a family does have a higher priority for me than participating in forum discussions these days.)

about 2 years ago

Multicore Chips As 'Mini-Internets'

tamyrlin Re:Yea cause packet transmissions (132 comments)

> MIT please get out of the dreams lab once in a while

Actually, no chip-designer wants to use a network-on-chip if they can avoid it due to the added complexity. However, for future SoC designs with hundred of modules it will simply not be efficient to have direct parallel links between every module on the chip. A network will in many cases therefore be the best trade-off between silicon area, bandwidth, and energy efficiency.

Also, note that a typical SoC used in for example a mobile phone already have significantly more eight cores (although most of these cores are not processors, they still require communication links of some sort). (Take the OMAP4470 as an example [1] - it has at least, two Cortex-A9, one IVA3 accelerator, powervr graphics, a signal processor, SDRAM controller, flash controller, MMC controller, HDMI output, SPI controllers, I2C controllers, SDIO controller, UART controller, USB controller, GPIO controller, etc). So if MIT is in a dream lab, the only thing they are doing is trying to come up with a way to handle the nightmare that future on-chip communication entails.

more than 2 years ago


tamyrlin hasn't submitted any stories.


tamyrlin has no journal entries.

Slashdot Login

Need an Account?

Forgot your password?

Submission Text Formatting Tips

We support a small subset of HTML, namely these tags:

  • b
  • i
  • p
  • br
  • a
  • ol
  • ul
  • li
  • dl
  • dt
  • dd
  • em
  • strong
  • tt
  • blockquote
  • div
  • quote
  • ecode

"ecode" can be used for code snippets, for example:

<ecode>    while(1) { do_something(); } </ecode>