Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Check out the new SourceForge HTML5 internet speed test! No Flash necessary and runs on all devices. Also, Slashdot's Facebook page has a chat bot now. Message it for stories and more. ×

Comment Re:Gender Binary (Score 1) 1026

It's a bit stronger than "psychologically dissatisfied" I'm afraid. But you'll be happy to know that the international standards of care for transgender patients require two mental health professionals and a general practitioner to have "bottom surgery".

I can fairly easily understand being dissatisfied with the results of GRS/transition. It's not necessarily going to gain you social acceptance, and if you really want to be female, there's still going to be a lot of things denied you. But I suppose the point that you might be able to clarify, were these people detransitioning because they no longer wanted to be female, or were they detransitioning because they no longer wanted to be a transgender female? Because I do think that we should probably draw a distinction between the two. At the least, I know a few transgirls who are pretty, but obviously transgender, and perfectly happy to be that as something good and complete in itself.

So I think the way I would describe being transgender would be something like, if you had a button to push that would give you your ideal body, that body would have opposite gender characteristics. There are a lot of ways that reality might not match that ideal, but it seems strange to me that the ideal would change. Body dysphoria is hell, straight up, and I really hope there aren't too many people unlucky enough to experience that from both sides. For me suicide would be pretty automatic at that point.

Comment Re:Libertarianism In Two Sentences (Score 1) 514

No, we don't disagree. Individual rights are important, and that's basically the core of libertarianism. Libertarianism is like a reducto ad absurdum of those principles, but I do think it's actually a good thing to have a bunch of mindless sociopaths championing their own self interest because, hey, maybe there could be some issues with arbitrary use of collective force. As a practical basis of a political system it's batshit, but as the polar opposite to collectivism it's at least a valid philosophy.

Comment Gender Binary (Score 1) 1026

Sorry about the gender thing. Transgender people are really biologically distinct. I think we're going to get to a point where we're past this idea that everybody has to be one thing or another. I mean, I'm never going to argue with any person who wants to consider themselves the opposite gender, but I'm not sure why you would want to embrace that as opposed to developing an identity as a transgender person. Yes, we get treated pretty crappy, but otherwise it's not like it's inherently bad. To be honest, it's actually pretty cool as long as you're not saddled with crippling mental issues from dealing with the gender binary.

The alternative to recognizing that mental gender is a separate biological process which occurs after the sex organs are developed is to tell people that their gender does not exist. This is resulting in mass suicides. If your position is that transgender persons deserve to die, well, I suppose that would be logically consistent. I'd very much hope that not to be the case, however.

Comment Re:Lab Measurement (Score 1) 320

Telling you to go measure something has nothing to do with faith. You lack an education. I'd be more than happy to explain to you in as much detail as you like the evidence and history of the science of Global Warming. I've read most of the original research papers, the IPCC, and any published contrarian works (Spencer, Curry, and that IRIS guy spring to mind).

Calling the opposition zealots works for everything but science. In science empirical evidence is the only thing that matters. If you are not arguing against science with measurement (i.e. more science) your argument is invalid. Empiricism is the opposite of faith.

Comment CC0 (Score 1) 63

Yes, copyright protection only exists for large corporations, and even at that it's still hardly workable. Since the "John Doe" subpoenas haven't found much favor in the courts it's hardly even worth trying to identify individuals. Personally, and speaking as a content creator, everything I do I CC0 because people are going to steal it if they want to, and I may as well benefit from any potentially wider distribution.

Comment Lab Measurement (Score 1) 320

Not to judge, but it is somewhat funny that you're presenting this as a "Gotcha!" If you would stop pretending your ignorance is just as good as anyone else's knowledge then this will suddenly become a real discussion.

So to answer your question, there are obviously things that happen on Earth which can't be easily replicated in a lab, but the problem is that the H2O-CO2 feedback ls so strong that we need a very large negative feedback to cancel it out. Some massive misunderstanding of the water cycle is pretty much all that would have saved us due to that, but as it happens we've looked at every known atmospheric phenomenon and ruled out any large negative feedbacks.

Global warming is the default, natural reaction of an increase of atmospheric carbon, and we've spent the last 121 years trying to disprove it. We actually thought we had disproved it right up until the mid-1950s. Unfortunately for us all, this really is settled science. What will happen as a result of AGW is a more open question, especially as this will depend on what we choose to do about it, but you really can prove AGW in your basement. Tyndall did it in 1859, you should be able to significantly improve on his results.

Comment Re:Use the tags, Luke (Score 1) 225

And the problem with that is, that on Chromium on Linux, if you double-click on the URL to highlight it, and then right-click to open in a new tab, then it appends 'Reply to this' with percent encoding to the end of the link, which does not result in a valid HTML document. Additionally, as I said, this is not a luddite forum. If you can't manage a minimal level of markup, kindly fuck off.

Comment Wikipedia, not Facebook (Score 1) 82

Or they can learn how to plant trees, purify water, and generate electricity. Do you know how I know that you've never lived without clean water and electricity? Because you seem to think that you can live without these things and not have that be a bigger priority than Facebook.

I did at one point live in some jungle shack that had a pathetic wifi signal, sometimes dropping to tens of bytes per second. It did have electricity of some sort, and as for water, well, there was definitely a tap, but whether you considered the output water was a matter of opinion. When you have shitty Internet, you make the most of it -- I downloaded programming documentation. Facebook would be a non-starter, it's just too bandwidth-heavy even if it were in some sense useful.

Comment Intolerance (Score 1) 126

You seem to be one of my fellow citizens, which means you're probably a pretty good person. Posting a message this results in nothing good, and I don't believe that you would say such a thing if we were in company together. I'm pretty concerned at this point that we're going to reach levels of partisanship that will result in civil war, and I don't think that's a thing any good citizen could desire. Please consider carefully what you write.

Comment Housework (Score 1) 202

As it happens, the US government collects statistics by gender of how much time is spent on which activities in the home. The relevant table is on page 9. I'll reproduce the relevant bits on housework here.

Hours per day, Average
Total: 1.84
Men: 1.43
Women: 2.23

Average percent engaged in the activity per day
Total: 76.4
Men: 67.0
Women: 85.2

Average hours per day for persons who engaged in the activity
Total: 2.41
Men: 2.13
Women: 2.61

I end up with the majority of the cooking and cleaning tasks; the girlfriend's ability to cook is pretty minimal. We're working on it. Anyway, for the average person it's not anything like a full-time job, but 2-3 hours per day, six days per week is definitely one of the larger components of human activity -- looks like the list goes sleeping, leisure, working, housework, eating.

Slashdot Top Deals

Recent investments will yield a slight profit.

Working...